💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

AprilY (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 2
Posted:
we bought our house in 2005 signed a contract w the seller and on the contract for an hoa says n/a , we refinanced our house in july of 2007 and in march of 2009 we received a letter stating we are being sued for not payn our hoa fees us and 72 other home owners in our development our court date is coming up. we have since contacted the person in chg of the hoa lettn her know we were never told any such thing and she has sent us a package w mtg minutes of mtgs that we were never informed of never the less she has 3 different property addresses listed for me and my husband. she states she has mailed things to us on several occassions which we never received . the question is how can she say she sent us anything when she dont even know our correct address. this hoa was supposably started in 1993 but no one started paying fees till 2007, is that legal? there is no street lights no sidewalks, and what the call a common area is a big field w no park or anything or a drainage area with huge drains a child could fit inside. the township takes care of our snow removal and we pay for our own trash removal. the hoa does nothing for anyone of us, and we didnt receive anything about bylaws til we requested it after we received notification we were being sued for something we were never informed of that existed. how can she hold us responsible for fees that we were never informed of? we read our deed and the only thing its says about an hoa is if one exists its paid by our escrow account. what can we do about this?
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Look at your property description. It should state the legal address of your home, including the name of the commuity or subdivision you live in. Then go to your county clerk and ask questions.

I can't imagine your selling agent did not metion this elephant in the kitchen!!
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
First, and please don't take this the wrong way, but I don't do so well when people don't use punctuation. Or capitalization.

I have no idea where some of your sentences end and where others begin, except for a handful of question marks scattered about.

Again, sorry to be critical, but it really really really makes trying to understand your issue somewhat problematic when we have to decipher sentence structures.

Now, about your concerns.

The first place you probably need to check is with your county clerk's office, in the Deed Room.

You should go down there in person and have a clerk help you locate your deed and your development. The clerk can pull any documents such as deed restrictions or covenants that may have been filed with your deed.

Yes, you probably should have received them from your seller, but apparently you didn't.

Second, try to do a search at your Secretary of State's website. MOST Secretaries of State's websites have a section that lists business incorporated in your state.

If you have a Homeowners Association, it's very likely it was incorporated and the filing documents would be in the SoS's records.

We have homeowners in our development for whom we have several contact addresses as well, so I'm not surprised if the woman who sent you your package of meeting minutes says she has several addresses for you, as well.

And, quite frankly, I also hear from people who insist they have "never" received anything from us until they get either a notice of lien pending or a notice from our attorney.

Believe it or not, lots of people throw away HOA materials thinking they are "junk."

Anyway, we, also, have no amenities, no do we provide snow removal or trash pickup. We do, however, still require assessments to be paid since that chunk of common area, including the retention basin, still needs to be maintained AND insurance needs to be provided for it. We DO have street lights we pay for however. Also, WE (the HOA) does not "maintain" the sidewalks in our development, either. That is up to each resident, per our Deed Restrictions.

At any rate, do some of these searches and see what sort of materials you find.

In the meantime, how much are your assessments? According to this HOA person? I don't mean the total amount now due and owing, I mean annually, how much are(were) you supposed to be paying?

MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SusanW1 on 04/05/2009 6:03 PM
Look at your property description. It should state the legal address of your home, including the name of the commuity or subdivision you live in. Then go to your county clerk and ask questions.

I can't imagine your selling agent did not metion this elephant in the kitchen!!

It's actually more common than one would think that agents don't mention HOAs.

They claim that the buyer should know, though, for the life of me, I have yet to figure out how.

But in Kentucky there's a sneaky little paper buyers sign along with all the other gazillion shoved quickly in front of their faces that is a waiver that absolves the title attorney from providing information on any (in)significant things like HOAs.

I didn't even realize this until we were purchasing a property for my dad. He wanted to move back to Kentucky from Colorado and would not do it unless we could find him a home that was NOT in an HOA (yes, my dad is the one who was close friends with THAT Jan in Colorado).

We found one (a little ranch) and during closing that little piece of paper popped up. I inquired about it and was told it was a standard form.

I wouldn't finish the closing until I got confirmation that the house, indeed, was NOT within an HOA.

I wasn't going to let the attorney off the hook for not doing his job. Plus, it seemed pretty sneaky to me.

My husband DID mention "how many people would just sign or initial that and not realize what they just agreed to?"

SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Even though you didnt know, sounds like your still part of an HOA. You should have pulled the deed at the town hall before you bought the place.

To go a step further, I would have found the owners name and pulled their mortgage from county records when they bought the place to see what documents were included in the sale and what else is under thier name at the county. Like lawsuits regarding the property, etc.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
AprilY,
To answer your question about the legality of the situation you find yourselve in; I can't see an answer to that from here. We don't know. But time passes and it looks like you are going to find out.
What should you do now? As advised by the posters here, get your act together and get informed. You have a lot of catching up to do, and it appears you need either a lawyer or some evidence of your contention. If other folks are involved in this, get them together and present a united front, with an articulate spokesperson. Don't go to court and have each individual trying to speak.
Have your spokesman with the help of those concerned write out their position and their issues. A couple of people should go to this HOA and make your presentation before the Board, not the Management Co.
Write a letter asking to be heard before the full Board, document your good intentions to resolve this issue BEFORE going to court. It is also important that you all stay in a group and apparently your position is you were never told there was an HOA. You have to convince a judge of this, and you have to convince him/her your collective efforts are above Board and not just a bunch of personal agendas.
That is what I think...........IMHO
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
April,

If, in fact, a mandatory HOA exists, the fact that you were not informed is meaningless. You are still subject to the CCRs (deed restrictions) and payment of assessments. Take a look at your title insurance, as it should make mention of an HOA. Also take a look at your warranty deed, which should also mention whether or not there are deed restrictions. If there are no deed restrictions then there cannot be an HOA, because the reason for an HOA is to enforce the deed restrictions. Aside from meeting minutes, what else was in the package you received from the woman who wrote the letter? Perhaps a copy of the CCRs, bylaws, articles of incorporation??? These are the documents you need to have; if you don't then I suggest you send a letter back to that woman and ask for them.

Get together with the other 72 h/o's who are being sued and join forces. It sounds really fishy that so many are being sued for delinquent assessments; perhaps they all have the same complaints as you, namely no knowledge of an HOA and the requirement to pay assessments.
JohnB7 (South Carolina)
Posts: 176
Posted:
"........and on the contract for an hoa says n/a......."

Depending on what you signed (agreed to) at closing, your only recourse would be against the seller (assuming you have a warranty deed and not a quit-claim deed).

In a capitallistic society it is 'Let the buyer beware'.

In any event you will need COMPETANT (expensive) legal advice.

By purchasing into a HOA you have waived many constitutional rights!

The HOA has not wronged you, the seller has (perhaps with the HOA's tacit neglect).

Just pay the bill and move on............................................
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
John,

Your advice to "Just pay the bill and move on" may be sound advice IF April knew for a fact a mandatory HOA exists. But, since she does not, paying and moving on is not the proper action to take. April needs to know whether or not a mandatory HOA exists. I won't even elaborate on all the different scenarios that could be going on here, but suffice it to say that nothing would surprise me! If I were April I would be asking for copies of all the gov docs as a first step. Once she is sure of the presence of a mandatory HOA and the requirement to pay assessments, then she can "just pay the bill and move on. . ."

Don't you think it strange that 72 other h/o's are being sued for delinquent assessments????
JohnB7 (South Carolina)
Posts: 176
Posted:
"In any event you will need COMPETANT (expensive) legal advice."

MaryA1,
What part of that statement is unclear?
John B.
GlenL (Ohio)
Posts: 5,491
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By JohnB7 on 04/06/2009 3:59 PM
"In any event you will need COMPETANT (expensive) legal advice."

MaryA1,
What part of that statement is unclear?
John B.

Uh, the word COMPETANT it's spelled COMPETENT



Seriously John your advice is spot on; pay the assessment and then fight it. Whether she is in the right or not serious consequences can occur while waiting to be "proved" right including a ding on your credit when the HOA files a lien. Mark paid under protest on the check and then take care of it; if she's right then she can take the HOA to small claims to recover the money.

Studies show that 5 out of 4 people have problems with fractions
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

April,

I find your story amazing. Who had their head buried? You closed in 2005 and unless it was a cash deal, was the finance institution asleep? You refinanced in 2007 and it was not discovered that the HOA existed then?
The your deed says that If there is a a HOA, then the dues will ba paid out of escrow?

Get the official documents from someone, HOA, Lawyer or the County Clerk. Read them, find out your responsibilities, financial and otherwise. Get paid up if you are part of a HOA. Ignorance of any of this is no excuse to be delinquent. You as the homeowner should know what you are a part of in your community.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Glen,

John did not say "pay the assessment and then fight it"; he said "just pay the bill and move on. . ." -- big difference. April can't just bury her head in the sand she needs to find out if an HOA really does exist, get copies of the gov docs and go from there. Does putting the statement "paid under protest" really have a legal bearing?
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By JohnB7 on 04/06/2009 3:59 PM
"In any event you will need COMPETANT (expensive) legal advice."

MaryA1,
What part of that statement is unclear?
John B.

John,

Aside from the obvious misspelled word, frankly, nothing! However, I don't know that April needs legal advice. All she really needs to do is obtain copies of the gov docs to determine whether or not an HOA exists. If it does, and it's a mandatory HOA, more than likely she needs to pay up. The exception I take to your advice is that she should just pay and move on.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Mary and John,
I agree with you both. For obvious reasons.
Both are probably accurate.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here