💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I have been in quarantine and then an ice storm hit. Our neighborhood has been iced in since Monday. Basically all the roads until today have been deemed impassible and/or closed. We live in the south which treats their roads entirely differently than the north or even TN. Long story but we don't have salt except for bridges and overpasses. The south doesn't have a need for stockpiles of salt/sand as we usually have only 2 snow events a year. Plows are limited as well. They are expensive. Most cities here may have only 2 in their fleet. (If that).

This isn't about all of that. Just setting the background of the situation. Of course if you live in a neighborhood on secondary roads, your not going to see a plow, salt, or any road assistance. We don't really have many companies that service snow removal. It's more like "Joe Bob" has a truck and put a plow on the end of it. Now going to sell that to anyone who will pay them.

As you can guess it.., We had some people who decided they want the HOA to pay for ice removal. We then had some "Joe Bobs" in the neighborhood saying they would do it. (You can see where this is going...). Our Management company is closed due to the weather. I spoke up and stated "If you want the HOA to pay for it, then you will be asked if your licensed and insured". Well you can just imagine the clutching of the pearls moment that caused!

Little miss "Karen Joe Bob" chimed in. She was like "We can do it ourselves. We will do it for free". Even better proposition! Yeah! I told them that need to call the MC first. Ask them if you can do it. My bet is they are going to ask if you are licensed and insured. Her response? "I will do it for free and plow your mother on the house". She didn't like that pointed out "legalities" when she wanted out to get Taco Bell. My response? "Thank you. My mother died after suffering from cancer. I do not want unprofessional putting my neighborhood at risk."

Maybe it's the COVID and Cabin Fever speaking... but one doesn't simply hook up a plow to their front fender and drive it through a HOA. Plus did I mention it was ICE!!! One of the cities actually decided to plow their streets. You could watch in horror as all they did was make it a black ice nightmare. Plowing ice is a bad thing. Especially if your not treating it with Salt and temps are below 20 degrees. It all just refroze solid within minutes. They stopped. Can't convince these people though...

Had to vent... Thanks!

Former HOA President
SheliaH (Indiana)
Posts: 6,964
Posted:
Hee! It's clear these folks think snow's no biggie. Someone should remind them they're in Alabama, not states like Michigan, Illinois, or Indiana (where the northwest part of the state is getting it hard) and other locations north of the Mason-Dixie Line. As you said, you can get in a bad way if your truck slips on ice and lands in a ditch.

I'm sure these folks can surf the web and find people who've tried driving through this stuff and tge police and/or fire department had to rescue them. Tell them to have a look and then get back to you with this foolishness if they still want to try.

If it is not right do not do it; if it is not true do not say it. Marcus Aurelius
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
There are people from the north that live here who do not understand. I am from the north myself. So, I understand Northern weather and the clearing of snow/ice. It is a completely different story when it comes to the south. People up north always say "Southerners don't know how to drive in the snow". That is completely FALSE. We do not have "Snow". We have ICE! No one can drive in ice.

It's funny as every year you get these people from up North who come down here. Their first winter they are "Winter Karens" about how we clear off roads. Don't do this, don't do that... We can't drive... They are ALWAYS the first people I see in a ditch or drive around to avoid. I know they are the first ones who is going to wreck the rest of us.

One winter we had boss from Chicago. We got 10 inches of snow. By the time he got to work that night, he was apologizing to ALL of us about how "Southerner's can't drive in snow". He learned his lesson that day. Changed his tune since.

Mind you that I have worked mission essential jobs for over 20 years. I had to drive in the worst of it. Trying to tell these people to NOT plow ICE because Mother Nature is a better melter is driving me bonkers!!! Good thing I have been locked up in my house for over a week!

Former HOA President
LetA (Nevada)
Posts: 2,679
Posted:
As someone who drove a plow truck on the side for a friend to make a little side cash, you just don't
drop everything and plow a property you don't have a contract with and you can't plow ice.

You can definitely spread salt if you have a salt spreader or spread by hand, but not all independent plow owners have a salt
spreader and only a few of the big gun landscapers have them.
DeanJ
Posts: 1,786
Posted:
You have to be licensed in Alabama to spread salt or plow snow?
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Yes when you hire a contractor to do the work as a responsible people do.

Former HOA President
WendyM5 (North Carolina)
Posts: 1,522
Posted:
if you logged off facebook you would save yourself a lot of drama. people just go to FB to vent, Not sure I've ever seen anyone do anything about something they complainted about after they typed it.

someone in our HOA picked up literally, one hand full of trash in the park. It fit in one hand, went on facebook and said the HOA needed to hire someone to clean up the park, even though that's never been done for 25 years. That was a year ago and not a peep since and nothing has changed.

vis ta vie
CathyA3 (Ohio)
Posts: 6,299
Posted:
To paraphrase one of my favorite writers, "You may think you live in Alabama, but if God thinks you live in Michigan, then you live in Michigan."

I live in the part of the country that often sees ice instead of snow, and ice is trickier to deal with. And it isn't just the ice, it's the terrain. I had a figure skating coach who'd just moved to this (hilly) area from (flat) Michigan, and I had mentioned that there was an ice storm predicted for the weekend and that the rink would probably be closed. She scoffed, of course, and insisted that we just didn't know how to handle winter weather and that we'd be having a lesson. She indeed got a lesson: she drove her SUV into a ditch. She was not seriously injured, fortunately.

Anyway, you deal with ice before it even arrives: you pre-treat the roads. You can often see lines of brine on the major streets in my area. There is also a temperature below which road salt doesn't work. And if you'd had snow and it's windy, it will blow the snow back onto the newly cleared and salted roads, and the snow will melt and then re-freeze overnight. Snow on top of ice is the worst.

At some point, you decide that God's in charge: He put it there, and He can get rid of it.

(Hope you're surviving whatever has you quarantined. I thought we'd left quarantines in my childhood years, but it seems we're determined to resurrect the ol' childhood diseases. I get really annoyed at people saying "measles is just a kid's disease". Yeah, one of the things measles can do - besides cause encephalitis or kill you outright - is wipe out 11 percent to 73 percent of the different antibodies that protect against viruses and bacteria a person was previously immune to. My sister and I both had measles and chickenpox simultaneously, and we both got chickenpox a second time. And our brother brought home scarlet fever. Good times, good times ... don't know how our mother survived it. We now return you to our weather discussion in progress.)
CathyA3 (Ohio)
Posts: 6,299
Posted:
While we're complaining...

Our new board has been making some questionable decisions around finances, and one of the decisions was to change our snow removal policy. We have to get three inches or more before they'll have the streets plowed and we have to clean our own driveways and sidewalks. (Two inches is the norm around here.) The board decided that it was more important to keep assessments where they were, even though we're underfunding our reserves, among other things, and assessments should have gone up.

Predictably, we got yet another email from the board president this morning. Apparently the community blew up his in box with complaints from people who didn't want to clean their driveways and sidewalks when the temperatures were in the single digits. Imagine that. In fairness to him, we were warned about this. In fairness to the community, people don't usually buy condos in order to shovel driveways and sidewalks. We expect to pay for these services, so "we don't want to pay for this" rings a little hollow, especially since there have been some questionable expenditures lately. Our treasurer also resigned abruptly in fall, and the remaining board decided not to fill the position until the annual meeting even though they had qualified volunteers.

I predict that there are fights about money in our future, as well there should be. On a positive note, we've now had a demonstration of what "keeping assessments low" actually looks like - so maybe we'll be able to have some realistic discussions around the topic.
DeanJ
Posts: 1,786
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By MelissaP1 on 01/21/2024 1:38 AM
Yes when you hire a contractor to do the work as a responsible people do.

Where exactly does one get a residential snow plowing license in Alabama?
DavidG45 (Delaware)
Posts: 994
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By DeanJ on 01/21/2024 6:29 AM
Posted By MelissaP1 on 01/21/2024 1:38 AM
Yes when you hire a contractor to do the work as a responsible people do.


Where exactly does one get a residential snow plowing license in Alabama?

I would assume HOAs want to deal with businesses who have a state issued business license as well as liability insurance.
DavidG45 (Delaware)
Posts: 994
Posted:
Melissa - it sounds as if your streets are owned by the town, and not the Association. Is that correct?
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
That my dear is another can of worms... We are in 2 different cities. If that doesn't sound crazy enough. 2 streets are in one city and the other streets are in the other. We have 2 different developers. The one developer owns the HOA. Whom are the worst developer between the 2. Plus the MC they hired just had our "handler" quit a few weeks ago. She was a piece of work...

The issue is many are new to the HOA world. Plus new to the area. They have never seen this weather before. I have a few times in over 30 years. It's not pretty and it's VERY VERY rare. We were just not prepared for the ICE. Snow is usually not a big deal. It goes away in a couple of days. This ice lasted a week! (We still have ice).

It's just been frustrating. However, having someone decide to put on a scraper and run the hood without insurance/license is just dumb. People were parked on the side of the road unable to move their vehicles. One swipe of a car and done.

Former HOA President
DavidG45 (Delaware)
Posts: 994
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By MelissaP1 on 01/21/2024 8:30 AM
That my dear is another can of worms... We are in 2 different cities. If that doesn't sound crazy enough. 2 streets are in one city and the other streets are in the other. We have 2 different developers. The one developer owns the HOA. Whom are the worst developer between the 2. Plus the MC they hired just had our "handler" quit a few weeks ago. She was a piece of work...

The issue is many are new to the HOA world. Plus new to the area. They have never seen this weather before. I have a few times in over 30 years. It's not pretty and it's VERY VERY rare. We were just not prepared for the ICE. Snow is usually not a big deal. It goes away in a couple of days. This ice lasted a week! (We still have ice).

It's just been frustrating. However, having someone decide to put on a scraper and run the hood without insurance/license is just dumb. People were parked on the side of the road unable to move their vehicles. One swipe of a car and done.


If the HOA does not own the roads, then clearly you don't have either the responsibility or the authority to clear snow and ice. I've been trying to explain that to our homeowners this week, as the developer has not done a great job clearing our streets and some are advocating that the HOA take action on its own.

My stance that I have told people is this. The HOA does not have the responsibility nor the authority to do anything to the streets. As soon as we arrange for plows or salt on the roads we open ourselves to liability for any damage claims the developer or any homeowner may choose to assert. Taking on that risk, for something that is outside of our responsibility, is a violation of our fiduciary duty to the community.

Now, if a random homeowner chooses to do something, that is up to them; and the liability is on them. Especially if the Board has made their stance clear.

JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
I have never heard of "scraping" the ice off a road. I know all about snow plowing bit ice scraping is new to me. I am familiar with "salting and/or sanding the roads.

MarkM19 (Texas)
Posts: 1,459
Posted:
Wendy,
I am with you on this. If you don't want to know what dumb or stupid people are saying stay away from FB or ND. It is very simple, and it will save you many hours of shaking your head.

Social media has 2 or 3 types of users. They have the really dumb that ask the craziest questions and the other type is the people who like to tweak those people. The last and smallest group are the actual people who give good suggestions. This group is very rare, I mean like Big Foot sighting rare.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Scraping is same as plowing except the ice was so thick it needed scraping.

David I feel your pain. that is what I am trying to explain too. Developer did nothing. Which I did not expect they would. This person popped off because I pointed out if you want the HOA to pay you, then best be licensed and insured. That is when they offered to do it for free and to plow my mother. Class act.

Former HOA President
CathyA3 (Ohio)
Posts: 6,299
Posted:
We don't scrape ice off the road unless it's already breaking up and the plow is moving large chunks. You can get the plow blade under snow - you can't get it under ice unless the ice is broken. Solid ice is staying where it is until Mother Nature lends a hand - scraping does nothing but make noise and pollute the air.

I remember at least one year in the late 70s when the Ohio River froze and people were driving their trucks on it and walking over to KY. Not something I would have tried, but nobody fell through and drowned. Ice is one tough material.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here