💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

JonD1
Posts: 2,350
Posted:
I was wondering what impact the slowing economy or recession if we are in fact in one has had or is having on your property.

As a Board member we all need to look forward and anticipate the negative effects of the slowing real estate market, increasing taxes, employment slowdown, and their effect on operating a condominium/HOA.

Have you had any negative effects on your property?
Has the number of foreclosures in your property increased?
Are unit owners remaining current on their common charges/dues?

With the rising costs of upkeep and the possible loss of income this is a situation we should be aware of for the future.

Here in NY working to keep the common charges at a resonable rate seems to be more difficult with each year. Costs are increasing for the operation of the property, the financial burden on the unit owners outisde their residence has increased and this leaves the Board caught in the middle to maintain the property and supply services without putting undue costs onto the unit owners.

Will this get better in the near future? I would think not.

I would be interested in hearing your thoughts..............

BradP (Kansas)
Posts: 2,640
Posted:
Jon:

Some interesting thought provoking questions. They say foreclosures are up astronomically across the county, that obviously is going to affect a lot of HOA's because a home in foreclosure isn't paying dues. Also with a recession people may lose jobs or have hours cut so others may struggle to pay bills.

The HOA has a tough balancing act they need to do, on one hand they need money to operate, on the other hand they need to be sensitive to their owners who are probably struggling to pay rising costs as it is. Is this the time for an increase in dues? Or is this the time where HOA boards cinch up the belts, maybe forgo a project or two that isn't deemed a necessity until the economy is better.
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:

Have you had any negative effects on your property? --- No

Has the number of foreclosures in your property increased? --- No. In fact, had fewer the last 2 years than the 2 previous years.

Are unit owners remaining current on their common charges/dues? About the same rate as usual -- and the same residents as usual. In other words, same people are delinquent year after year. Seems they would figure out that it's costing them 2 to 3 times more to let it slide than to just pay it on time.
RichS (Florida)
Posts: 13
Posted:
Yes to all your questions. I am on the board for 168 unit townhome community. We currently have 11 homes in forclosure. In the last several months I have watched as more and more fallbehind or are totally delinquent in motnly assessments. Our outstandings have risen by another $10,000. we are looking for ways to collect and still be aware of the current problems for people, but we still have financial obligations. i wish your community luck.
RobertR1 (South Carolina)
Posts: 5,164
Posted:
Does a fallling economy hurt your association.?
Sure it does, even if you have no foreclosures or no increases in the # of forecloures. Talk to people on the street or in your neighborhood. Gas prices don't discriminate, nor food prices or doctor bill's, and look how education costs are rising. If the BOD's are not ajusting their sights and reviewing their economic needs, they should be and should have done this last year. But, if your board it like mind it takes them months to gear up for their yearly budget and once that is discussed to death and some picture formed, it would take an act of god to make them tweak their program to meet the daily changes occuring. Why some board seem so cumbersome and why some seem to glide along is a mystery to me. After a regime is 10 years old I think they develop some kind of gene pattern that gets past from one board to the next. Most association BOD's are incubators for the next BOD and they follow their genetic transformation acquired from the previous Board. Good or bad, they will likely operate like their predassessors. I have been waiting a lot of year to go to a board meeting and have the President stand up and announce, "The annual meeting this year will be about how the Board has decided to spend the whole year going over our programs and infastructure, and come up with ways to cut our budget 20%." You would have to dial 911 to revive all the owners that fainted. This is all relevant to economics and how most of us as a family unit slip in and out of economic pressures, adjusting on the fly, so to speak. But our boards never seem to get beyond a Long Range Plan, and then finding ways and reasons to change the initial projections, which can take hours and hours of discussions and meetings to start the process, which is outdated when it is proposed to the owners and full of pencil changes.
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
Our local paper just had a story today on how the housing issues have affected our area.

We are (somewhat) fortunate in that, while we are seeing some flat market conditions, on the whole our area is faring much better than others around the country.

There's no prediction on whether it will last for us, but the local "experts" seem to think as this environment evolves that we'll shake out okay.

Our market has always had "moderate" home prices, compared to most other areas, so we'll just hope that keeps us from experiencing some of the more painful results.
JonD1
Posts: 2,350
Posted:
MicheleD:

Just where is your area?

We are located in the northern NY metro area.

We have 132 condo units and I have served on the Board for 20+ years.

With the rising costs of maintaining a property that gets older each year.
The rising costs of water/sewer.
Insurance coverage.
Legal
Landscaping
Snow removal
management
The property has increases as far as the eye can see.

Now add in the higher expenses to the unit owners:
Add in the rising food costs.
Gas prices heading towards $4.
Employment concerns for many folks I speak with.
Seems he have a double edged sword with which the HOA/BOM needs to deal with.

Can you raise the CC to where they need to be and should be?
Assessments are the unit owners able to handle this? Or do you run the risk of pushing people faster into financial problems?
What areas do you cut back on to make up any difference?
What areas are on the must do list and what areas can be put off.

At our last Board meeting the MC told us he has seen a rise in the number of unit owners falling behind in CC payments on other area properties. If this trend continues this could affect the budgets of many HOA/Condo properties.

Throw in the lost revenue PLUS the legal fees of going after the unit owners for payment.

We had our reserve funds in CDs to generate additional income to be added to the budget now with the interest rates going down that added income will be cut by at least 1/2.

Serving as Board President for the last 5 years I have suggested very strongly to the Board members that we need to make decisions based on the financial health of our property even more then in the past. We must pick and choose carefully where we use the funds provided by the unit owners. But in general terms it would seem to me our job will be getting more difficult going down the road.

In my area if you speak to most people for more then 2 minutes you will soon hear about how the economy is affecting them or someone close to them and not in a good way. ( This requires of course you have your ears open.) As Board/HOA members we need to deal with the consequneces not only in our personal lives but in the lives of our property owners.

But then that is why we get the BIG bucks......

Good luck to you all.......
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Our HOA consists of 250 homes. We have 11 either vacant or in foreclosure. We have about $18,000 in overdue assessments. YES, the economy is hurting us! Michigan is really hurting . . . (anyone want to buy a home in a nice subdivision with lake access?)
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
My "area" is central Kentucky.

We have 300 single-family stand-alone homes.

We have 2 homes in foreclosure.

The same 2 homes that started a foreclosure last year, got caught up, now are back in foreclosure again. Both are going through nasty divorces.

We have 10 homes in collection status (no liens filed yet) and 8 with liens (of which 2 are the ones in foreclosure).

We actually had more liens 4 years ago (13 liens). Of the 10 homes turned over for collection, only 2 are "new" (in other words, these are roughly the same 8 people who we have to send to collections almost every year. For some wacky reason, they don't pay until they get additional fees tacked on. Go figure. Why one would prefer to pay $275 versus $150 is beyond me.)

BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
you can't fix stupid. i one knew several families that would routinely write a check for milk and bread, KNOWING it would bounce.

They bought $6 worth of stuff, knowing they would eventually pay another $15 or $20 for the bad check.

go figure. pretty expensive dues, pretty expensive bread.
HaroldS (Arizona)
Posts: 906
Posted:
I've noticed more yard sales in our area than we've ever had. Some by people who have never had a yard sale in 11 years living here.
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
Maybe they just have a lot of accumulated junk to sell after 11 years!!

We always see a lot of yard sales in the spring, all over our county, I mean. Our neighborhood doesn't have many. I think there have been like 4 in all the years I've lived here!

Every now and then one resident or another will talk about an HOA yard sale, but it never gets organized.

I hate yard sales. My husband, however, loves them.
BradP (Kansas)
Posts: 2,640
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By BrianB on 04/20/2008 5:46 PM
you can't fix stupid. i one knew several families that would routinely write a check for milk and bread, KNOWING it would bounce.

They bought $6 worth of stuff, knowing they would eventually pay another $15 or $20 for the bad check.

go figure. pretty expensive dues, pretty expensive bread.

Perhaps they were backed into a corner and didn't have credit or cash and needed that stuff, knowing it would buy them a couple of weeks to get money. People do crazy things in desperate times. Around here car title loans and paycheck loans are huge, you would think people would realize they are getting screwed but most of them are desperate and don't see a solution.
SheliaH (Indiana)
Posts: 6,964
Posted:
Indiana has been a state with a HUGE foreclosure rate for several years now, but it seems the number of delinquencies is fairly steady (although it's still too high for my taste). We've wrestled with some owners almost as long as I've lived in this community (I joined the board about a year after moving in) and some of them are in bankruptcy, so we're pretty much at the court's mercy.

We've given homeowners the option of paying online, automatic deductions, even weekly or bi-weekly, if that keeps them current, and we trying to push more people to enter into payment plans, as it's easier (and hopefully cheaper) than sending yet another case to our attorney. We also have liens all over the place and this fall, we'll have to make several decisions on who's going to be foreclosed on.

Meanwhile, we've tried to bundle as many services as possible with our vendors in exchange for a two or three year service agreeement with no increases. We've also had to reduce the number of days our pool is open during the summer - these days it's pretty Thursday - Sunday

If it is not right do not do it; if it is not true do not say it. Marcus Aurelius
HaroldS (Arizona)
Posts: 906
Posted:
Our Arizona Republic had an interesting article yesterday on what lenders call "jingle mail" - owners who are simply mailing their home keys to the lenders. These are owners who bought at the height of the market and now owe more than the home is worth. "These typically are people who can afford their mortgage but don't want to pay on a loan that is more than their house is worth. They'll live with the stigma or credit ding from a foreclosure just to get out from under their loan."
One example cited was a mother and daughter who bought a home in 2005, putting nothing down, with a loan that let them pay less than they owed, and now their loan is $200,000 more that the house is worth. They can easily afford the payments, but choose not to.
We have a vacant house across the street from us whose owners did just that. Only they had refinanced to the hilt when the market was up and now found they were paying on a mortgage much higher than the worth. They are now renting some investor's house for less money and are happy as a lark.
MaryA1 (Arizona)
Posts: 7,043
Posted:
Was speaking to my HOA pres. the other day and he told me of a house in our HOA that is being sold "in pieces" by the owner. The house is being foreclosed and the owner is filing for bankruptcy. He's selling off anything he can to make some $$$. He has sold all the cabinets inside the house and the garage doors. A neighbor told the Pres. he is going to sell the tiles off the roof! There is nothing the HOA can do about this. They can't demand he put the house back to it's original condition because he'll just ignore any violation letters and won't pay any fines -- he's going bankrupt! I wonder what the mortgage co. will do when they find out what he's doing.

Has anyone ever heard of this????
BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
Mary, yes, that sometimes happens: either the foreclosee strips the house for money, or spite. Lenders are getting wise to it, but there isn't always much they can do ( it takes time, money, effort, caring, a program, etc.).

Sad part is, the new "owner" isn't likely to invest much to fix it up for resale, and will likely sell it "as is" to someone at a huge loss in value. Then, there is not much guarantee that the new new owner will fix it up to standards either.

BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By BradP on 04/20/2008 7:37 PM
Posted By BrianB on 04/20/2008 5:46 PM
you can't fix stupid. i one knew several families that would routinely write a check for milk and bread, KNOWING it would bounce.

They bought $6 worth of stuff, knowing they would eventually pay another $15 or $20 for the bad check.

go figure. pretty expensive dues, pretty expensive bread.


Perhaps they were backed into a corner and didn't have credit or cash and needed that stuff, knowing it would buy them a couple of weeks to get money. People do crazy things in desperate times. Around here car title loans and paycheck loans are huge, you would think people would realize they are getting screwed but most of them are desperate and don't see a solution.

I can't say how backed into a corner they were. They still had plenty of money to buy beer and cigarettes, fast food lunches at work, etc.. I have little pity or sympathy for people who whine about being broke over a six pack of beer.
SidneyP (Florida)
Posts: 302
Posted:
and a cigarette hanging our t of their mouth and a pack in their pocket...right on Brian

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here