💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

To all of our Florida managers, directors and association members.

Today, I recieved a present for all of us, from a group that has been the hardest working bunch of Floridians that I know, whose main goal is to keep us informed on happenings going on in Tallahassee with our State legislators. This is a PRO Board group, feeding thru one of the top HOA law firms in the State. I have worked with them for a few years and one of my associations has them on retainer.
The new website is ---www.callbp.com. You will find very valuable information as to pending changes in the HOA laws and what we can do about it. Thank You all and Happy Holidays. DonnaS
LaverneB (Florida)
Posts: 129
Posted:
Thank You Donna just in time for our elections whicj i am a little confusedd about the changes.. Merry Holidays!!!
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Laverne,
I cannot stress enough the importance of everyone who is working on a committee or is a member of a B.O.D, to run a copy of the Statute 720 for HOAs or 718 for condos and to take the time to read the important stuff, like section 303 and 306 which are election, amendments, voting and quorums. It is not a difficult read but it is the law. It becomes very clear after a couple of times of reading and would make running an association so much easier for all of the newcomers--and some of the old guard who have just been "winging" it all along. This is where all of the percentages and numbers are referred to , to make sure that your associations are in compliance with the State Statutes.
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
I need help with a Florida Statute. A homeowner wants to put a large propane tank on his property to use (supposedly) to heat the pool. We (the BOD)have told the Management Co. since it is clearly in our docs that we do not allow any type of tank above or below ground, we will not approve the request. The Management Co. says we may have approve it because according to State Statutes we must allow "energy efficent measures". I don't see how this is an energy efficienct measure, but maybe someone can enlighten me or know of this statute, so I can pass it on the the other Board members.

Thanks

Pat
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Pat,
Below is the Florida site for energy conservation. A couple of questions first. Are there any other Propane tanks in your developement? If there are , then you guys are out of luck in denying this application. We went thru it because of the large size of our area, before we had turnover and were still under the Developers watch, many pool installers just put the tanks in and no one reported them going in. So we had a precedent already set to deal with. For sure, every County has very strict installation requirements and they must be followed.

If there are no tanks at all, and your documents clearly state that there will be none allowed, then unless someone can find it in the energy act, there shall be none allowed. I could not find a law stating otherwise.

The energy act is- "FLORIDA RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES AND ENERGY EFFCIENCY ACT"
This act forbids restrictions on the use of solar and xeriscape landscaping and other renewable resources that can be used in HOAs. But nothing on Propane that I saw.
RW1 (Texas)
Posts: 149
Posted:
Should start a new thread for this but... the statute is FS 163.04. It specifically mentions solar but I guess wind would also be included. Propane tanks are not protected!
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
We had a resident put an underground tank in with the help of the last board. This should never have happened since our docs prohibit tanks of any kind.

Wonderful!

Thanks for the Enery act info

Pat
CharlesW1 (Georgia)
Posts: 826
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By PatR on 12/27/2007 1:25 PM
We had a resident put an underground tank in with the help of the last board. This should never have happened since our docs prohibit tanks of any kind.

Wonderful!

Thanks for the Enery act info

Pat

PatR

In your last post you state “We had a resident put an underground tank in with the help of the last board”. So apparently it was approved. I would think it was approved “IF” the previous board had helped install it.

I personally wouldn’t be concerned if in fact it is underground therefore not an eyesore to any of the residents within your community.

Just my 2 cents
Chuck W.


Charles E. Wafer Jr.
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Pat,
As we so often say---"Here we go again". The Board has approved an item that is strictly against the CC&Rs. Now they have no choice but to allow the new applicant for a tank to be installed. Selective enforcement if they are denied the ability to install the tank.

Your County has restrictions on it's installation. Our County has 10 foot from a property line and 10 foot from any structure. So at least you have some sort of guideline.

I also would make sure that the tank is installed underground. Get some ARC guidelines written to at least make sure that the beast is not visable from other properties.
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
I requested a copy of the ARC request from the old Management Co. There is NOTHING about a tank on any of the pages, only the request for the pool.....Stay tuned!

Pat
RW1 (Texas)
Posts: 149
Posted:
I agree with Chuck, the tank is out of sight... what's the problem if all local laws are met? Again, we must be reasonable! The renewal energy argument is however bogus.

I do appreciate and BENEFIT from DonnaS's posts. I believe she was a bit "quick with the mouse" in citing the Energy...ACT for this example. If you review the ACT she quoted it is aimed at industry, entreprenuers, etc, no direct benefit to HOAs specifically but may offer tax and other benefits to home owners. Maybe she meant the statute and was mis-spoken in her desire to help.

Pat, The FLA statute I quoted to you is short and easy to understand and HAS been tested in court in Palm Beach Co. (even in a case where a solar skylight, tube like device WAS NOT B.O.D. approved before installation!)

Also, Xeriscape clauses in FS 720 are restricted to HOAs formed after a specific date (don't recall at this time) again, not to say it could'nt be argued for all HOAs today especially given FLA's current water issues. But it [Xeriscape]has nothing to do with energy conservation or the Energy...ACT.

No intent to offend (DonnaS), just set the record straight.

If I have mis-spoke please let me know.

RW1
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

RW1,
This is the statement in 720;3075, (4)

4) Homeowners' association documents, including declarations of covenants, articles of incorporation, or bylaws, entered after October 1, 2001, may not prohibit any property owner from implementing Xeriscape or Florida-friendly landscape, as defined in s. 373.185(1), on his or her land.

History.--s. 3, ch. 98-261; s. 49, ch. 2000-258; s. 47, ch. 2000-302; s. 8, ch. 2001-252; s. 2, ch. 2002-50.

Yes, I did quote the Energy Act address so that everyone can have access to it for their own research. This is such an involved issue now days because there are also Federal restrictions and County, along with our State regs. I spent alot of time looking for Propane tanks and found nothing except for County installation restrictions.
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
Even though our docs forbid tanks of any type, the Board approved the ARC request, without noting that there is a little box checked off that says they are using liquid fuel.

So that tank is installed.

We really do not want to have 347 tanks!

Pat
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
Thanks so much Donna.

I also reached out to a State rep. He is his response:

I am unaware of a state statute mandating the allowance of propane tanks regardless of circumstances. We quickly searched the Florida Statutes today, and found 14 sections where propane tanks were referenced. None of the 14 statutes are applicable to your set of facts. However, there are a number of other references to things that include propane tanks within statutory definitions, so the search could go on and on.

Thus, I recommend writing a letter to the management company asking for a citation to the law.

Pat

DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Pat,
Okay, so what the State Rep is saying to you that he is not aware of any restrictions on the use of Propane tanks. Your HOA docs have the restrictions on tanks not being allowed. A previous Board did allow one to be installed. None of us can find any laws for HOAs to not allow their useage. Therefore my conclusion is that they can be restricted by individual HOA's.

Now you are stuck with the precidence of a tank being installed. The choice is now up to the Board.

Have the one tank removed? Ouch, I hear a lawsuit coming.

Allow tanks to be installed? Ouch, I hear a different lawsuit on non enforcement coming.

Change the CC&Rs to allow tanks? By what percent are you required to have to change the CC&Rs thru an association vote? Would it pass the membership? Probably not.
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
Yup, you are correct on all points.

We had the same problem with basketball hoops....not allowed, but the old board made an "exception", now we have many....If you are a member of the HOA, and hate basketball, and moved here to get away from basketball, cause we don't allow basketball hoops, then too bad!

My advice to everyone is not to make exceptions, because someone out there will call you on it!

A rule is a rule, no matter how dumb or unfair it may seem.

Pat

DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Pat,
Probably 90% of all Board problems come from their ignorance or lack of enforcement of laws, rules and CC&Rs, The most important thing that BODs can do is to educate themselves. That was the jist of my original post. Now we have some very valuable help with the site that I posted.
Then 90% or so of all member problems is basically the same except many chose to ignore laws, rules and their CC&Rs.
Put these two together and then there is need for us, who are trying to sort this mess out.
Boards who knowingly chose to make exceptions to their CC&Rs, are doing a disservice to their members and create many issues that even future Boards cannot straighten out. And there is always the "Fiduciary" responsibility to follow the CC&Rs, which doesn't seem to be enough to force BOD's to still do the job according to the rules. HUMPH!!!
AlexC1 (Florida)
Posts: 25
Posted:
Pat, we have a similar situation at our HOA in Florida BUT our bylaws stipulate that no gas tank shall be installed on said property if it is visible from the surrounding properties. What many homeowners have done is install an approved barrier (Shrubs, fence, etc) so that the tank is hiden from view. Would your documents have such a ruling ?
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
Our docs say NONE....But we know there is at least one that slipped by! It's a little tiny 1000 gallon tank. Oy!

Pat
DonnaS (Tennessee)
Posts: 5,671
Posted:

Pat,
As I said above, basically your Board is between a rock and a hard place. A precident has been established by a previous Board allowing the "little tiny 1000 gallon tank "to be installed.
Geez, I hate that when that happens. Anyone now wanting to install a tank and they get denied, the selective enforcement monster rears it's ugly head. Like I said, to try and get the exhisting tank to be removed would be a disaster for the owner because he was given approval by the Board. To ignore your CC&R's is totally unacceptable for everyone in your membership.
My own opinion would be to try to get in motion, an amendment to allow the tanks with certain restrictions. Mostly that they be buried and totally out of view from other properties. Of course, they must be installed according to your County codes. In Florida, there is no problem with having them buried so that is a non issue. This is always a nightmare for Boards to deal with when a previous Board has not done their job correctly.
PatR (Florida)
Posts: 139
Posted:
Good ideas.

We have a meeting this week...I'll bring all this info.

Thanks again, and Happy New Year

Pat
TracyT (Maryland)
Posts: 228
Posted:
Hi Pat,

I'm curious if/how this got resolved and how you're overcoming some of your other voilations.

Thanks.
Tracy

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here