💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

FrankH1 (Florida)
Posts: 14
Posted:
Can an officer of the board, president or treasurer, place a lien on a property after the property manager sends a 45 day notice and gets no response?
The law firm that is recommended by our new PM says we cannot do it because it would be considered a practice of law without a license.
Our problem is that about 50 properties out of 164 are deliquent including 16 of the developers properties. The amount owed is about $50,000.
In round numbers it would cost us about $500 to put a lien on each property according to the lawyer. About $50,000. Any helpful advice would be greatly appreciated.
Frank
JaniceM1 (Georgia)
Posts: 27
Posted:
It depends on your community statis. In Georgia we have HOAs and POAs. I hope this information helps and you have this option in Florida (scroll down to read about the POA).
If not you need to ask your attorney to gather a collectability report. This will show you each person's ability to pay, if they have the funds in accounts or if they already have other liens/ bankrupt reports on their credit. It will save you from spending the money to collect by placing a lien when you will never see the money from that owner.
Also, to have 2/3 of your accounts collected in this economy, you are doing pretty good for it to be April. Some maybe waiting for their tax returns.
Our dues are due Feb.1 and we always get a good portion paid prior to the pools opening Memorial Day weekend (or their access is closed). We are at 75% collection and we have 1673 homes.
Godd Luck. Janice M.

Some of the benefits of the POA include, but are not limited to the following:
1. Automatic Statutory Liens
After submitting to the POA, the association will no longer be required to file liens at the county courthouse for unpaid assessments or other charges. Instead, the POA creates an automatic statutory lien against a delinquent owner’s lot for any sums owed to the association. The POA provides that the declaration of covenants itself serves as notice that there is a lien on every lot in the community for any unpaid assessment or other charges. As a result, closing attorneys, title examiners, purchasers or owners must contact the association for a statement of any amounts owed to the association prior to concluding a sale or refinance of the lot, or risk the existence of a lien. If the association is not paid out of the proceeds of the sale or refinance, the lien continues against the lot and will generally have priority over subsequent liens and mortgages.
An additional tremendous benefit of the POA’s automatic lien is that it protects the association even if the association’s records have incorrect or misspelled owner names. Recorded liens are only effective if filed under the correct owner names. If the association’s records have an owner’s name misspelled the recorded lien may be ineffective. The POA makes the lien effective, even if you have incorrect or no information about an owner.
2. Buyers and Sellers are Jointly and Severally Liable to Pay Assessments
The POA includes another provision that generally strengthens an association’s assessment collection powers. The POA makes buyers and sellers jointly and severally liable for all unpaid assessments. This means that, if the automatic statutory lien is not paid at the closing, the association can proceed against the new owner, who will be personally liable for all amounts owed prior to the closing.
3. Tenants are Obligated to Comply With Association Regulations
The POA also clarifies that all owners and tenants must comply with all the provisions of the declaration of covenants and the association’s rules and regulations.
4. Fines and Suspension of Privileges
The POA gives the association a statutory power to assess fines against violators and to suspend the common area use rights of violators, if specified in the declaration. Fines constitute a lien against the violator’s lot, and the ability to fine significantly strengthens the association’s powers to enforce the covenants and the rules and regulations.
5. Late Fees and Interest
Submission to the POA allows the association to charge a late fee of the greater of $10.00 or ten percent (10%) of the amount due, and interest at a rate of ten percent (10%) per annum on unpaid assessments and charges, if specified in the declaration.
6. Recovery of Attorney’s Fees from Owners
The POA authorizes the recovery of the association’s costs of collection of the delinquent assessments, including reasonable attorney’s fees actually incurred. This provision is extremely helpful with judges who otherwise are reluctant to grant the association is attorneys’ fees, when it sues delinquent or violating owners.
7. Perpetual Duration
Prior to 1993, Georgia law generally provided that covenants expire after twenty years. The Georgia statute providing for the expiration of covenants, O.C.G.A. Section 44-5-60(d), was amended in 1993 to permit covenants to automatically renew, but the Georgia courts have held that covenants in communities that were recorded prior to 1994 do not receive the benefit of the new 1994 law. The POA expressly provides that O.C.G.A. Section 44-5-60(d) does not apply to the covenants submitted to the POA. Accordingly, covenants submitted to the POA have perpetual duration.
LaramieC (Alabama)
Posts: 7
Posted:
In Alabama, anyone can place a lien, you do not need an attorney to do so. We place liens twice a year on delinquent accounts. We have a lien form and lien release form that was drawn up by our legal department and once an acocunt falls 60 days delinquent, I (the Manager) place the lien myself and release them myself. It costs us $8.50 to record and $8.50 to release. By the time, my administrative costs are figured in, my mileage and certified mail fees it costs the HOA about $100, which is recouped in the fee that must be paid before the lien can be released.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Would you mind sharing that form so all of us could benefit? Times are tight, it would be great if we could all share legal forms and other tips. Thanks in advance.
RogerB (Colorado)
Posts: 5,067
Posted:
Steve,
Attached are forms we use for filing Notice of Lien and Release of Lien. In our state the Declaration often allows assessing the homeowner for lien filing fees. We charge $100 up front when the Notice of Lien is filed with no charge when the Release of Lien is filed ($50/filing). We also give written notice to the owner at least 30 days prior to filing the lien.
📎 Attachments (2):

⏸ Downloads temporarily unavailable

📝142115937571.doc(24 KB)
📝142115951654.doc(24 KB)
RogerB (Colorado)
Posts: 5,067
Posted:
Corrected lien forms are attached. In making the forms generic I made a typing error on each.
📎 Attachments (2):

⏸ Downloads temporarily unavailable

📝1421112765271.doc(24 KB)
📝1421112765254.doc(24 KB)
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
We can file and release liens ourselves in Kentucky as well.

I believe it's $11.50 plus between $7 to $9 for notary fees (depending on where you get the document notarized) to both file and then release, for a total of $41 if you take the higher notary fee.

We file liens after the third delinquency notice, which includes an intent to file lien statement and gives the date lien filing will commence.

EllenS1 (Florida)
Posts: 1,148
Posted:
Frank,

Unless the person filing the lien is being paid for his/her services it is not practicing law.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Thanks Roger!

Ellen, good point. Sounds like a scare tactic from the law firm into getting some easy money from the HOA. $500 to process a sheet of paper and a little bit of time. Smart law firm.

The HOA can easily file that paperwork themselves.
JohnK3 (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 967
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By EllenS1 on 04/21/2009 9:33 AM
Frank,

Unless the person filing the lien is being paid for his/her services it is not practicing law.

I'll disagree, Ellen. It's not money; it's about someone advising a 3rd party or doing something for a 3rd party that represents having knowledge or skills associated with what lawyers typicaly do that civilians typically can't. Having said that, filing a lien ain't rocket science, so in this case, I'd say it's not practicing.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
I'll disagree, Ellen.

Ellen was just trying to make a point. It would be up to a judge if that person was unlawfully practicing law or not, and we don't know the whole story of what this person does on a daily basis. But based on the post, if it's just the simple task of filing the proper paperwork to place a lien on a property, anyone can do that. Its just business as usual.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Frank,

This should be checked out with an attorney. AZ is one of the a few states in the country with no statute prohibiting the unauthorized practice of law. In 2003 the AZ Supreme Court issued a ruling defining the "practice of law". As a result of this ruling only a "legal document preparer" or an attorney can prepare any document for filing in any court. So, legally speaking, if you were in AZ the answer would be "NO" your assn Pres or Treas cannot perform this function unless they are a certified legal document preparer or an attorney.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
if you were in AZ the answer would be "NO" your assn Pres or Treas cannot perform this function

I just googled the AZ law and from what I read it only applies to a management company preparing it for the association and not the association doing the paperwork on its own. So if the officers in the association did it, it would be fine?

EllenS1 (Florida)
Posts: 1,148
Posted:
John,

I doubt you have knowedge of Florida laws which are specific. Unless a person is paid for giving advice or filing paperwork they are not considered to be practicing law. I've been in the legal field for about 30 years during which I have given my best advice and obtaining a divorce for my cleaning lady without receiving any compensation and I was not practicing law. Building contractors and sub-contractors can file liens all the time and do without the help of an attorney.
EllenS1 (Florida)
Posts: 1,148
Posted:
John,

An afterthought..anyone can go to small claims court without an attorney which I have done myself.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
Building contractors and sub-contractors can file liens all the time and do without the help of an attorney.

Yup.
AnneH2 (Florida)
Posts: 82
Posted:
Ellen-

Thanks for the FL info. You make a good point about trades people filing liens independently.

I am looking forward to responses from others in FL. And Donna-
JohnK3 (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 967
Posted:
Ellen,

You are correct that I am not knowledgable about most law specific to FL (except that I know FL, as with most popular retirement states, does not offer reciprocity to attorneys licensed in other juristictions). And of course, one can always choose to rep themselves, in SCC and other courts. But if what you say is true...

Hypothetical. Jack has been charged with murder and has hired a licensed attorney for all the pre-trial work. But once the trial begins, Jack replaces his attorney with Jill, his girlfriend, whose knowledge of law is based on watching police procedurals (Law and Order, etc.) on television, who will not be paid for srvices and not be required to file any documents.

I find it hard to believe that would be allowed in FL or anywhere else. Though according to you, it would?

Please advise.

And again, I don't see filing a lien as practice for the reasons I noted earlier.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Steve,

Management companys were mentioned because many HOAs contract with them and they do the filing. However, the rule does apply to everyone. Whoever goes to the county recorder's office to record a document should be either a legal document preparer or an attorney. This is a rule of the AZ Supreme Court but it has not been enacted into law. I don't know that the Co Recorder's Office asks for identification from the person wanting to record a doc.
PeterB1 (Florida)
Posts: 257
Posted:
Frank,

I just looked up the atty bills for liens we place. In round numbers, we paid half of what you are being quoted. We are here in Florida.

Perhaps you could call a few local law firms.

peter
AnneH2 (Florida)
Posts: 82
Posted:
Your post is so off topic.

Ellen isn't saying that a lay person can represent a defendant in a court of law. She is saying that filling out simple legal forms for no compensation is not considered practising law without a license in Florida.
EllenS1 (Florida)
Posts: 1,148
Posted:
John, Your hypothetical involves criminal law and not what we were discussing. I know very little about criminal law but have seen judges allow defendants to represent themselves in criminal cases. I would say the judge would rule on that.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
Whoever goes to the county recorder's office to record a document should be either a legal document preparer or an attorney. This is a rule of the AZ Supreme Court but it has not been enacted into law.

Should be? Not a law?

Sounds like anyone could file the documents, but they prefer it to be someone licensed.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
The Supreme Court has jurisdiction over all courts and as such adopted this rule which is a section of the AZ Code of Judicial Administration. It was stated in one of the documents I have outlining this rule that it was not known how the Supreme Court intended to enforce the new rule which was effective 7/1/03. I couldn't find any statutes applying to "legal document preparer".
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Everyone,
In Florida, anyone can file a lien on a property. Forms are on line for downloading. To file, it can cost $15.00 and up, depending on how complicated it is. Proper notification is required before anything can be filed. Lawyers like to scare people into thinking that they need to hire them but if you have a simple lien, anyone can fill out the form. But many times, the need to have legal representation becomes nescessary if the lien is complicated by multiple ownership, bankrupcy and other issues relating to a delinquent property.
AnneH2 (Florida)
Posts: 82
Posted:
Does anyone have a good 45-day notice that goes out in advance of filing the lien? I've seen two that I didn't think really got the message across to the owner. While they may have technically contained all the information required for legal notice, they have too much soft language hta blurs the message, IMO.
JohnM3 (Florida)
Posts: 288
Posted:
Dear Henry

I am the treas of a community of 307 homes of which 18 are empty foreclosed on by various banks. We employ a Firm named ------ out of pembroke Pines there system is very simple we the bod set the amount ( 2 months dues ) for what amount before being referred to the firm. Prior to do the collection we issue a 30 final warning if no funds are forthcoming the case goes to the firm period they send an additional 30 day warning its req by Fl Law no I am not a lawyer but with 17 empty homes my monies coming in versus going out have matched to the dollar for the past 15 years. Our system is failure proof. After the 30 day final warning from the firm the firm adds a 1500 dollars to the amount owed and that becomes the new debt. We do this for 2 reasons

1. Get our money out of others pockets

2. Prevent members from doing this constantly the electric company does not wait to get paid the water bill does not wait no pay the water is shut off. BODs have to understand you are running a business not some social club. If the BOD can pay on time the entire community can pay on time its a question of teaching people that hoas assessments are not a thing to be played with or used as a part of a balancing act. Its a question of moving it up the chain of things to get paid period. It is the BODs job yes I said job to educate and keep the community informed of things via a community web site of what is going on and enforcing its rules but with a huge amount of common sense. By the way if the firm is not successful in getting our money back they have a flat fee of $300 per case all other costs are put on the person creating the debt not the hoa. If it is a drag race to foreclose on a account we always let the bank win. Then we wait 30 days for the bank to pay then we send them a 30 day notice and we lien the home while they own it that way all homes have a certain amount of money coming back to the HOA. The BOD realizes that once a house is foreclosed the Bank automatically becomes a member of the HOA and it must act,perform on the same plane as the physical members are expected to do period.

people have to learn there own rules and put them into effect period. Pay people to do things but follow up and if they don't work written notice twice then fire them period.............In closing Henry realize something each state has its own laws and only the laws of the state where you live are used in your state alone... good luck
LindaD4 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Frank:

I am Treasurer of our HOA in South Carolina. We do not need to have an atty. file liens. I file them myself. Here it costs $5.00 to place and $5.00 to remove. I can e-mail the form we use if you would like. Here, we need 2 witnesses and notary to file the paperwork.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here