💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
Orange County, Texas

According to county court documents the Successor Developer aquired all previously unsold and unconveyed lots within our subdivision from the Original Developer, in an amendment. Currently the Successor Developer has lost this to the bank. In the original 'Dedications and Restrictions' it mentions that the HOA is responsible for the common areas, however in the amendment nothing was mentioned about these said areas. At the end of the only amendment its says "Except as amended herein, the remaining provisions of the original Dedication and Restrictions shall remain in full force and effect, as therein provided."

There was never an HOA formed. There is another document "Maintenance Affidvit" that mentions the Successor Developer (a man and his son) are the sole members of the Architectural Control Committee, and "the duties of which are assigned to the Architectural Control Committee until the formation of the Homeowners Association". My assumtion is that until the HOA is formed, the Successor Developer is repsonsible for the common areas, however, now the bank owns it.

Here's the catch...

Hurricane Ike knocked down a good stretch of a brick fence/wall that is around the subdivision. So since the HOA was required to carry insurance on the common area, would the Successor Developer also have to, since the Affidavit said he was assigned the duties? Secondly, now that the bank owns the properties, would they now be responsible for carrying insurance on the common areas?

We saw someone many months ago measuring the area, and they said they were going to give a bid, but didn't say who to. Last summer there was someone mowing the grass in the common area and he said the bank hired him.

We have contacted the city to file a complaint, and they are trying to find out if the brick wall is required to be erect. I would love to know where to find that information.

NORMALLY in a case like this, when the bank owns a common area, are they required to carry insurance or do they have any responsibility to cleaning up the debris or erecting the wall like the HOA/Architectural Control Committee would have to do? Or for that fact, if a kid gets hurt in or around the down brick wall, who is responsible?

I'm not sure if the rules are different when a bank takes ownership. Lastly, the mess that Ike caused to the wall is hurting the value of our home, and is just unsightly.

Any thoughts would be fantastic!

JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
What is the opinion of your attorney?
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
I have a feeling there is no "your" - that would imply that there is an organized group.

Try to set up an appointment with the bank and find one person who can tell you what the bank's official stand is on taking care of the property. I would bet it is nothing. They are the middle man right now. Just a paper holder

Get in line. (you should see bank owned properties in Michigan. most properties look woefully neglected, especially in landscape and maintenance areas) They tend not to take care of properties unless they are really valuable.

Organize a group of concerned owners and get an attorney. You may be able to petition the court to establish an HOA with the purpose of protecting property values.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
JohnB26-
I do not have a real estate attorney. Unfortunately there are so few houses in the subdivision, and obviously fewer that are being occupied because of Ike's flood. Some people are still in the process of rebuilding. So with the compound of the recession and the natural disaster, I know everyone is stretched pretty thin already. And unfortunately, when push comes to shove, we just do not have any money for an attorney. That's why I'm posting here.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Neely,

If a bank owns the common areas then they are resp for everything associated with those common areas: i.e., maintenance, insurance, liability. Just as you are responsibile for maintaining the property you own, etc.

I would contact the bank to find out what their plans are with regard to rebuilding the wall.

Since an HOA was never formed, and a bank now owns the common areas, I would think you don't have to worry about paying assessments. However, you are still obligated to abide by the restrictions as outlined in your covenants. When there is no HOA to enforce the covenants, each property owner has the right to enforce in a court of law -- usually small claims or justice court. If you take a look at the deed to your property it should state: "subject to deed restrictions" or something to that effect. That means that the deed restrictions (covenants) "run with the land" and are in force for as long as you own the property. These deed restrictions will pass on to your successor heirs or to anyone you should sell the property to. This is what "covenants running with the land" means.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
SusanW1-
That's a good idea about the bank, only they are in Houston, some two hours from here. I think you are right about them JUST being a paper holder - and that's what I'm afraid of.

I hope the city can enforce something. I also wondered if perhaps it would be part of the developer's bankruptcy/foreclosure requirements or if FEMA would help.

I certainly wish I could get my hands on those papers!

I wondered that since the bank had someone mow the common area that they might be responsible, at some level. Then when the guy came to give a bid on replacing the wall, I was again hopeful. I'm pretty sure with it being brick it's in the excess of $50,000 to get this back to good.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
MaryA1 -
That's fantastic to hear - and I hope that's how it works!

I'll contact the bank and see what they have to say. I'm going to record the conversation too, just to be safe.

We, along with everyone else, indeed abide by the restrictions. We've even bought attachments to our lawn equipment to keep some of the common areas under control - it was worth it to us for it to look uniform.
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Neely - i know your intentions are good, but be careful taking care of common areas. It's not your property! The bank won't step up to maintenance if they think it's being taken care of.

SOMEONE is hiring these workers. Find out who requested the bid for the wall and who hired the lawn mower. That's the person/company you need to contact.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Neely,

You and your neighbors should keep in mind the fact that those "common areaa" are private property and each time you step on them to mow the lawn you are trespassing. Also, how can you ever expect the bank to do their job by maintaining these areas if you and your neighbors are doing it for them -- free of charge. I know you all are well-meaning, but I just do not think it's a good idea. Even if there was an HOA, the members would not have the authority to just take over the maint of a common area even if the BOD was not doing it.

Seriously think about making 2 phone calls; one to the bank and the other to city/co code compliance.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
SusanW1 & MaryA1 -

It was last summer when we mowed the common area, and before the 'bank' hired anyone to mow it. Once we saw someone maintaining it we didn't touch it, for that *exact* reason.

As I stated in my post, I've already made a phone call to the city's Code Enforcement Department, they have created a work order and the City Manager has to first find out:
(1) If it is required that the wall be erect
(2) If so, if the wall has to be the same as pre-strom conditions or if any type of barrier will do (i.e. wooden privacy fence).

However, they mentioned that since we had a natural distaster there are thousands of violations in our small city and it is a very long process. But they encouraged us to stay on top of it, and we will.

I have yet to find the right person to talk to at the bank. Since the bank is two hours away in Houston, it's not possibe for me to travel there without a definate appointment with someone. I assume they will pass the buck as long as they can.

As far as the guys who came out and measured for the bid last summer, I do remember them mentioning what road they were located on, within our city. I can drive by there and see if there are any fence companies - hopefully they will be willing to find out who made the request! Great idea. (The mower hasn't been seen since last summer, and we don't recall any company decals to contact him.)

My main question is:
-Now that the bank owns the properties, are they *normally* responsible for insuring the common areas that was originally required?
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Neely,

Whether or not they are "required" to have liability ins on the common areas, they are the owners and the liability is on them. If something happens and they want to pay a liability claim out-of-pocket instead of having insurance, that's their problem. Whether or not they are covered with liability ins would be the least of my worries. If you found they are not, what could you really do about it? IMO, you should just be concerned with getting them to maintain the area and rebuild the damaged wall. When I suggested you contact city/co code compliance, I was thinking about maint of the common areas not for rebuilding the wall.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
MaryA1-

That's probably more of what I'm getting at. Maybe not so much that they have to insure it, but if it's required that they maintain the grass, and rebuild the wall, especially the wall, since it is decreasing our property values. The main reason I ask about insurance is because it could have probably been claimed on flood insurance, rather than having to pay over $50,000 fix it.

The city won't cut the grass in the common areas, since it's private property. There are only 33 lots in the subdivsion, and about 1/2 have houses on them, and about 2/3rds of the houses are being occupied. To be honest, it's not a huge area. It would probably take maybe 30 minutes or so on a riding mower.

So in your experience (or knowledge)it's common that when a bank takes over property, they are responsible for this sort of thing?
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Neely,

Yes, if the bank is, indeed, the owner of record, then they are resp. for all maint on the property. My HOA has had several situations like this and when we have informed the bank that we will do the work and bill them they acquiesed and did it themselves.

When I suggested contacting the city I was thinking they would issue a violation notice. Here where I live, when a property owner violates a code ordinance the city will come out, inspect and issue a violation notice giving the prop owner a certain length of time to comply. I was not suggesting the city come out and cut the grass.
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
Although, where I live, if the homeowner continues to ignore the grass, then after they issue so many $$$ in fines, they will then cut the grass and add the cost to the liens (the fines are liens).
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
MaryA1-

Oh I see, I see I see. I think the city will issue a violation notice, when we finally get to that point, at the VERY least, for the bank to get the grass mowed. The bad thing is, is that all the brick from the wall is in the grass, so they only mow where the bricks aren't...obviously. But I need to think "Baby steps, baby steps."

Another great idea about telling the bank we'll do it and bill them - that might put a fire under their a**!

I did contact the fencing company about the bid. The lady said she knew exactly what I was talking about, but her husband wasn't interested in it, so they didn't give a bid, therefor do not have any record of it. Ugh. I'd just like to get who requested the bid so I can contact them - since it's the same. I wonder what the department at the bank handles this sort of stuff? For example, the city department is Code Enforcement, or a variation of...any ideas what department of a bank would be called?
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
MicheleD-

I'll keep that in mind!
DwightT (Idaho)
Posts: 664
Posted:
We have several homes in our neighborhood that have been abandoned and are in various stages of foreclosure/bankruptcy/probate. Most of them don't have any power, so the timers for the irrigation system are non-functional.

Our CC&Rs explicitly allow us to maintain the landscaping if the property owner fails to, so a couple of weeks ago we sent a certified notice to all of the owners of record (including the banks) that we intend to install battery-operated timers on the irrigation valves and have somebody start mowing the yards with all costs to be assessed to the property.

Amazingly over the last few days all the bank-owned properties have had crews out to take care of the landscaping. Guess our message was received.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
DwightT-

That's encouraging! Did you address it to a certain department at the bank? As I mentioned in a previous post, the county records show the bank is in Houston, which is two hours from here, and it's a natioanlly known bank - I'm worried it would be put aside without it being sent to someone or something in particular to the issues.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Newly, If you have not done an on line search on the Court House Court Records and looked for your development name, the name of the first developer, the name of his company and likewise the name of the second developer and company names, and connect the bank to any of these people including your association name.

From what I can see this all has to be included not only in the property records of the country records office, and planning county office, but also the records of any court proceeding and from what has happened there is a paper trail a mile wide somewhere. In the situation the owners of your development are in, they need information. Apparently, all these various proceedings are not being circulated.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
RobertR1-

From what I have found so far, there was an original developer, then it was sold to a 2nd developer, and then the bank stepped in - which is who has it now. However, there is nothing yet other than liens against the 2nd owner. Looks like his troubles began in 2006 (before we bought the house) and the bank stepped in as of late last year. I have pretty much researched this myself, no one else in the neighborhood had a clue what was going on.

The only thing I found about court proceedings was an 'active case' list on May 1, 2010, on a pdf that had many names of the plantiffs and defendants. The name of the 2nd developer (the defendant) and the plantiff "ALL INDUSTRIES INC" <---which led to nothing, was all that was listed. It doesn't post again until June 1, 2010.

On top of that there was never an association formed. But I'm not stopping here - I'll keep digging as time allows to find as much info (ammo) as possible.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Newly,
I have no idea what kind of area you live in, but if it is typical Americana, someone in your town knows the answers or how to get I find courts records to be confusing and property records also, however the people that work in these offices are generally helpful. Usually when you can't find everything you know is somewhere, it is because we don't have the day to day knowledge of how this stuff is handled. Our planning office is a wealth of knowledge because they have the master plans and any change in ownership usually goes through them simple because there is always changes that have to be made when large properties change hands.
But keep digging and maybe look locally for a company that can provide a complete property search and court records search. I bet it is all there, when they go to court to make these property changes, you can bet the lawyers have done just what you want to do.
DwightT (Idaho)
Posts: 664
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By NeelyW1 on 05/14/2010 5:50 PM
DwightT-

That's encouraging! Did you address it to a certain department at the bank? As I mentioned in a previous post, the county records show the bank is in Houston, which is two hours from here, and it's a natioanlly known bank - I'm worried it would be put aside without it being sent to someone or something in particular to the issues.

We just did a title search and sent it to the owner of record. Frankly, we didn't really expect any response and we where just sending out the notice as a legal formality. But if it got them to actually start taking care of the property, then all the better.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Newly,
Your: "
On top of that there was never an association formed."
*****************************************

Have you checked your state business filings. The original developer would have to file a Business License (I assume). There seem to be huge gaps in the continuity of your records, I am sure you know this, but on what authority is your association operating under.

I don't know what else you can do except to keep digging and don't put your neck out.

It would appear you are a fair distance from where you can start shooting at someone.
NeelyW1 (Texas)
Posts: 11
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By RobertR1 on 05/15/2010 8:56 AM
Newly,
Your: "
On top of that there was never an association formed."
*****************************************

Have you checked your state business filings. The original developer would have to file a Business License (I assume). There seem to be huge gaps in the continuity of your records, I am sure you know this, but on what authority is your association operating under.

I don't know what else you can do except to keep digging and don't put your neck out.

It would appear you are a fair distance from where you can start shooting at someone.

There is no authority, no association - nothing. Just lil ole me trying to find out if the bank is repsonsible for erecting the wall and cutting the grass...and then if they are - make them do it.

I'm going to keep digging for sure! I think it's worth it, since it's affecting our property value.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here