JayM11 (Florida)
Posts: 14
Posts: 14
Posted:
In our community we have architectural guidelines. Some things in the guidelines are very specific, i.e. Fencing: must be made of wood or PVC not more than X' tall. Walls must be PVC or Woodsiding with PVC or Wood trim. Other things, such as the porch railings are not mentioned at all.
There are other guidelines such as, every home must have roofing with exposed rafter tails.. There are 3 of 29 homes that comply. There are various other rules that have clearly, never been enforced.
I have done major upgrades to my home over the past few years. I am now looking to replace the rotted porch railing with wood and a stainless cable. The style I am requested to use is not present in our small community of 29 homes. (Beachside) This style however is very common in homes around us and certainly not a deviation from architectural norms. I then submitted the proper forms with the ARC chairman.
The ARC responded by saying that the covenants forbid use of anything except wood or PVC. I told them that the guidelines make no mention specific to porch railings only fences and wall trim. They said it was inferred by referring to trim. They also told me that if they made such an exception, it would be a slippery slope and could potentially allow others to do whatever they want. I feel I am being unfairly singled out because my home is the first one you see in the community when you drive in and personal feelings and taste are coming into play. I am frustrated by it because I took a dump of a home and in the end, added value indirectly to everyone in the community.
So question is, how specific do the ARC guidelines have to be?
Thank you!
There are other guidelines such as, every home must have roofing with exposed rafter tails.. There are 3 of 29 homes that comply. There are various other rules that have clearly, never been enforced.
I have done major upgrades to my home over the past few years. I am now looking to replace the rotted porch railing with wood and a stainless cable. The style I am requested to use is not present in our small community of 29 homes. (Beachside) This style however is very common in homes around us and certainly not a deviation from architectural norms. I then submitted the proper forms with the ARC chairman.
The ARC responded by saying that the covenants forbid use of anything except wood or PVC. I told them that the guidelines make no mention specific to porch railings only fences and wall trim. They said it was inferred by referring to trim. They also told me that if they made such an exception, it would be a slippery slope and could potentially allow others to do whatever they want. I feel I am being unfairly singled out because my home is the first one you see in the community when you drive in and personal feelings and taste are coming into play. I am frustrated by it because I took a dump of a home and in the end, added value indirectly to everyone in the community.
So question is, how specific do the ARC guidelines have to be?
Thank you!