💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

AngelaC11 (Maryland)
Posts: 5
Posted:
There is only one board member. Her term has expired. She has failed to have a yearly meeting? The resident agent is an attorney and no help. Our Bylaws stated we can remove Directors… with a majority of signatures. A petition was started and gathered a majority of signatures…to remove the last Director. The petition was given to the resident agent. Nothing has been done…still no notice has been sent to homeowners to hold a yearly election. What should the community do? Thank you
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Stop assuming there is a "They/Them" that exist. It is YOU and your neighbors. The play book is in your hands. Start playing it.

Former HOA President
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Let me elaborate. It sounds like you and your neighbors are watching a house on fire and ASSUMING someone called 911. Meanwhile the person in that house (the last board member) is outside watching with everyone else. Your HOA is basically ASSUMING things are in place without realizing there isn't anything there. That board member probably has been screaming "fire" and no one responded.

So I would suggest those with a fire in their bellies start getting involved. Find out what is in existance and go from there. Sounds like a few people need to step up and form an actual board. That last person at the helm done fell off and doesn't want to climb back on board.

Former HOA President
AngelaC11 (Maryland)
Posts: 5
Posted:
Because the last board member failed to hold a yearly meeting after her term expired. I drafted up a notice for a interim HOA election. The notice was given out and posted on a community web site. I also drafted up a ballot, proxy forms and a sign in sheet to establish a quorum… which we were able to do. As a result of the meeting…that was held in the community outside in a common area, the community was able to select a completely new board. The resident agent is aware of the election…of the interim board. The resident agent said that the last board member said she was going to send out notices to have an end of month January election…so that the community can once again elect the interim board members… however…the last board member did not send out notices. The community want the last board member removed…using the petition for removal which our bylaws support. Since I was elected interim President… I have written two letters to the resident agent to put her on notice as to what is going on in our community. I have also spoken with the resident agent. I have left a message with her receptionist to have her contact me. She has not contacted me since I wrote her the second letter…to inform her…that no notice was sent to community homeowners to hold a election. The last board member has not turned any HOA documents over to the elected interim board…so that we can move forward. The resident agent and last board members are holding our community hostage…what do we do? The community has no money to hire an attorney after a resent frivolous lawsuit was filed and the HOA board lost. So what next?
CathyA3 (Ohio)
Posts: 6,299
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/25/2022 7:57 PM
There is only one board member. Her term has expired. She has failed to have a yearly meeting? The resident agent is an attorney and no help. Our Bylaws stated we can remove Directors… with a majority of signatures. A petition was started and gathered a majority of signatures…to remove the last Director. The petition was given to the resident agent. Nothing has been done…still no notice has been sent to homeowners to hold a yearly election. What should the community do? Thank you

You want to remove your last director?! I hope there are others prepared to serve on the board, because you'll send yourselves right into receivership which is an expensive eye-opener for communities without functioning boards.

Technically you have no board at all right now if the last director's term has expired, although it's common for directors to remain in place if the annual meeting/election hasn't taken place. Even if the person has remained in place, a single director is not a quorum and technically is not allowed to conduct business at all. Who is paying the bills and handling all of the other essential jobs that go with running a community association?

You should probably talk to a knowledgeable lawyer sooner rather than later if there really is nobody in charge. There are a number of requirements to successfully removing and replacing directors, and you have to follow these requirements exactly. If your petition didn't meet the requirements, for example, that could explain why nothing has happened.

http://www.md-hoa.org/board-annual-and-special-meetings/

AngelaC11 (Maryland)
Posts: 5
Posted:
Our petition met the requirements based on our bylaws…that is why I’m confused…why is it taking so long to get the last board member removed….the last board member should be removed…since the community has already elected a new interim board to replace the last board member. The community has repeatedly requested financial documents, budget and minutes for the past 4 years and nothing have been provided and the resident agent is aware of that fact. We have less than 100 homes in our community.
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/26/2022 6:26 AM
Our petition met the requirements based on our bylaws…that is why I’m confused…why is it taking so long to get the last board member removed….the last board member should be removed…since the community has already elected a new interim board to replace the last board member. The community has repeatedly requested financial documents, budget and minutes for the past 4 years and nothing have been provided and the resident agent is aware of that fact. We have less than 100 homes in our community.
I think part of the problem is that, if only one person is on the Board, then this person gets full legal advice from the HOA attorney. If the HOA attorney does not think your recall and/or election met the requirements of the law, the HOA attorney can ignore you.

You may think you complied with the Bylaws or state statute, but as is often pointed out here, dotting all the i's and crossing all the t's is no easy feat. The HOA attorney may have found your efforts defective and so their results, not lawfully obtained.

Prince George's County, Montgomery County and Charles County appear to have government offices that can help with HOA disputes. See https://marylandhomeownersassociation.org/problem-solution/. If the OP lives in one of these counties, then I think she should contact the right authority as listed at the latter site. The OP should then explain her concerns and ask questions.

Also try contacting:

https://marylandhomeownersassociation.org/

Else I agree with CathyA3 that the OP should seek an attorney.
AngelaC11 (Maryland)
Posts: 5
Posted:
The HOA board term expired in June or August 2021. I submitted a letter to the Board to hold a special meeting for a yearly election. At the time I submitted the letter there were 3 board members…2 of 3 have resigned. No notice of the special meeting was sent out to the community. I would think a professional HOA resident agent works on behalf of the community not just one board member who’s time has expired and who have repeatedly lied about sending out election notice. Removing this person as a director may not be possible if she was elected by the members, but she was not…for a second term. I can prove a breach of fiduciary duty. That is, to prove that she was acting for her personal benefit at the expense of the association. Her position as President is not so assured, especially if it can be proven that she deliberately and knowingly refused to hold the annual meetings required by law. The declaration likely gives her the right to serve on the board but there is no such thing as a right to be an officer. How can a board member who term has expired and has repeatedly fail to hold a election be considered acting in good faith and abiding by her fiduciary duties if they fail to follow the governing documents of the community…they serve?

JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By CathyA3 on 01/26/2022 5:35 AM
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/25/2022 7:57 PM
There is only one board member. Her term has expired. She has failed to have a yearly meeting? The resident agent is an attorney and no help. Our Bylaws stated we can remove Directors… with a majority of signatures. A petition was started and gathered a majority of signatures…to remove the last Director. The petition was given to the resident agent. Nothing has been done…still no notice has been sent to homeowners to hold a yearly election. What should the community do? Thank you


You want to remove your last director?! I hope there are others prepared to serve on the board, because you'll send yourselves right into receivership which is an expensive eye-opener for communities without functioning boards.

Technically you have no board at all right now if the last director's term has expired, although it's common for directors to remain in place if the annual meeting/election hasn't taken place. Even if the person has remained in place, a single director is not a quorum and technically is not allowed to conduct business at all. Who is paying the bills and handling all of the other essential jobs that go with running a community association?

You should probably talk to a knowledgeable lawyer sooner rather than later if there really is nobody in charge. There are a number of requirements to successfully removing and replacing directors, and you have to follow these requirements exactly. If your petition didn't meet the requirements, for example, that could explain why nothing has happened.

http://www.md-hoa.org/board-annual-and-special-meetings/


I agree. The OP needs something more then her letters.
AngelaC11 (Maryland)
Posts: 5
Posted:
I have spoken with the resident agent. She did not state their were an issue on the interim board end on how we elected the interim board. Notice were sent out…time, place and date. Community members should up. We had enough attendance and proxy’s from the community to have a quorum. The meeting was second and the meeting was open to conduct community business. Also, on the notice was the reason for the meeting and the agenda of the meeting. The resident agent was sent a copy of the documents that was drafted for the meeting. She has not stated a concern about not following our governing documents.
AugustinD
Posts: 3,698
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/26/2022 11:45 AM
The HOA board term expired in June or August 2021.
This does not matter. As is repeated often here, your state's nonprofit corporation statute undoubtedly states that directors serve until their term is up andtheir successor is elected.
Quote:
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/26/2022 11:45 AM
I would think a professional HOA resident agent works on behalf of the community not just one board member who’s time has expired and who have repeatedly lied about sending out election notice.
The HOA attorney's client is the HOA corporation. However, the Board gives direction to the HOA attorney on behalf of the corporation, and per the Board's enumerated power.

Quote:
Posted By AngelaC11 on 01/26/2022 11:45 AM
The declaration likely gives her the right to serve on the board but there is no such thing as a right to be an officer.
I can almost guarantee that your HOA's governing documents and your state's relevant statutes state that the board selects the officers. If only one person is on the Board, then this person picks the officers.

You say you spoke with the "registered agent." Maybe you are making progress on installing the people you say were properly elected.

I understand you believe the facts are on your side. It's making the facts become the reality of a new board that is quite often, difficult. Often one must hire one's own attorney.

Two cents.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here