💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
I recently obtained the rights of the Declarant to my 50 house-single family subdivision. The original Declarant sold the property to a bank, but did not sell the Declarant rights. A new developer bought the land and held himself out as the Declarant. When he offered a waiver for a homeowner to put up a fence but wouldn't extend that courtesy to others in our sub, I began researching, reached out to the original declarant, and purchased those rights.

My intention now is to begin raising assessment dollars from all lot owners (including the new builder) in order to purchase the park space back from the bank and to build a playground. My question is this: has any one built a park for their HOA? Any advice, tips, resources? I think that a park would be a great community asset and my neighbors (aside from the new developer) are on board.

Thank you!
LetA (Nevada)
Posts: 2,679
Posted:
Our developer already had a park built with a splash pad. I would stay away from a splash pad because it is costly to maintain.
I would add a dog patch, that would add some curb appeal Perhaps some tables with umbrellas and a bbq grill.
CjC
Posts: 210
Posted:
Rebecca-

Do your documents allow you to collect dues from the builder? Many only allow on improved lots (lots with home with occupancy permits).
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
The covenants say that assessments are made and costs are divided equally among lot owners. There is no language that differentiates empty lots from built ones
I don't know if this was an oversight of the original declarant or whether he didn't intend to collect assessments until the subdivision was completed.
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
Thank you for your replies. I had liked to idea of a splash pad, so I'm glad to see you talking about that. Will definitely shy away from it if the costs are high to maintain.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I attempted but never got passed the planning stage. Why? The parents did not want one. Before you start this project do a poll to see if you have the support. It may sound strange parents not wanting a playground in the neighborhood. However, think about how much trouble those can be. Especially those who have to listen to screaming kids or bandaging a knee. Also the equipment isn't so easy/cheap to find. It has to rated for PUBLIC use and not private. The difference is the warranty. That equipment you see at Lowes/Home depot/special playground companies won't do. Those are for private homes and they won't cover damages/replacement if not kept exclusive private. Read the small print!

I find a dog park is very popular but comes with plenty of liability. (Dog fights, cleanup, and bad owners). A basketball goal is what we had in our park area. It was used very little. I found that the best option may be a community garden instead. Many people seem to like them and seem to manage themselves.

Former HOA President
JeffT2 (Iowa)
Posts: 880
Posted:
I'm very curious, how much are declarant rights worth for a 50 lot development?

Declarant rights often expire when the declarant has sold a certain percentage of lots. In your case, it appears that the declarant has sold 100% of the lots and the rights have therefore expired. Do you know if the rights have expired? What are the conditions in your CC&Rs for the rights to expire?
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
My Restrictions says the following: "Once development of the Plat...is completed, or substantially completed, Declarant intends to transfer administration of these Restrictions to the Homeowners' Association. However..Declarant further reserves the right to retain administration of any portion of these restrictions indefinitely."
GenoS (Florida)
Posts: 4,276
Posted:
This sounds most unusual. Do you have prior experience as a Declarant of a deed-covenanted development? If the documents give you control of the board, the devil on my left shoulder says,

1. Sell your home and move outside the development right away
2. Appoint yourself and your friends as directors
3. Quadruple assessments
4. Buy up the properties at bargain basement prices as distressed owners sell
5. Profit!

But it's probably not that simple. Along with rights there are probably state and local laws and regulations that impose obligations and the duty to perform certain things. This would depend on the governing documents and the local planning board (or whoever approved the development in the first place).

The angel on my right shoulder says if you've never done this before you should hire competent legal counsel right away before doing anything at all.
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
I have never done this before, though I am a lawyer. I wasn't really interested in this originally, but the new developer's agent was condecendng and rude to my neighbors and me. Now that I have to power, I hope to use it to help my neighbors get the park that they were promised and were never going to get. After that, I'd like to hold a vote to get rid off all the restrictions in the master deed-our city code is enough.
JeffT2 (Iowa)
Posts: 880
Posted:
If you have the full set of the usual declarant rights, you can appoint members to the board of directors, including yourself, take over the bank account, manage the association, and raise assessments.

I assume that the association has not been turned over to the homeowners. If it has, your declarant rights may be gone (or can be challenged).

Who has control of the hoa's bank account now?

Be ready for a legal challenge.

Raising the assessments might not be as popular as you imagine.

You may wish to turn the hoa over to the owners sooner rather than later. Let the owners decide what to do.

By the way, board members must act in the best interests of the association, not in their own best interest.

You will need an hoa to maintain the playground in the future.

You can hold a vote to get rid of the restrictions without being declarant.
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
Thanks Jeff. Power has not been turned over to the homeowners. The original developer created the HOA, but didn't build any houses before he sold the land to avoid bankruptcy. There is no bank account, to my knowledge. There wouldn't have been any money in it, even if he had created one.

The current builder has been making assessments, claiming to be the HOA for the last several years. He collected $300 per house at closing (10 houses done, 40 empty lots remaining) and has made $100 per year annual assessments. My plan isn't to raise them, but rather collect them from all lot owners, including this new builder.

I'm on friendly terms with all of my neighbors and have cc'd them all on the letters and documents I have sent/received regarding this from the beginning. I don't think that I really want to turn control over to the HOA and give the developer control (since he would have 40 lots vs. our 10).

JeffT2 (Iowa)
Posts: 880
Posted:
This gets more interesting all the time. I'm usually on the side of the homeowners, not the declarant, but in this case I wish you good luck.

Most HOAs are incorporated. You can check the name of your HOA at the MI secy of state here:

http://w1.lara.state.mi.us/businessentitysearch/

You can view the articles of incorporation there. The current builder should be using the name of the HOA and have established a TIN with the IRS and should have a bank account in the name of the HOA. The right to assess homeowners usually goes through the HOA, and not in the name of the declarant or builder. The builder usually has no right to collect assessments independent of the HOA.

Do you make your yearly assessment check payable to the HOA or the builder?

If the HOA is incorporated, the MI non-profit law has procedures for members of an association (lot owners) to view/copy all of the association's records, including the HOA's current bank statements that are in the possession of the builder.

If the HOA is incorporated, you will need to take charge of the corporation. The board of the HOA is the board of the corporation. Appoint the board, call a board meeting, everything by the book, then go to the bank to take over the existing HOA account. You can't usually collect assessments in the name of the declarant.

If not incorporated, I would start by incorporating the HOA.
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
Thanks Jeff! I think that it's probably pretty rare for the declarant to be a homeowner, fighting for the other homeowners.

The HOA was definitely incorporated in 2006, around the same time the original declarant filed the master deed. Since then, it was automatically dissolved because it wasn't current on its annual fees. The new developer created a new non-profit corporation, created new articles of incorporation and bylaws, allowing him to appoint himself and his friends/agents to the board.

I'm thinking it might be easier to incorporate a new HOA and go from there.
JeffT2 (Iowa)
Posts: 880
Posted:
Reinstating the original non-profit corporation through the secretary of state website (or by paper) will have the real name of the HOA, be the real HOA corporation and may be more legitimate than a new corporation (and probably already has a TIN).
RebeccaM7 (Michigan)
Posts: 10
Posted:
I thought about reinstating but I would owe penalties and late fees. The cost to reincorporate would be ~$500 v. ~$50 or so. I'd also have to file statements for the last several years. I don't know that I feel comfortable doing that. Though I assume that the previous declarant did nothing during that lapse, I don't know that I really want to attest to that.

Also, because the original was dissolved so long ago, the state gave away the name rights anyway, so I would have to re-name the corporation.
JanetB2 (Colorado)
Posts: 4,219
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By RebeccaM7 on 10/15/2017 6:44 PM
Thanks Jeff! I think that it's probably pretty rare for the declarant to be a homeowner, fighting for the other homeowners.

The HOA was definitely incorporated in 2006, around the same time the original declarant filed the master deed. Since then, it was automatically dissolved because it wasn't current on its annual fees. The new developer created a new non-profit corporation, created new articles of incorporation and bylaws, allowing him to appoint himself and his friends/agents to the board.

I'm thinking it might be easier to incorporate a new HOA and go from there.


So ... how could the new developer create a new Non-Profit HOA and ATTACH any such new HOA to current properties without any owner's approvals??? If you are an attorney ... that potentially should be a question you are asking yourself. Potentially in my state the new developer would just be an owner of X number of lots, if the developer did not have the "development rights" transferred to them at the time of their purchase. Seems to me the moron is exceeding their legal authority.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here