💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

JdW (Texas)
Posts: 40
Posted:
(Texas) - but I'm just looking for general information for the Board, which we'd let later with attorney.

Large condo complex (> 100 1 bedrooms) is 90% rentals and we active owners and Board want to implement policies to get better control of to whom and how the place is rented.

Can the HOA require things such as:

Criminal background checks? In order to enforce no serious occupants with serious crime records policy.
Copies of applications with photo IDs of all adult renters to keep on file with property manager?
Copies of leases to keep on file?
Occupancy limits? (As long as complies with laws- e.g., we have 400 square feet units with 6 people in them.)

Any comments related to this general subject matter appreciated. We're trying to clean the place up more directly than relying on fines. We're also looking at limits on renting by new owners, such as not allow renting of the units the first 24 months of ownership in order to increase owner occupancy.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
My opinion is the HOA is a third party to the rental agreement and thus should stay out of it. However, that doesn't mean the HOA is powerless. I think the HOA should require that ALL owners put into their lease agreements that tenants MUST follow the HOA rules. Violation of those rules then can allow the owner to take action to evict the tenant. It levels the playing field for all. The HOA can contact the owner if there is a violation, the owner can then address it with the tenant. If that tenant doesn't correct, then the owner can evict within 30 days or whatever your state allows. Otherwise, if this clause is NOT in their lease agreement, then the owner is powerless to take action for eviction due to no violation of the lease agreement has occurred.

Former HOA President
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,062
Posted:
Jd,

What can and can not be done varies by State.

Typically, a condominium association can get away with more on rentals then a home owners association can.

Requesting/requiring copies of leases typically isn't an issue for either association.

Copies of the application, I doubt it (check with an attorney to be sure).

Occupancy limits, your local zoning department should already have that covered. Find out what they are and call them in when needed.
Otherwise, the Association may be facing legal action trying to enforce.

Criminal background checks - perhaps (something to check with an attorney about).
You will need definitive guidelines on what rules someone out and what doesn't (not having such guidelines can leave the Association open for legal challenges).
There is a lot of discussion with this issue in FL (do an internet search on Condo criminal background checks)
KerryL1 (California)
Posts: 14,550
Posted:
Tim's advice looks good. If we do amend our CC&Rs, we intend to place an occupancy limit on our condo units. Probably what's called 2 + 1. this 2 per bedroom plus 1 more or 3 in your situation. But I wouldn't try to enforce such a policy unless your municipality has a law about this (as you mention). The make a rule a bout it following the procedures in your bylaws or in TX law.

We have about 30% rentals and we do jump right on the Owners when their renters don't follow our CC&Rs & rules. Usually works just fine. We had parking issue with one renter for about a month, but the minute the Owner was called to hearing & fined $150 with the promise of doubling for future violations, the violations stopped immediately.

I do think that Tim's right--you need to contact an attorney about certain matters.
JdW (Texas)
Posts: 40
Posted:

Occupancy limits, your local zoning department should already have that covered. Find out what they are and call them in when needed.
Otherwise, the Association may be facing legal action trying to enforce.


The only occupancy law is that no more than 4 unaffiliated individuals may live in a dwelling, which was primarily aimed at single family homes. However, apartment industry standard is the 2+1 policy based on bedroom count. Do you have an opinion on if the owners or the Board (whichever is required) modified the condo cc&rs/bylaws to make it 2+1, that such would be adequate for restricting occupancy? Again, we'd run all this through an attorney.

KerryL1 (California)
Posts: 14,550
Posted:
Not in the legal biz, but if you can get enough Owners to vote to amend your CC&Rs to a 2 + 1 situation, should be no reason it wouldn't be legal.

If you're going to the trouble & expense to amend your CC&Rs, you may as well implement other changes. I don't know, for instance, if you can legally get copies of leases.

I have heard in CA that HOAs actually can evict renters if in their CC&Rs. Very thorough paper trail needed, of course. But I don't know about TX.

We do require that all a occupants are registered with us and their auto & motorcycle info too, plus emergency phone numbers.

Our CC&Rs permit us to remove common area amenity privileges for infractions and that has worked with delinquent Owners, but you need to have amenities worth removing and a way to enforce it. We, for example, have deactivated access fob to the pool & gym.
JamesG11 (Florida)
Posts: 118
Posted:
Controlling rentals is one of the most important aspects of association management, in my opinion. I have witnessed many communities degenerate over time as owner-occupied communities became more and more populated by renters.

When the community I recently moved from was turned over from the developer in April 2007, one of the very first things we did (I was elected to the first homeowner-controlled Board there) was solicit the owners to enact an amendment to the CC&Rs that, among other things, limited rentals to no more than 5% of the homes in the community at any one time.

We also required criminal background checks on all prospective tenants, copies of all proposed leases to be furnished to our CAM, mandatory clauses to be included in each lease (e.g., authorizing the Association to collect delinquent assessments from the tenants directly), and a number of other things.

Occupancy limits are tricky, and raise potential Fair Housing concerns. However, your local city/county codes should speak to this issue and should be consulted. Additionally, federal law generally supports limitations on occupancy of no more than two adults per bedroom.

This is an area of association regulation where it is essential to get experienced counsel involved lest you create more problems than you solve. Just Google "Fairing Housing - lawsuit - association" to get a sense of what I am talking about....

Good luck!

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here