💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
Hello, friends!

I received an email response from management. The only things they agreed to provide were the past audits and the 1997 lease between laundry company and our condo building (in NJ).

Here is a list of things we owners are not entitled to. PUtting it it caps because I don't think bold facing works here ("OUR ATTORNEY ADVISES THAT YOU ARE NOT ENTITLED TO SEE THIS.") :

1. Proposal provided from XXXX (laundry company) dated November 2014. (I had asked because the laundry company gave me a copy of what they had provided in 2014, which the Board decided not to accept, and Board said that the copy I was provided was not what they had promised in the Proposal the Board was given in 2014. So I asked to see their copy to see what was, in fact, true. I am not allowed to see that. It is JUST A PROPOSAL from 2014 that was never even considered.

2. Closing statements of the initial loan granted, as well as the second one that was applied for and granted in January 2016 (or thereabouts) and ALL related paperwork for both, including but not limited to initial applications and reasons and the projects proposed to the bank for the loan monies to be applied towards. (Loan total of 2.1 million)

3. Amounts applied to each said project completed.

4. A list of Units owned by the Association, and monthly rental incomes of each unit from January 2015 - Present. (For this, he only listed ONE apartment - because he knows I know of THAT 1 unit, but owners have told me there are a lot more than this.)

The NJ law requires that they provide all receipts we ask for as owners. Now, should we owners not be entitled to see the LOAN application and closing documents and the projections and payments? At this time the Board is only paying the interest monthly, nothing is being applied to the Principle loan amount. It is all VERY mismanaged.

We already suspect there is kickback stuff going on, and we deserve to be able to view all documents.
If you would like, also, you can respond to me directly at username enufzenuf and this is on the yahoo email account.

Thank you in advance for all your help!!!

KerryL1 (California)
Posts: 14,550
Posted:
In my HOA and in CA, I believe, Owners have no right to see proposals or bids, only executed contracts.

So, #4, you're saying your HOA owns some or many units? If so, rental income should be shown on your months financials as income. What do you mean by HOA? Are you still under developer control?

CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
OOps, We are a 200-unit condo building. And yes, ALL rental income should be shown on the final audits. It is not.
CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
Also, the proposal in question is something provided in 2014 which was discarded by the Board and it went its own way. My reason for asking for a copy of what they receieved is to prove or disprove their comment that the copy I was provided by the laundry company and promises made therein was NOT what they received in 2014. I want to compare the two. In fact, the Board asked me to show them what I had, and I said, I would like to see what they have as well.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
How does the HOA "own" these units? Not really clear to me. Typically a HOA would never want to own a property. They may have a property manager that manages the property on the behalf of an owner. I just don't see an actual HOA owning a unit and renting it out.

Former HOA President
CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
The Association entity owns some units, which are assets for us as rentals, much like when leasing our laundry space to laundry company, the payments on that lease were a source of income. I Dont exactly know how, maybe when units were sold after conversion from coop to condo, the Association bought over some units to use as our source of additional income. I anticipate yet another cover up to this but I have evidence that not all income is being reported, and it is not just on one ledger entry line. Also, thanks to a website link on here provided by someone, I plan to go to NJ state main offices as well.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
You do understand your a member of this HOA your "fighting" right? So don't get to far into your battle to find out your battling yourself...

Former HOA President
CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
We owners are being kept in the dark. We have met a few times and will again in the morning. "I" am not battling alone. I am the one posting here. New information is being shed to light on a continuous basis. I hope when you were HOA president, that things were not as shady! Having an effective President helps, but she is always outvoted, she says.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Be careful of what you ask for... You may not really agree with some of my advice but it's not coming from a bad place. Just a reality place.

I agree with much of what the response was for denial of review of those records. Do not believe you or others need to see or have access to much of that of which you were denied. Remember you and your neighbors elected people to represent you on the daily operations of the HOA. So even if you see this information, not much you can do about it. Your not in a position to make changes in budgetary changes or approvals.

Now that is NOT to say your not powerless. It just means you need to take another approach. That is to vote and elect the board out you all feel is not representing your best interest. That is only half the battle. You need to vote on people who you DO feel represent.

If you have those two things, then you don't need all of this "witch hunting" efforts. You will have your majority of involved owners who are in charge of their own destiny.

Former HOA President
CharooM1 (New Jersey)
Posts: 15
Posted:
Hi Melissa, actually, there is a lot more going on than I feel comfortable posting here. My State does allow us to view financial records to prove or disprove fraudulent activity. It is not "witchhunting", it is gathering information that is necessary and should be legally available to any homeowner(s) who request it, I have called State offices.

The management rep is the one who initiated the "activity" which has ended up harming us. Greed and a quick buck was more important, and the rest of us are in danger of being left with the mess.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here