💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
The annual insurance renewal for our property is coming up.

the property manager seems doing everything possible to avoid getting actual comparisons.

with a cost of 180,000. isnt' there a requirement for associations to get bids.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
texas house bill 1588 required all hoas to now get bids for any contracts or services over 50,000.

please tell me this also applies to condominiums
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
texas house bill 1588 required all hoas to now get bids for any contracts or services over 50,000.

please tell me this also applies to condominiums
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
texas house bill 1588 required all hoas to now get bids for any contracts or services over 50,000.

please tell me this also applies to condominiums
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
I think you are referring to the statute sections that SB 1588 and its incarnations added. All I know is that TPC 209 (applying to non-condo HOAs) says:

In addition to the other applicable requirements of this section, an association that proposes to contract for services that will cost more than $50,000 shall solicit bids or proposals using a bid process established by the association.

TPC 81 and TPC 82 (applicable to condominiums) say nothing like this.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
gosh, that was my fear.

augustine, this makes no sense. the insurance is the single largest purchase a condo association makes. something nefarious is going on. a competitng broker has requested the opportunity to present a proposal.

currently the managing agent who only provides us bookkeeping has also been umbrellaing our property and liability insureance with all of his full managed properties. This has prevented us from having insurance that addresses our specific needs.

I was reading over the contract today between the managing agent and our property..

"the association's insurance shall be considered the primary coverage for the benefit of managing agent company."
SteveH35 (Washington)
Posts: 339
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LaskaS on 05/18/2022 6:34 PM
The annual insurance renewal for our property is coming up.

the property manager seems doing everything possible to avoid getting actual comparisons.

with a cost of 180,000. isnt' there a requirement for associations to get bids.

Go around your property manager directly to the source: your insurance broker. Quoting insurance is what they do extremely well.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
steve, we don't have our own broker.

we are a self managed condominium community,, but we do contract with a management company to provide the accounting and bookeeeping services.

this company also provides full service managment to many properties.

He has all of the properties he manages under one giant policy with a particular broker.

the client of the broker is the management company.

The management company is telling us we are wasting our time getting comparisons he has already done all the research.
The owner of this management company (different than our property manager, our property manager is employed by the association) has repeatedly misinformed the board or rather, neglected to be clear with explanations. He does what's good for his company.

i know a broker's commission for an hoa's insurance policies is substantial. The managing agent provides all 80 of the communties his company manages to this one broker.. none of the communties have their own policy..
MaxB4
Posts: 3,513
Posted:
Sorry, your association needs to start over from scratch, throw the baby out with the bath water. This is all messed up.
SteveH35 (Washington)
Posts: 339
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LaskaS on 05/18/2022 8:45 PM
steve, we don't have our own broker.

i know a broker's commission for an hoa's insurance policies is substantial. The managing agent provides all 80 of the communties his company manages to this one broker.. none of the communties have their own policy..

If your CIC's policy premium is $180,000/yr or even $10,000/yr or more, you should have your own broker who works for the association and obtain an individual policy. Broker's commissions are baked into policies no matter what. There's nothing substantial about a commission standing in your way. Tell your management company to bugger off.

Regards,
Steve
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LaskaS on 05/18/2022 7:04 PM
the insurance is the single largest purchase a condo association makes.
Of the regular annual operating expenses, I would say it is often one of the larger annual expenses.

Quote:
something nefarious is going on. a competitng broker has requested the opportunity to present a proposal.

currently the managing agent who only provides us bookkeeping has also been umbrellaing our property and liability insureance with all of his full managed properties. This has prevented us from having insurance that addresses our specific needs.

I was reading over the contract today between the managing agent and our property..

"the association's insurance shall be considered the primary coverage for the benefit of managing agent company."
All you can do is maybe speak about this at board meetings (if an open forum happens at board meetings) or maybe send out flyers. I would keep firmly in mind that the owners have spoken, regarding who they want on the board. That the owners are largely absentee does not matter.

I do not support speaking with the COA's vendors. To me, doing sotlooks like too much of an attempted end run around the COA's Board or manager. It fouls up communications and relationships.
MaxB4
Posts: 3,513
Posted:
EVERY HOA should not be using rhe management companies broker for insurance. Each HOA should/must have their own broker or agent. This holds true for using an management company's attorney as the association's, NEVER, NEVER, NEVER...Huge conflict of interest.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
remember,, Our condominium is self managed. we employee maintenance employees and an onsite property mananger.

we contract out to a management company the bookkeeping and document retention and notification duties.

The managment company has several communities which it completely manages. including providing manager, maintenance of the common areas etc.

For those communities the management company has an insureance broker who provides all of the properties with the required insurance.

For some reason. probably igorance on the assoications part, years ago, the management company suggested that our community could be included in his group. He suggested the association would reap benefits of being in large group. Suggesting we would get better coverage because we were part of a large group. i.e economies of scale.

he did not inform the association of the downside of being in a master group. there are several.

There are numerous considerations that should be part of the decision making process when choosing whether to have our own broker or stay with exisitng broker. Broker has repeatedly stated that management company it its direct contact.

Every attempt to get another hoa insureance broker to present options to our board has been stmied by this manangement agent. he is stating that If condo association(ours) has a broker go to market and shop for insurance for just our association that would be a red flag to insureres and would possibley result in the association not being able to get insureance or getting unfavorable rates.

All i am asking is that the board get two independent proposals and bids. Unfortunately, every meeting that this is brought up, the management agent strongly interjects that I am wrong for suggesting this. Or belittles me and tells the board that he already has the best possible insureance available etc.... I do know , some board members have recognized the extreme reaction this management agent has whenever the option of getting comparisons is mentioned. They do agree that we should get bids. However, the property manager (not managing agent) is now backing away from his assureance to me that he would get bids to present to the board. I know whats going on here.

Could i file a complaint with the state insureance board against the broker?? my goal is to ensure that the board agree to independently , without the managing agent present, have another insureance broker make a presentation. If after reviewing all of the informatoin the board chooses to stay with existing broker , which is not our broker. Than so be it.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
remember,, Our condominium is self managed. we employee maintenance employees and an onsite property mananger.

we contract out to a management company the bookkeeping and document retention and notification duties.

The managment company has several communities which it completely manages. including providing manager, maintenance of the common areas etc.

For those communities the management company has an insureance broker who provides all of the properties with the required insurance.

For some reason. probably igorance on the assoications part, years ago, the management company suggested that our community could be included in his group. He suggested the association would reap benefits of being in large group. Suggesting we would get better coverage because we were part of a large group. i.e economies of scale.

he did not inform the association of the downside of being in a master group. there are several.

There are numerous considerations that should be part of the decision making process when choosing whether to have our own broker or stay with exisitng broker. Broker has repeatedly stated that management company it its direct contact.

Every attempt to get another hoa insureance broker to present options to our board has been stmied by this manangement agent. he is stating that If condo association(ours) has a broker go to market and shop for insurance for just our association that would be a red flag to insureres and would possibley result in the association not being able to get insureance or getting unfavorable rates.

All i am asking is that the board get two independent proposals and bids. Unfortunately, every meeting that this is brought up, the management agent strongly interjects that I am wrong for suggesting this. Or belittles me and tells the board that he already has the best possible insureance available etc.... I do know , some board members have recognized the extreme reaction this management agent has whenever the option of getting comparisons is mentioned. They do agree that we should get bids. However, the property manager (not managing agent) is now backing away from his assureance to me that he would get bids to present to the board. I know whats going on here.

Could i file a complaint with the state insureance board against the broker?? my goal is to ensure that the board agree to independently , without the managing agent present, have another insureance broker make a presentation. If after reviewing all of the informatoin the board chooses to stay with existing broker , which is not our broker. Than so be it.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
remember,, Our condominium is self managed. we employee maintenance employees and an onsite property mananger.

we contract out to a management company the bookkeeping and document retention and notification duties.

The managment company has several communities which it completely manages. including providing manager, maintenance of the common areas etc.

For those communities the management company has an insureance broker who provides all of the properties with the required insurance.

For some reason. probably igorance on the assoications part, years ago, the management company suggested that our community could be included in his group. He suggested the association would reap benefits of being in large group. Suggesting we would get better coverage because we were part of a large group. i.e economies of scale.

he did not inform the association of the downside of being in a master group. there are several.

There are numerous considerations that should be part of the decision making process when choosing whether to have our own broker or stay with exisitng broker. Broker has repeatedly stated that management company it its direct contact.

Every attempt to get another hoa insureance broker to present options to our board has been stmied by this manangement agent. he is stating that If condo association(ours) has a broker go to market and shop for insurance for just our association that would be a red flag to insureres and would possibley result in the association not being able to get insureance or getting unfavorable rates.

All i am asking is that the board get two independent proposals and bids. Unfortunately, every meeting that this is brought up, the management agent strongly interjects that I am wrong for suggesting this. Or belittles me and tells the board that he already has the best possible insureance available etc.... I do know , some board members have recognized the extreme reaction this management agent has whenever the option of getting comparisons is mentioned. They do agree that we should get bids. However, the property manager (not managing agent) is now backing away from his assureance to me that he would get bids to present to the board. I know whats going on here.

Could i file a complaint with the state insureance board against the broker?? my goal is to ensure that the board agree to independently , without the managing agent present, have another insureance broker make a presentation. If after reviewing all of the informatoin the board chooses to stay with existing broker , which is not our broker. Than so be it.
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LaskaS on 05/19/2022 1:16 PM
[edited slightly for readability] Every attempt to get another hoa insureance broker to present options to our board has been stymied by this management agent.
How come you think the fault does not lie with the board here? Right now, and arguendo assuming you are correct in asserting the manager is lying, I think this is the board's fault in not questioning the manager (a salesperson for the purposes of this thread) carefully.
LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
it's just a total joke.

there are several board members who did raise questions and insisted that the association should at a minium get a separate bid.

the managing agent has on numerous occasions advised against the need to to this.

Last night, at the meeting, the two board members that had been pushing for getting comparisons were not at the meeting.

anyway.. this is ridiculous.

augustin i'm starting anther thread regarding the board adoption of the budget.
MaxB4
Posts: 3,513
Posted:
Laska,

Again, you need to start over from scratch. You have a mess and this forum will not resolve the issues.
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LaskaS on 05/19/2022 2:22 PM
it's just a total joke.

there are several board members who did raise questions and insisted that the association should at a minium get a separate bid.

the managing agent has on numerous occasions advised against the need to to this.

Last night, at the meeting, the two board members that had been pushing for getting comparisons were not at the meeting.

anyway.. this is ridiculous.


Amiga, isn't this where the Serenity Prayer should kick in?

I say this with a twinkle in my eye and respect (and though a mere Gringa, also having hailed from the Southwest).

Keep talking to the directors displeased with the situation?

I will watch for your next thread.

LaskaS (Texas)
Posts: 1,025
Posted:
maxb4, I agree with you. but i can't do it alone.

I was able to gather enough support this year and other owners willing to serve. However, the current board did several things that prevented proper notice about the upcoming meeting and elections .

The group of owners that were running now know what games are played and are going to start collecting signatures early january. We don't need to wait for a notice of annual meeting.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here