💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

AnnN3 (North Carolina)
Posts: 3
Posted:
As Developer/Declarant of s/d, we have maintained HOA responsibilities to date; however, ready to turn over to HOs. Several potential problems: HOA has not been formally registered w/SOS. Initial Protective Covenants of S/D address auto membership into HOA by virtue of buying a lot. Covenants also outline much of the By-Law type language such as dues payable, voting rights, majority needed, etc... Now that I want to move this baby to HOs, I will register with SOS, create skeleton By-Laws to jump start their efforts and step away. I have several homeowners that have not paid dues...some are several years old. I feel it's my duty to collect these funds before handing this thing off; however, without the official SOS status, do I have a leg to stand on? Or by virtue of purchase per the covenants (also their deeds are subject to this covenant language), are they required to pay up? Not sure if I've lost leverage by not filing for my status.

Further info...in view of the non-status, I've been careful to only pay for entrance lights, street lights with the HOA dues collected. All taxes on Common Areas, maintenance of entrance, gazebo area, etc... have been paid out of my pocket.

Any thoughts appreciated -
Ann
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
Ann,

Effectively, what you are describing is an unincorporated HOA.

Laws vary by State. As a developer, I expect that you have an attorney available to answer specifics regarding rights in court for incorporated and unincorporated companies.

Of course, if they were several years behind in assessments, I'm very surprised that the Association failed to record a lien on the property and, perhaps, start foreclosure proceedings by now. My Association starts the collection process through the courts after 4 months delinquency.

LarryB13 (Arizona)
Posts: 4,099
Posted:
Ann,

My advice is to change your name and move to a foreign country with no forwarding address.

You sold property with a requirement for the buyers to join an incorporated association that has never existed. You got in a little deeper by collecting assessments in the name of this non-existent entity. Now you are planning to go whole hog and try to collect unpaid assessments using the name of a non-existent corporation. These are not "potential problems." These are real problems that exist right now.

Any sober attorney would have advised you to incorporate the homeowner's association before selling the first lot. You now have a mess on your hands. Your only saving grace is that most homeowners do not know their rights well enough to sue.

AnnN3 (North Carolina)
Posts: 3
Posted:
Wow - and good morning from Chechnya! Is that far enough away, Larry?! :-)

Correct - the entity had not been created. That was my question... The membership is automatic by virtue of lot purchase per recorded covenants for s/d. No surprise there for HO. And payment to 'non-existent HOA' was automatic and prorated. It was disclosed and incorporated into their Offer to Purchase contract and collected at closing table. No surprise there for HO. Sooooo....not sure I can claim ignorance (although it's appropriate in this case), but HOs know all about the HO dues. It's just that it wasn't a legal entity. Larry, you say that DOES matter. OK... what shall I do about this? File as an entity (non-profit corp), forget the past due accounts and move on. Or shall I stay in Chechnya and never look back?

I'm looking for a way to correct my error, give this over to them and be done. I've been as fair as I could be with their meager dues by not paying anything but lights. All other is on me - Did not gouge on dues. In fact, I skipped several years - giving them a dues 'holiday' because I didn't need or want that extra money. By only paying the utilities, the additional funds were not needed; therefore, not collected. All funds collected did go into a separate HOA checking account - no commingling involved here. Just ignorance... thoughts?
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AnnN3 on 11/04/2016 6:25 AM

In fact, I skipped several years - giving them a dues 'holiday' because I didn't need or want that extra money.

That one sentence would have be very concerned if I were in your Association.

It's not your money.
It's the Associations money.

As the trustee (or only Director serving), you might not have had authority to waive assessments (normally, waiving of assessments isn't allowed as the contract, aka CC&Rs or deed restriction, require that members pay them. Unless the CC&Rs authorized you to waive those assessments,you exceeded your authority as a trustee.

Additionally, you likely did a disservice to the members of the Association by keeping the assessments artificially lower then they should have been and the failure to establish a Reserve fund. This will require a hefty increase in assessments.

There are unincorporated HOAs. It's not smart to do that, but they do exist.
I expect that you have a TIN for the Association (otherwise, you wouldn't have been able to open a bank account in the name of the HOA).

My advice, obtain the services of an attorney versed in HOA and corporate law to aid you in transitioning control to the members.

As for reference material on transitioning control, see the following threads:

Subject: HOA transition from developer control to homeowner control 2008 thread

Subject: HOA Transition from developer

Additionally, see:

Best Practices Report #7 - Transition a 55 page pdf document from the Foundation for Community Association Research

Developer/Homeowner Transition: A Guide To Success from Neighborhood link

TRANSITION PLAN a 10 page pdf document developed by an HOA (specifically for their HOA but still good info)

For the future:

Best Practices Reports links to all the reports by the Foundation for Community Association Research

AnnN3 (North Carolina)
Posts: 3
Posted:
Good info and links, TimB4. Will review, print for file and get it together. Thanks for your help

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here