💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Current papers I have read in the cc&r says you must have 90% of owners sign to make changes up till Oct.2018, yet you hear that lawyers are drafting papers which says you only need 75% of owners ,how can this be possible ? Yes I have asked and all I am told is I can ask at the next meeting .

Just seems that this could not happen ( yes I know there is suppose to be lawyers drafting something up ) yet I know not all are ethical .

Does anyone know how long a draft takes to write up ?( I would think not long ) but also again only papers I have seen say only after the date in 2018 .

Is this legal ?

I am hearing the date was changed to this year but even if it was should there not be new papers which says it has been changed ?
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
What is the exact language of the CCR's that specifies a 90% threshold approval? It does not make sense that the lawyers would draft language calling for a 75% approval contrary to your governing documents.

Suggest you not bother to ask; READ and put your concerns in writing. It is very easy to brush off and "misunderstand" a question when verbalizing these kinds of things on the fly. According to your comment, you are already being brushed aside. That is easy to do when one is not in possession of the facts.

Reading and comprehending the requirements of your governance and statutory law is a jumping off point to questions. There is no way to evaluate "ethics" until all the facts are on the table.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Article VII section 3
The covenants and restrictions of this declaration shall bind only the land specifically herein described and shall run with and bind the land .The Declaration may be amended prior to October 1 2018 by an instrument signed by the owners of not less than 90% of the lots and by the Declarant .so long as the declarant still owns any lots and there after by am instrument signed by owners of not less than 75% of the lots

This what I am questioning I have not seen any papers saying the date has been changed to this year .( 10/1/2017) no other papers just the one I see here ,

Am I reading it wrong ? To me it says in order to change this you have to have 90% of owners to sign to amend after the October 2018 then it drops to 75% .

As to owners this would be mainly owner occupied homes I would think those homes which are owned by rental company's and those which are owned by individuals which live elsewhere would not be willing to sign .
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Oh and there is 1 lot which is still owned by the development company
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
You wrote:

so long as the declarant still owns any lots and there after by am instrument signed by owners of not less than 75% of the lots

This is telling me that after October 2018, as long as Developer owns a lot--which it does now--then the voting threshold drops to 75%. This language suggests to me that that the threshold will only drop to 75% if the Declarant still owns a lot. What happens in October 2018 if the Declarant does not own a lot? I never read anything written like that. Also, the language seems a little careless as you have written it ie incomplete sentence construction, bad spelling/punctuation and I wonder if that is actually the exact rendering of the CCR?

At the current time-and until October 2018-the approval threshold is 90% to amend. The threshold to amend a provision is automatic and pre-determined. Owners do not weigh in unless an amendment provision is offered to amend the CCR percentage and the then-existing approval threshold is met.

What are the lawyers drafting? If they are drafting an amendment to the amendatory provision of the CCR, then they still must have 90% of owners approve the amendment to reduce the threshold to 75%.>>> That is nearly impossible.

Owner occupancy is not relevant. Whether or not owner-investors are willing to change a provision is unknown but might be "guessed" depending on the nature of the change.

LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
I may have made some typing errors but I did write as it is written in the papers I was given .

The papers are for a rental cap I believe this is the term for reducing homes which are used as rentals and not owner occupied .

There is one lot we did not even know about the lot till someone went to question the man running the bulldozer .There is no sign up that its for sale .Its been cleared but it is a small lot and would need much work if someone wanted to place a home on it .

Currently we are unsure of the number of homes in our part of the subdivision ( its one subdivision but we are under separate PMC and have separate hoa 's alos ) I have always heard 177 but looking up the tax records I can only count 166 .Out of those according to the records at least 39 of these are non owner occupied homes as best as I can tell by the record

I hesitate to upload the papers because I am not wanting to mention the name as I have been told its against the rules anyway .

GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
The "papers" that you copied from for your comment here--is this paper from the recorded CCR? OR was this "paper" derived from the original and given to you?

The reason I am questioning this is that generally, CCR's are Developer documents and created by a lawyer. It is not typical for a lawyer, whose practice is hugely dependent on the written word, to make so many errors in the construction and details within a CCR.

I did suspect that there was a rental issue at play here when you started talking about owner-occupied units. The first thing to do, IMO, is validate the accuracy of the papers you were given. The rental cap issue is another fish to fry depending on the authority given to the Association to restrict rentals.

The fact that you are unsure how many homes are in your subdivision suggests to me that you are not in possession of your actual CCR's. CCR's will always tell you the complete description of the plat that is being indexed to the restrictions in the CCR's. Note that it is possible there are some non-voting lots in your subdivision if they are common properties for parks, outbuildings etc. These are typically not counted in the subdivision description of parcels but will be identified on the Plat. You are only concerned with Platted building parcels that can be held by owners and have a voting right attached in your HOA.

It is irrelevant if there are multiple subdivisions and HOA's unless you are additionally subject to a MASTER HOA. These facts are a material representation and are on the subdivision CCR.

It does not matter if one of the lots looks like an undersized building lot and a bulldozer is building sand castles; if it was approved originally as a buildable parcel within a subdivision, it has a vote and an assessment attached to it. If it is not buildable and has a vote attached, that is another matter altogether.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
The papers are the ones I was given at closing from the realtor
DouglasM6 (Arizona)
Posts: 724
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 9:19 AM
Article VII section 3
The covenants and restrictions of this declaration shall bind only the land specifically herein described and shall run with and bind the land .The Declaration may be amended prior to October 1 2018 by an instrument signed by the owners of not less than 90% of the lots and by the Declarant .so long as the declarant still owns any lots and there after by am instrument signed by owners of not less than 75% of the lots

This what I am questioning I have not seen any papers saying the date has been changed to this year .( 10/1/2017) no other papers just the one I see here ,

Am I reading it wrong ? To me it says in order to change this you have to have 90% of owners to sign to amend after the October 2018 then it drops to 75% .

As to owners this would be mainly owner occupied homes I would think those homes which are owned by rental company's and those which are owned by individuals which live elsewhere would not be willing to sign .

The confusing part is in bold. There is a period in there.

What I believe it means, in simpler terms, as long as the developer owns one lot, it requires affirmative vote of 90% AND the developer if the change is to happen prior to oct. 2018. Once the developer no longer owns a lot, or after oct 2018, then it requires the affirmative vote of 75% of the lot owners.

I think......LOL
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
That is what I thought yet why would a lawyer be drafting up new papers now ,I find that confusing .
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
Do the papers that you got at closing have recording information stamped on them? I am trying to find out if you are looking at the recorded document or a doctored document. What Douglas said.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Yes I can see it on the top page there is a persons name and there is a date and then some code numbers
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
This is the County recording information and it should be on every single page that you have received. Does it appear on the page with the Article that you have
Cited?
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/12/2017 4:54 PM
This is the County recording information and it should be on every single page that you have received. Does it appear on the page with the Article that you have
Cited?

No it is not on every page ,and it is not on the page with the article I wrote about and its only on 2 pages these page appear to be very similar with only slight differences .Never have been in an hoa so I have no idea what it should look like .We closed and the realtor gave us these papers ,to be honest I never really looked at the papers till after we had been in here for about a year .
At that time I asked some questions about who was on the hoa .At the time I asked no one knew who or if there was one .Found out there was 1 person but the person did not want anyone to know who they were .At a meeting last year 3 people volunteered to be on said board and the PMC placed one as the president .
Since then one has quit and not been replaced the other 3 want to keep their position .I am taking issue with 2 of the 3 because I feel that they are to busy with their regular work to be as on hand as needed right now .
I do not like the current PMC company even have sent a registered letter asking about a contract as has one member of the current hoa and we are not getting any answers .
I am a bit worried on how the meeting is going to be that we do have coming up .
I don't trust this PMC at all .
Anyway thank you for your help

Now since my papers do not have this stamping how would I get one which does ?I would think everyone here has papers similar to mine .
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
You need to validate the truthfulness of the CCR document you are looking at. All recorded pages have a recording notation on the page with the Book, Page, County ID, Date and Time the document was recorded. If you are looking at pages with no recording information, I would strongly recommend that you validate the document directly with the County Recorder.

I am not saying that anyone fiddled with the docs. All the information is not yet at hand.

Has falsification of documents been done by an HOA in the past? The answer is YES. In my experience, my HOA falsified documents on several occasions. That was proven by comparing the "published" document with the RECORDED document.
DouglasM6 (Arizona)
Posts: 724
Posted:
I'm going to step back a little here. You Hear lawyers are drafting up papers?? From Whom? Why would the lawyers have to draft up papers saying 75% when it'll go to 75% soon anyway. It is possible the developer is closing a deal on that last lot and that will remove the 90% stipulation. The lawyer, if there is one involved, may be making the changes in preparation for the turn over.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
I only know that as to more detail of which I asked I was told you will find out the meeting which is coming up exact date not yet determined .

I know one of the 3 of the ones on the hoa has made it their big goal to stop rentals .I asked how they can do it when we would need 90% right now and by this time next year it goes down to the 75% anyway.

I still don't see how this is going to work because one of the people who is a different company which I was talking with said it usually gets thrown out when taken to court .I gave up asking because they just keep saying at the meeting .

As to the lot there is no sign and I have not seen it on any real estate web site .
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
You have another problem to solve ahead of the one you posted about--and that concerns taking a close look at your documents, AS RECORDED. There is something sketchy about how you are describing your documents.

You will hear only what the Board wants you to know at the meeting. Be Prepared. It helps to know the basic answers before the questions are asked.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/12/2017 6:28 PM
You have another problem to solve ahead of the one you posted about--and that concerns taking a close look at your documents, AS RECORDED. There is something sketchy about how you are describing your documents.

You will hear only what the Board wants you to know at the meeting. Be Prepared. It helps to know the basic answers before the questions are asked.

Any idea on how to see the papers as recorded ?I am thinking that even though the PMC says if we did not get the papers at closing to tell them ,they would be no different than the papers we did get at closing .Should I see if someone who has lived here from the start has different papers ?I have no idea how the realtor got the papers or who they got them from.
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
Most counties have an online database of public documents that can be freely accessed. If you want to PM me with the county in which your subdivision is located, and give me a property address and name of subdivsion, it is quick and easy to lookup. I am [email protected]

If not online, you can go directly to the county office where records are recorded.

It is unknown where your title company got the documents you were given but I have heard that sometimes they get them from the Seller of the property and sometimes from the realtor handling the sale. People can assume that the papers they are given are real, but that is not always the case. I know this all too well from personal experience.
GenoS (Florida)
Posts: 4,276
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 10:08 AM
I may have made some typing errors but I did write as it is written in the papers I was given .

This is really hard to read. Sorry for being pedantic, but the 'period' punctuation mark should come immediately after the last word in a sentence. THEN a space. THEN the next sentence starts. You consistently get that backwards. There's never a space between the final word in a sentence and the period.

Also, why are some words separated by multiple spaces?

Sorry. I don't mean to sound like an English teacher. Your meaning is clear for the most part but it's really difficult to read the way you type.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GenoS on 10/13/2017 1:54 AM
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 10:08 AM
I may have made some typing errors but I did write as it is written in the papers I was given .

This is really hard to read. Sorry for being pedantic, but the 'period' punctuation mark should come immediately after the last word in a sentence. THEN a space. THEN the next sentence starts. You consistently get that backwards. There's never a space between the final word in a sentence and the period.

Also, why are some words separated by multiple spaces?

Sorry. I don't mean to sound like an English teacher. Your meaning is clear for the most part but it's really difficult to read the way you type.

Probably because I am not very good at typing ,and was never very good in my English classes. Sorry I am getting a little better with not having to hunt and peck than I was in the beginning.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/12/2017 6:59 PM
Most counties have an online database of public documents that can be freely accessed. If you want to PM me with the county in which your subdivision is located, and give me a property address and name of subdivsion, it is quick and easy to lookup. I am [email protected]

If not online, you can go directly to the county office where records are recorded.

It is unknown where your title company got the documents you were given but I have heard that sometimes they get them from the Seller of the property and sometimes from the realtor handling the sale. People can assume that the papers they are given are real, but that is not always the case. I know this all too well from personal experience.

Thank you I will look for it ,and if I can't find it myself I will take you up on your kind offer
DaveD3 (Michigan)
Posts: 796
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 6:37 PM
Posted By GwenG on 10/12/2017 6:28 PM
You have another problem to solve ahead of the one you posted about--and that concerns taking a close look at your documents, AS RECORDED. There is something sketchy about how you are describing your documents.

You will hear only what the Board wants you to know at the meeting. Be Prepared. It helps to know the basic answers before the questions are asked.


Any idea on how to see the papers as recorded ?I am thinking that even though the PMC says if we did not get the papers at closing to tell them ,they would be no different than the papers we did get at closing .Should I see if someone who has lived here from the start has different papers ?I have no idea how the realtor got the papers or who they got them from.

Go in person to your register of deeds.
Tell them you're looking for any restrictions that are attached to your deed and that you want to get a copy of the document(s) as they're recorded.

Personally, I would not trust that anything available online is complete or up to date.

LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Thank you I will try and find out who that is and where they are at .
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
I did some calling ,I talked to some one in the land registration office ,she told me that they only stamp the first page of the CC&R .

I am wondering though if I do have all the papers .When I asked about them changing the date from the 90 to 75 per cent .I was told a certain article and section .After pouring through what I have I cannot find that particular section .

I just find this is getting odder and odder
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
Get a Certified Copy of the documents recorded from the land registration office. Make sure you have a correct copy of your documents. Starting off a conversation with faulty documents is a waste of time.

If you are unable to find the reference, it is odd (to say the least).
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
I have to figure out who to contact about getting the CC&R .I spoke with the lady from the land registration office she did not seem to know where I could get them .

So I googled to see what CC&R should look like ,since this is my first time ever dealing with these things .
Not sure if what I was viewing is the normal way for them to look if so ours looks so bad in comparison .

Again I will try and figure out how to find them .
GenoS (Florida)
Posts: 4,276
Posted:
What is the "Land Registration Office"?

You need to find out if your county's official records are available online. Search the internet for the "Register of Deeds" in your county. You should be able to find your recorded deed there. I'd advise against paying for certified copies of things at this point. You might need those in the future, but you don't need them now. I would absolutely trust what's online until there's a good reason to think something is missing.

You should absolutely start with your deed. After all, you are trying to track down "deed restrictions" that apply to your property. The deed should give you the first clue.

"The beginning of wisdom is to call things by their proper name." - Confucius
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GenoS on 10/13/2017 10:18 PM
What is the "Land Registration Office"?

You need to find out if your county's official records are available online. Search the internet for the "Register of Deeds" in your county. You should be able to find your recorded deed there. I'd advise against paying for certified copies of things at this point. You might need those in the future, but you don't need them now. I would absolutely trust what's online until there's a good reason to think something is missing.

You should absolutely start with your deed. After all, you are trying to track down "deed restrictions" that apply to your property. The deed should give you the first clue.

"The beginning of wisdom is to call things by their proper name." - Confucius

First I really do not know what the land registration is I just found it by looking at the county web site .

Second I did manage to find the register of deed web site but all they had was things I all ready know .( property address dates of when it was bought and sold )

What I am trying to figure out is

A. The paper work I was given by the realtor at the closing is accurate

B. If there has been a change why were we not informed on this

C.Why would they waste time making a change by 1 year ?

D. After looking at many law office web sites seems that even if they somehow approve a cap its usually not held up in court
E. How do I get a accurate CC&R and Bylaws ?I thought I did have them yet the document
and article section I was told to look for is not in my papers .

F. How can a law firm write up new amendments when the papers say other wise ?

Sorry I just am not trusting anyone at this point and I am feeling like I am swimming up stream .
JohnB83 (South Carolina)
Posts: 124
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/13/2017 1:46 PM
Get a Certified Copy of the documents recorded from the land registration office. Make sure you have a correct copy of your documents. Starting off a conversation with faulty documents is a waste of time.

If you are unable to find the reference, it is odd (to say the least).

ditto ditto ditto
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
Good advice Geno. Lori originally referred to the land registration office so this term was referenced back; however, it is not term in common use. Communication is easier when all use the same commonly-understood terms.

I understand from Lori that she wasn't very good in English classes and this makes it more difficult for her.
Additionally, I think Lori has entered a strange land of specialized knowledge and is trying to get up to speed to find out how the pieces fit. I offered to do the lookup for her off the board to help speed the inquiry process and direct her to the correct path to find her resource.

@Lori: Too many questions at this early stage. You need to answer Question A. You FIRST need to have the facts; what do your documents say? You must identify the Article that your board is referring to as it is actually written/recorded. Other questions/answers will flow from that.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/12/2017 6:59 PM
Most counties have an online database of public documents that can be freely accessed. If you want to PM me with the county in which your subdivision is located, and give me a property address and name of subdivsion, it is quick and easy to lookup. I am [email protected]

If not online, you can go directly to the county office where records are recorded.

It is unknown where your title company got the documents you were given but I have heard that sometimes they get them from the Seller of the property and sometimes from the realtor handling the sale. People can assume that the papers they are given are real, but that is not always the case. I know this all too well from personal experience.

Thank you for your offer but I don't feel comfortable sharing to much personal information.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Okay my papers were given by the realtor at closing .
Secretary of hoa cited a certain article and section again which I don't seem to have,and glancing through it,I don't even think that whoever wrote them up is not good with Roman Numerals .

GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
You must go to the Registrar of Deeds for a recorded copy; apparently, there is some document that has been circulated that does not refer correctly to what your board is using. You must get the correct record and cannot rely on "verbals" and re-published and derived (possibly manipulated) reproductions.

It appears the realtor was simply passing along whatever he/she was given without authentication (authentication of a document is not a realtor's job!) Typically, a buyer would be represented by an attorney who would have gotten the recorded CCR's from the Registrar of Deeds, reviewed the documents and if you wanted, provided an opinion on the property and any restrictions.

The subdivision name would not seem to be "personal" information, IMO but it is certainly your option to decline focused help. Good luck.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Okay I found the deed of registration web site ,after much searching all I can find on that site has to do with mortgages.
I did not see anything other than that,checked every box offered on the site and could not find any cc&r on that site .

Found another site which did say search by subdivision I put mine in and nothing came up,which how I ended up calling the land deed office,who also did not know why the subdivision was not there nor anything about how to get cc&r .
GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
Ok then go the the Public Records for your county and use the subdivision name in your search. You might want to limit the search to Restrictions if there is a checkoff for that. The info is probably there if you cannot find it in the Property Records.

Sometimes counties separate their Plat books from the Official Record Books. They do that with my county. The Deeds are in the Plat Books and the restrictions are in the OR (Official Record) Books in separate databases.
GaryM15 (North Carolina)
Posts: 63
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 8:30 AM
Current papers I have read in the cc&r says you must have 90% of owners sign to make changes up till Oct.2018, yet you hear that lawyers are drafting papers which says you only need 75% of owners ,how can this be possible ? Yes I have asked and all I am told is I can ask at the next meeting .

Just seems that this could not happen ( yes I know there is suppose to be lawyers drafting something up ) yet I know not all are ethical .

Does anyone know how long a draft takes to write up ?( I would think not long ) but also again only papers I have seen say only after the date in 2018 .

Is this legal ?

I am hearing the date was changed to this year but even if it was should there not be new papers which says it has been changed ?


Here is my interpretation of the article.

The Declaration may be amended
A) prior to October 1, 2018
1) by an instrument signed by both
a) the owners of not less than 90% of the lots
b) the Declarant, so long as the declarant still owns any lots
B) there after
1) by an instrument signed by owners of not less than 75% of the lots
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/14/2017 11:41 AM
Ok then go the the Public Records for your county and use the subdivision name in your search. You might want to limit the search to Restrictions if there is a checkoff for that. The info is probably there if you cannot find it in the Property Records.

Sometimes counties separate their Plat books from the Official Record Books. They do that with my county. The Deeds are in the Plat Books and the restrictions are in the OR (Official Record) Books in separate databases.

I found the site but there is no way to search for subdivision .They give an option to search by address which I did but did not see anything new .It just shows who owns what property .
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/14/2017 11:41 AM
Ok then go the the Public Records for your county and use the subdivision name in your search. You might want to limit the search to Restrictions if there is a checkoff for that. The info is probably there if you cannot find it in the Property Records.

Sometimes counties separate their Plat books from the Official Record Books. They do that with my county. The Deeds are in the Plat Books and the restrictions are in the OR (Official Record) Books in separate databases.

I found the site but there is no way to search for subdivision .They give an option to search by address which I did but did not see anything new .It just shows who owns what property .
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GaryM15 on 10/14/2017 11:47 AM
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/12/2017 8:30 AM
Current papers I have read in the cc&r says you must have 90% of owners sign to make changes up till Oct.2018, yet you hear that lawyers are drafting papers which says you only need 75% of owners ,how can this be possible ? Yes I have asked and all I am told is I can ask at the next meeting .

Just seems that this could not happen ( yes I know there is suppose to be lawyers drafting something up ) yet I know not all are ethical .

Does anyone know how long a draft takes to write up ?( I would think not long ) but also again only papers I have seen say only after the date in 2018 .

Is this legal ?

I am hearing the date was changed to this year but even if it was should there not be new papers which says it has been changed ?


Here is my interpretation of the article.

The Declaration may be amended
A) prior to October 1, 2018
1) by an instrument signed by both
a) the owners of not less than 90% of the lots
b) the Declarant, so long as the declarant still owns any lots
B) there after
1) by an instrument signed by owners of not less than 75% of the lots

That is what I thought also which is why I am confused how they can get a law firm to write up new amendment
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
It can be done. It takes 90% to make a change until Oct 2018. You could get 90% to approve making it less prior to Oct 2018.

I under Declarant control the Declarant may well control enough vote to do so. Even if not under Declarant control, 90% voting in favor could do it.

We had a similar issue. We needed the larger majority to vote to change something to a lesser majority. We did it.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By JohnC46 on 10/14/2017 5:49 PM
It can be done. It takes 90% to make a change until Oct 2018. You could get 90% to approve making it less prior to Oct 2018.

I under Declarant control the Declarant may well control enough vote to do so. Even if not under Declarant control, 90% voting in favor could do it.

We had a similar issue. We needed the larger majority to vote to change something to a lesser majority. We did it.

I read it that way but I am being told ( on page x and article x ) that we can change it now to 75% I don't have those papers I have looked through all I have and I have no papers .

I do not want to ask the PMC because I am sure there copies would be no different than what I all ready have and there does not seem to be a way to find these papers online .
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/16/2017 11:20 AM
Posted By JohnC46 on 10/14/2017 5:49 PM
It can be done. It takes 90% to make a change until Oct 2018. You could get 90% to approve making it less prior to Oct 2018.

I under Declarant control the Declarant may well control enough vote to do so. Even if not under Declarant control, 90% voting in favor could do it.

We had a similar issue. We needed the larger majority to vote to change something to a lesser majority. We did it.


I read it that way but I am being told ( on page x and article x ) that we can change it now to 75% I don't have those papers I have looked through all I have and I have no papers .

I do not want to ask the PMC because I am sure there copies would be no different than what I all ready have and there does not seem to be a way to find these papers online .

I say you can change it now to 75% if 90% agree to it.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
I just cannot figure out how many homes are in this section of the subdivision .I counted on the tax recorder web site and that figure differs greatly from what we have always been told .
I just don't think we can get 75% or the 90% ,

I am not even sure I want to sign to cap rentals . I mean I read a lot of law pages on the issue seems they get over turned all the time .

I also can't figure out why I do not have the section that talks about the new date of making the changes .I just think its odd they would have changed it by 1 year from 2018 to 2017 .

I am just tired of how messed up it ,I am trying to figure things out but when no one else cares it sure seems like I should just give up and let whatever happen happens .

GwenG (Florida)
Posts: 669
Posted:
@Lori-you are becoming discouraged; I can hear your fatigue and confusion.

We might be able to help you find your way but not without more information.

The facts that you need are in the recorded CCR's. What you have received is documents that have not been revealed to be complete, comprehensible or true. There is only one source and that is the public record. The fact that you cannot identify provisions cited by others suggests that the documents in your possession may have been altered or tainted.

There is only one way to know and that is to identify documents recorded in the public record. Your bylaws might not be recorded and this can be problematic, but the Covenants and Restrictions MUST be on record and that is where your amendment provision is found. It is this provision that is odd and which you cannot find in your documents. This can usually be discovered easily by calling up the online public records for your homeowner association. These documents are almost always available online as most public records are now digitized. The document will reference the Plat and that will identify the # of parcels.

Remember that "what you have been told" must be discounted or given a Healthy Dose of Skepticism until you determine the facts. You do not have to "count" or guess to find this out--or wait for the next meeting.

On the subject of Caps on Rentals, it is a very sketchy deal to try to attempt an end run around homeowners who have already accepted deeds with a promise--the Covenants--that do not contain a rental limitation or put one on notice that a limitation might be placed in the future. These kinds of material, "vested property interests" typically require 100% agreement by the Owners. Sometimes, they can be passed as a voluntary restriction on owners who agree to be bound by a restriction on rentals.

Personally, I think owners are asking for trouble by passing such a rental cap amendment unless Covenants clearly permit such a cap. I see a progression in community life that will inevitably become a rental community as original buyer-owners pass on or move on... I don't believe that amendments can do anything more than stick a puny finger in the dike and at worst, cause expensive litigation that comes back to bite an HOA and cast further shadows of doubt.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Can you give me an idea of how to search for those records ?I appreciate your help and yes I am tired of all this because I feel like I am the only one who is trying to figure things out .One thing I asked about the PMC and if there was a contract .The secretary of the PMC told me she did not know ,and gave me the cell to the owner .I called and he said if I gave him my name and number he would let me know.Well this was August 31 ,well he never responded and as I was directed here sent a certified letter on September 18 was not picked up till the 27th of September .No answer so I emailed him .I do not understand other than its illegal cause why can't they answer my question ?
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,061
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By GwenG on 10/17/2017 5:29 PM

Remember that "what you have been told" must be discounted or given a Healthy Dose of Skepticism until you determine the facts.

A very true statement.

Individuals may truly believe what they are telling you is the truth and factual. Problem is, they may have been told that from another individual who was informed by a different individual, etc. etc.

Trust but verify.

DouglasM6 (Arizona)
Posts: 724
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By LoriF3 on 10/17/2017 4:44 PM
I just cannot figure out how many homes are in this section of the subdivision .I counted on the tax recorder web site and that figure differs greatly from what we have always been told .
I just don't think we can get 75% or the 90% ,

I am not even sure I want to sign to cap rentals . I mean I read a lot of law pages on the issue seems they get over turned all the time .

I also can't figure out why I do not have the section that talks about the new date of making the changes .I just think its odd they would have changed it by 1 year from 2018 to 2017 .

I am just tired of how messed up it ,I am trying to figure things out but when no one else cares it sure seems like I should just give up and let whatever happen happens .


You will probably not be able to get 90% or 75%. Most people agree to the restrictions and go about their lives.

You're right about capping rentals. It rarely stands up in court. It would probably end up a big mess with the membership holding the BOD accountable.

If I were you, and I was just a short time ago, I'd call an HOA attorney. Tell them you are a homeowner with questions, NOT a Board Member. They will probably give you 30 minutes free. If that's the case, you right down the questions you have a sheet of paper and leave room for the written answers.

Getting the recorded documents shouldn't be this hard. Maybe I'll try mine and see what I find out. I know I have the recorded ones now, but maybe I'll learn something in the process.
LoriF3 (South Carolina)
Posts: 240
Posted:
Thank you I will try and search out a HOA attorney and am still trying to figure out where those documents would be located online at .

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here