💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I recently moved to a small community of 6 units. I was on the Board of my last community and immediantly saw a need here for leadership and a HOA overhaul! They had one meeting last year and it was not even an Annual Meeting, just a "List of Concerns." They think everyone is a Board Member and everyone should be able to vote on everything!!! We do have a Treasurer and I am the acting President. We are required to have 3 Board members but there are only two of us right now, which, according to the Bylaws, is enough to make decisions. I have an Annual Meeting planned for next month. The Treasurer and I met with and hired a manager that I had worked with from my last community, as we desperately needed someone to help straighten everything out. Now this sleepy little community has woken up and is up in arms that we hired a manager! Hense my question... According to what I can disern from the Decs it is a decision of the Board to hire a manager. Is this not true?! Also, what decisions are to be presented to the owners to make and what decisions are made independently by the Board? It is my understanding that the owners elect the Board members and approve the Budget. Owners can participate in discussions regarding other decisions but ultimately the Board members are the decision makers. Any clarification would be greatly appreciated!
NoelleC (California)
Posts: 42
Posted:
WHy in the world would they be upset that you hired a manager? I say congrats. You and the other board member are volunteers, and by now way should do anything with out a managment comp. in place, other wise you better ask who else is going to serve to help with calls, ledgers, violations notices ect.

I say have a MC!
BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
one reason i can see to NOT hire a MC is that the cost has to be divided by 6. An MC for 600 units, even 60 units, might be doable, but to divide the "monthly service fees" by 6 might likely mean a huge increase in dues. I know the MC we once hired had a $1500/month minimum fee, plus expenses. That's a lot of money for 6 people to pay.

As for what the board should do versus members: the board should run the daily/monthly operations of the business. they can make decisions to hire, fire, get into contracts with vendors, set the budget, pay bills, engage insurances, speak to city officials, etc. The board approves business requests (or denies), helps define/interpret and enforce the CC&Rs, send notices, collects monies, etc.. The owners typically vote on major changes to the rules, and for new board members.

there should be a bit more definition of the duties in your by-laws.
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
Any and All powers should be in writing - in the bylaws or other governing documents. It may not specifically say that the Board hires an MC, but is given powers to enter into contracts for the good of the association.

As president, you should be working to have a full and complete Board.
JoeK1 (Michigan)
Posts: 37
Posted:
There are few moments as exciting -- and these days, as perilous -- as taking over the Board of Director President’s job at a small condo association or home owner association. But once you are in place, what exactly do you do? Here is a practical guide to help you navigate through many issues and turbulent waters that you are likely to encounter. Visit www.********.com and viwe the Contents section. It will give you tons of information on what you should be doing, when you should do it.

Good Luck
JoeK
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
The manager that I work with did a great job with the 16 units in my last community. We were self-managed for several years with the idea that a small community like ours didn't need a MC. I changed my mind after we decided to hire one! We risk a lawsuit with this Association in it's current condition which is much more costly divided between 6 people!! The fee for the manager is 75.00 mo. Incredibly reasonable, I think!

Thanks for clarification on the duties.
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Thanks everyone for your encouragement and information! Much appreciated!

Linda
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
For a 6 unit HOA, what is the management company doing that the Board could not? Just curious . . .
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
I would just surmise a guess to that: building an "arm's length" distance between neighbors. By that I mean, the property management company gives the board a "face" for the good-cop-bad-cop routine, especially given the limited number of neighbors and the greater possibility that they are or might be "friends." So if the PM sends a violation notice, it's one-step removed from "Joe, who is my neighbor, sending me a wrist slap."

For $75 a month, I would take them up on it!
RobertG (Arizona)
Posts: 505
Posted:
Just out of curiosity, you said you and another board member hired a manager. When did you do that? Sounds like you did it without any type of meeting. Even if there aren't any open meeting laws, doesn't that start the members wondering what else you are doing without their knowledge?
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
The MC takes care of the bills, collects the HOA pmts, does our monthly financial reports, budget, attends our meetings, takes minutes, handles owner complaints and violations, finds contractors and gets bids. When you are small it is a big advantage to have a management company on your side as contractors many times won't give you the time of day if you are a small community. It helps to be part of a larger "management family." This manager manages a lot of smaller communities and is very familiar with what we need to remain in compliance. She already saved us a small bundle by getting another bid for our insurance through a company she works with. As for our community, we are all of working age. Two of our owners travel for their jobs. One owner lives out of state and one has so many violations we can't possibly trust him to be on the Board. It's just pretty slim pickings when there are only 6 owners! Just feel it is a great advantage to have the MC, at least initially, until we are back in compliance. I'm planning on her being our manager for the long haul though! It's not that the Board cannot do these things, it's that we work and have other obligations that do not allow the time or resources to manage the HOA effectively.
HaroldS (Arizona)
Posts: 906
Posted:
Also curious how you became "acting president"? You said they've only had one meeting last year, which wasn't an annual meeting. Was there an actual annual meeting since then where you were elected president? And a budget approved?
I can't imagine what this MC can do in an hour or two per month (about all $75 will buy) that your members can't do. Even at $75 per month, that's $150 a year per unit that you've committed the members to. Your board may very well have the authority to issue contracts, but did you get other quotes? And what percent increase is that in respect to previous dues? Does your documents or the state regulate the allowed percentage of increasing dues without needing member approval? There's a lot to your post that's confusing.

BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
Robert... Can't speak for this case, but my guess is that with only 6 owners, and you can't fill three seats on the board, the "other" four owners aren't really all that concered with what the two who are running the board are doing.

IMFHOA, we had 40 units, and I couldn't fill a three person board, and it was all apathy and "hey, the guys running it seem to be doing fine. My dues are being raised, what do I care?"

Apathy rears it's ugly head.
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Exactly!!!! The price is a bargain just based on that!
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
We did call a "special meeting" of the Board to make this decision. I followed this with a note to our owners informing them of the decision. We will finalize our decision and sign a contract at our Annual meeting next month.
LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Our President resigned in September. The Board (of one!) decided that I would be "acting President" until our Annual meeting in April.

What I have failed to mention is that I was on the Board of my last community for 7 years. I became the President of that community after an owner decided to sue us, the President at the time left because she felt threatened and sold her place. Board members bailed and I was left at the top. We settled the lawsuit, went to "Board Member Boot Camp" offered by HindmanSanchez law firm, totally redid our governing documents, developed Rules and Regs that had never been done. Few other owners wanted to involve themselves with the HOA, so year after year it was the same people on the Board, as many HOA's are familiar with! Honestly, I'm just tired!!!! I moved here hoping I would not have to be on the Board, but it's just too screwed up and it's my money they are screwing with! I'm not willing to straighten out another HOA! $150.00/yr. IS worth it to me. We may not need to up our dues as the manager found substantial savings with another insurance company. This is an administrative expense that we will work into our budget which will need approval at the Annual meeting.

Sorry to be confusing!
MicheleD (Kentucky)
Posts: 4,491
Posted:
Not confusing at all.

Best of luck to you and congratulations on having helped out your former HOA.
SusanW1 (Michigan)
Posts: 5,202
Posted:
I agree with Michele (in the sub-conscious)reason why a MC was hired)

And I think it's wise to bring in a 3rd party when things get too intense.

Good luck. Hope things settle down for all involved.
PaulM (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 1,347
Posted:
LindaC10: Since you are a community of only 6-units/6-owners, and you are hearing some negative response to your decision on hiring a Prop. Mgr., I would suggest you invite the Mgr. to your annual meeting next month. It is well for the entire membership to understand the role & duties this person will be assuming on behalf of the 6-association owners.

It may offset some concerns and negativity further down the road. It may even work out that once the Prop. Mgr. gets things in order the Board may not see the need for their services and can manage 6-owners themselves. It is important to sign the contract annually, so as not to lock yourself in for a lengthy period with no clause to terminate should the need arise.

You may find that, once things calm down and all is working as well as can be expected, you may want to negotiate the fee for services next year because of a need for fewer responsibilities for the Mgr. to assume.

LindaC10 (Colorado)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Thanks Paul. Yes, the manager is planning on attending the Annual Meeting. I understand the owners concerns, as I was reluctant to hire a manager when we were considering one for my last small community. I was pleasantly surprised, however, once we did! It was so worth it!!!

We've already talked to the manager regarding fewer responsibilities in the future and talked about a lesser fee, so she is well aware of that and willing to work with us. Our Decs will only allow us to sign contracts not longer then one year so that's not a problem.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here