💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I am on the board of my HOA located in myrtle beach SC. I have a boat 19 ft bayliner that is in my driveway, on a boat trailer. The Hoa has give me gruff about it sighting this section below. My answer to this is no where in this section does it state boat. The HOA hangs on the word trailer, being the boat is on trailer. My problem is the trailer in which it speaks I do not think that it is the type of trailer intended. My other statement back to the HOA is that it also states no commercial Vehicle, but yet we have three work trucks will wraps on them by three seprate home owners , but nothing is said. My final point to the HOA is that we have 2 Police Officers that have drive home vehicles, these two are commercial vehicle, but who is going to tell them that you cannot park at your house with your police vehicle. Can someone tell me if I am wrong for thinking this way or I am in the right? below is the section

Section 15 trailers. etc.: No trailer, motor home, tent, barn, camper, commercial vehicle, tree house, or other similar out-building or structure shall be placed on any lot any time either temporarily or permanently.
JackE1 (Indiana)
Posts: 26
Posted:
IMO you're wrong, a trailer is a trailer no matter what it's hauling. Now technically I suppose under that section you could store the Boat as long as it wasn't on the trailer. The police vehicles IMO are not commercial vehicles, they are public service vehicles. The cars with wraps are commercial vehicles and the owners should either park them in their garage or cover them in the driveway.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I will agree that a trailer is a trailer and that police vehicle is a public service vehicle. I do want to mention that we are talking an hoa of about 68 homes. Yes i say the same thing that i can have boat but not the trailer. So if i put the boat up on bricks and store it that works looks crappy and brings down the nieghborhood. But then again having it on a trailer and covered apartly is worse. Also would like to add i have spoke to my surround neighbors that have no issue with. I respect all opinions and tgank you for the reply
JackE1 (Indiana)
Posts: 26
Posted:
Steve you if enough of your fellow homeowners agree, you could always amend the documents to specifically allow boats on trailers. If you look at the way the section is written I'm sure it was to disallow anything not a motor vehicle and it is unfortunate that boats were not specifically mentioned.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Its possible there is a state law exempting the police vehicle from any rules your HOA might make. Basically, the police can go anywhere they want.

As for the boat, its obvious the issue is with the trailer. Simply remove the trailer and put the boat on the lawn, and people wont have an issue. (wink)

Solution: Put your boat/trailer in your garage.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I would put in garage it just does not fit. Mind i dont care about the police cars or the trucks just think it is dumb all around when they pay my tax then they can make demands.
JackE1 (Indiana)
Posts: 26
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/20/2014 4:47 PM
I would put in garage it just does not fit. Mind i dont care about the police cars or the trucks just think it is dumb all around when they pay my tax then they can make demands.

Steve I assume no one was holding a gun to your head when you sat down and signed that you agreed to be bound by the covenants. If you wanted to keep the boat in your yard, you should have purchased a home that allowed it. You said in your original post that you were on the Board, how do you expect to hold others accountable when you are in violation? The old: Do as I say not as I do rule?
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Just so you know smart ass when i bought my home there was only 3 houses in the whole place, and was told that it was a very lax hoa. Problem only started when the home owners took over. Last it was insane to the point that the board did not want kids riding bikes down the road as hoa was in fear of being suied for anything. Yes i am on the board and voted there by the homeowners that dont want to see someone with nothing better to do but help feed their ego by being president of hoa continue the bs. I have no shame to say i think hoa is bs. Plenty of neighborhoods do just fine without hoa. But yes i will say noone put a gun to my head. I bought into the place and know they had hoa that is my fault. But did not know that assholes where going to move in.
JackE1 (Indiana)
Posts: 26
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/20/2014 7:38 PM
Just so you know smart ass when i bought my home there was only 3 houses in the whole place, and was told that it was a very lax hoa. Problem only started when the home owners took over. Last it was insane to the point that the board did not want kids riding bikes down the road as hoa was in fear of being suied for anything. Yes i am on the board and voted there by the homeowners that dont want to see someone with nothing better to do but help feed their ego by being president of hoa continue the bs. I have no shame to say i think hoa is bs. Plenty of neighborhoods do just fine without hoa. But yes i will say noone put a gun to my head. I bought into the place and know they had hoa that is my fault. But did not know that assholes where going to move in.

Why is it that you buy a five hundred dollar used car and you have to sign a paper stating that anything the sales man said was void unless it was in writing but people are willing to take someone's word on something like the purchase of a home?

BTW - I like your mindset asshole = someone who wants to follow the rules rather than the someone who thinks the rules don't apply to them. As I stated before, if you can convince enough of your fellow homeowners, you can amend the covenants to allow boats, trailer and all.
JoK2 (California)
Posts: 198
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/20/2014 7:38 PM
Just so you know smart ass when i bought my home there was only 3 houses in the whole place, and was told that it was a very lax hoa. Problem only started when the home owners took over. Last it was insane to the point that the board did not want kids riding bikes down the road as hoa was in fear of being suied for anything. Yes i am on the board and voted there by the homeowners that dont want to see someone with nothing better to do but help feed their ego by being president of hoa continue the bs. I have no shame to say i think hoa is bs. Plenty of neighborhoods do just fine without hoa. But yes i will say noone put a gun to my head. I bought into the place and know they had hoa that is my fault. But did not know that assholes where going to move in.

I take great offense to your calling us names. Your in the wrong. Period. Suck it up and get rid of the trailer or move to a neighborhood that does not have an HOA. We read our covenants, you didn't and now you call us names. America, the land of the free to be irresponsible and lay the blame on your neighbor instead of yourself.

Speaking for all the HOA A** holes who read their contract before they signed it.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
Plenty of neighborhoods do just fine without hoa.


Those neighborhoods dont have shared expenses such as roads, street lights, etc. They are owned by the town. For everyone else who does, a HOA is required.
MikeL13 (South Carolina)
Posts: 83
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/20/2014 7:38 PM
I bought into the place and know they had hoa that is my fault. But did not know that assholes where going to move in.

I find it interesting that you see the owners moving in who want to follow the CCR's and maintain the standard of the development are the problem and not the person you see in the mirror every morning.

Seems to me this just may be another troll, or maybe one of those "I was here first types" so it should be my way.

Mike
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I understand how that may seem that i am just whinning. I guess it would not be as big of a issue if the former board was not such a big hammer on the community. Like i said we are not a big community and in one year the former board set out 65 fines in one year. It has left a very bad taste in our mouths. Others in the community asked me to run just to keep the former board from getting fine happy. So i guess i am being such a jerk about it, is simply due to a feeling that we have retired people that moved in and want it to be a 55+ community.
JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
aaaaah

now I understand

there is NOTHING worse than the bored geezer police

let them have their wall and hide themselves away

good-bye ~ good luck ~ GOOD RIDDANCE

RAH RAH SIS BOOM BAH, HOPA ALL THE WAY

MikeL13 (South Carolina)
Posts: 83
Posted:
Maybe the cause of your concerns is that you based your purchase on how lax the CCR's were enforced instead of the opposite.

I'm more on the side of following CCR's so it does not create issues in the future due to lax enforcement. I don't agree with all that is written in our founding documents but overall it is a good community because of them. I had a good, although not complete, understanding of the "rules and regulations" and made a purchase decision based on that.

Earlier in out history drunk driving, although against the law in many areas, was something that was somewhat overlooked. Later enforcement was not warmly welcomed by everyone. I believe we are much better off with stricter enforcement of the "rules" to the betterment of the many rather than the few.

Mike
PitA1
Posts: 222
Posted:
Trailers in driveways are banned.

You own a trailer.

You would LIKE to park same in driveway.

DOH

? what is the issue ?

Oh, yeah, you signed a contract which includes a restriction !

Now you are moaning and whining and squirming and looking for validation.

CAVEAT EMPTOR
MikeL13 (South Carolina)
Posts: 83
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By PitA1 on 05/23/2014 5:06 AM
Trailers in driveways are banned.

You own a trailer.

You would LIKE to park same in driveway.

DOH

? what is the issue ?

Oh, yeah, you signed a contract which includes a restriction !

Now you are moaning and whining and squirming and looking for validation.

CAVEAT EMPTOR

Now there's the JohnB we all know and love. ;-)
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Wow this was not helpful in the least. Filled with people that live to be on the hoa boards. Sorry life is that boring to have to put all that energy on what other people do just to full that empty void. Thank you to the people that actualy said helpful stuff. I should have know better to go on a hoa board and try to think anyone would do anything but defend hoa.
MikeL13 (South Carolina)
Posts: 83
Posted:
Sorry SteveM. The hoa is there to protect the development, not for those who would prefer not to follow the conditions they signed up for. If you came to this forum to find a way around those conditions, from what I have seen in my readings, you are in the wrong place.

How about someone builds a tar paper shack in your community? Are you willing to fight for them to "break the rules"? Or is it only OK for you.

Mike
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
No i would fight for all even the tar shack. See again that seems to be the hoa mindset god forbid there is no hoa how could people possiable be able to take care of their own property without someone butting in to tell them what is best for them.plenty of places survive without a hoa and their are bot gettos.
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Steve

There is something to be said for living somewhere were you can build, park, landscape, paint, etc. whatever you feel like. This is perfectly acceptable.

What is not acceptable is moving into an HOA and agreeing to abide by the rules you signed for then not abiding by such rules.

You signed, agreed, etc. to do so, so man up and do so or move on down the road.

JeffT2 (Iowa)
Posts: 880
Posted:
Steve,

Can you get enough support from other owners to change things? Get the board to ease up, or elect a majority of board members, or recall your board, or actually amend your CC&Rs? If yes, go for it.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I am so sick hearing this you signed a contract. I get that i am not saying i didn't. I will play ball that is not the problem. I am shedding light on how silly hoa can be when their egos. When i moved in the the building company rab the hoa as we were not at 80 percent full. There was never any issues. The only time that the hoa even got involved was when a neighbor would call and complain. In the three years the builder had hoa a total of 4 warning letters went out and zero fines. It has been one whole year since it was taken over by the community and in one year 65 letters go out. All of a sudden everyone went nuts in the neighborhood? Letters ranging from mailbox does match ti the garage door open to long. Come on!!! I think hoa does have their place. But maybe i am so willing to challenge them is simply because they are pushing way to much. But then again i guess if you give anyone to much rope they will hang soon or later.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
How can you go about recall the board. Cause we did have a hoa meeting for tge new board to try and get these guys out and at meeting we did. But tgen the meeting got heated and meeting was closed out. Later they did a proxy vote by mail and said the votes at the meeting did not count. Why that makes me mad is that half the people have no idea who anybody is. Funny thung is that the three members that seem to be issues all went around soliciting votes. Which is funny since there is a no soliciting by law. And tgey just got back in. Then when we had first meeting five board members. The meeting starts with one nominating the other for president and the other seconding it. So me and the other fellow that are not happy about all this will be out voted everytime. Really thought there should be a hoa meeting with neighborhood and any of the board members that want to run for prez should get to speak to the neighborhood and let them decide. For the people by the people not for peopke by the board.
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Steve

Proxy voting is legal in SC as is the right to solicit such. The just out hustled you. While you were complaining, they got out and worked for the votes. You could do the same thing rather then just pi$$ and moan.

Nothing finer then hustling a hustler.

One note about proxies. The latest one is the one that counts. Someone gets my proxy voting YES and dated April 1. You come along and get a proxy from me voting NO and dated April 2. The NO is the one that counts. The one saying YES means nothing. That is how to out hustle a hustler.

AnnH6 (Florida)
Posts: 27
Posted:
1)You could try to get your documents changed by a majority vote. Change the restrictions and then you can park your boat and trailer on your driveway.
2) You could rent a parking space in a boat storage area and store your boat there.
3) You could sell your home and move to another house where there are no deed restrictions and keep your boat and trailer parked at your home.
4) You could possibly remodel your home and extend your garage so that you can keep your boat and trailer parked in your own garage. My neighbor is doing this- losing a room in their home so they can extend the garage by enough feet to park their boat in their garage.

JoK2 (California)
Posts: 198
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM
I am so sick hearing this you signed a contract. I get that i am not saying i didn't. I will play ball that is not the problem. I am shedding light on how silly hoa can be when their egos. When i moved in the the building company rab the hoa as we were not at 80 percent full. There was never any issues. The only time that the hoa even got involved was when a neighbor would call and complain. In the three years the builder had hoa a total of 4 warning letters went out and zero fines. It has been one whole year since it was taken over by the community and in one year 65 letters go out. All of a sudden everyone went nuts in the neighborhood? Letters ranging from mailbox does match ti the garage door open to long. Come on!!! I think hoa does have their place. But maybe i am so willing to challenge them is simply because they are pushing way to much. But then again i guess if you give anyone to much rope they will hang soon or later.

Your not the first one, nor will you be the last to come to this forum to get support, but you nor the rest of the HOA cry baby BS won't get the support your looking for. This forum is titles HOAtalk, not antiHOAtalk.
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,060
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

I am so sick hearing this you signed a contract. I get that i am not saying i didn't.

Good to know. Often the regular posters read that individuals don't believe that they agreed to be part of a contract. We are human and sometimes don't always read everything before responding. It shouldn't happen that way, but it does (I've done it myself).

Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

I am shedding light on how silly hoa can be when their egos.

I agree. If you take the time to read most of the court cases surrounding HOA's, most of the cases, in my opinion, could have been avoided if ego's or personality conflicts were not involved in the decision making. Unfortunately, it does happen.

This is why it's important that the entire membership be involved in the running of the Association, as it's the membership that are the checks and balances for the Boards.

In my opinion, minimum participation is attending the annual meeting (or send a representative in your place if you can't attend) and actually casting a vote. Unfortunately, just as it can be comical (silly) when Boards allow egos and personality conflicts to enter into decisions, it can become disastrous if membership apathy removes the checks and balances (by lack of participation).

Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

It has been one whole year since it was taken over by the community and in one year 65 letters go out. All of a sudden everyone went nuts in the neighborhood?

Well, to be honest, typically the Declarant won't be as forceful in ensuring compliance as their main interest is selling houses.

When you say that everyone went nuts, are implying that it was the members of the Board, the individual members or both that went nuts?

Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

Letters ranging from mailbox does match ti the garage door open to long. Come on!!!

So are you upset because the violations are being identified and brought into compliance?

or

Are you upset because the members chose to ignore the CC&Rs and now have to deal with the consequences of that choice?

or

Are you upset over the methodology used to enforce the covenants?

Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

But maybe i am so willing to challenge them is simply because they are pushing way to much.

So perhaps it is the methodology used.

Perhaps you could volunteer to serve on the enforcement committee and implement a different methodology.

Quote:
Posted By SteveM24 on 05/23/2014 6:39 PM

But then again i guess if you give anyone to much rope they will hang soon or later.

To look at that statement from a different perspective and to use an analogy, it appears that sometimes everybody knows what the speed limit is, chooses to go faster than the posted limit and then complains when the police set up cameras to catch the speeders. Those who chose to speed, are ticked at the police rather than admitting that they made a poor decision. If they believe that the speed limit should be higher, then they should have lobbied for a higher limit rather then simply choosing to ignore the limit established.

Or in other words, don't shoot the messenger.

If you believe that a covenant or rule should be changed, gather support and propose the change. If you have enough support, the documents can easily be changed to what you believe is more appropriate.
PitA1
Posts: 222
Posted:
Tim,

as usual

a voice of logic and sanity

SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Tim i would like to thank you. You clearly do not agree with me on all, but i can respect that. You really are the first person to come and voice your thought without acting to far one way or another.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
Tim i would like to thank you. You clearly do not agree with me on all, but i can respect that. You really are the first person to come and voice your thought without acting to far one way or another.
JoK2 (California)
Posts: 198
Posted:
Yes, Tim is one of the strongest voices of reason on this forum and I hope that one day when I read someone's post, I can look the other way when the OP calls fellow HOA members names, or states accusations etc. It seems that a lot of the people that come on here for help are perfectly ok with calling other HOA members names, throwing accusations around and thinking they can bully their point of view around, which is usually wrong. BUT when they hear blunt advice or that they need to stop crying, they can't handle it and turn on the people giving the advice they seek. Somehow Tim sees through that and that is to be applauded!

Yes, I hope that one day I too can ignore that and still be able to offer help like Tim has. I have learned quite a bit from several people on this board and you will as well.
JimbB (Hawaii)
Posts: 42
Posted:
I LOVE THIS IDEA!
JanieF (South Carolina)
Posts: 9
Posted:
hi steve, i also live in good old Myrtle Beach, SC. Our covenants read the same as yours. Our neighborhood is being fined up the ying yang for the boats and trailers. And it is being upheld by our HOA lawyer. Sorry, i know how you feel.
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
Our neighborhood is being fined up the ying yang for the boats and trailers.


There are plenty of storage places that can handle boats. If your HOA says no boats, it means no boats.

When I want to fire my gun, I go to the gun range. I dont try and turn my property into a gun range and upset others.
SteveM24 (South Carolina)
Posts: 12
Posted:
I am past this but that last thing about a gun is one of the most stupid comparsions i ever heard. The last time i check i never heard on stray boats and trailers in a community killing anyone. So dumb all i can do is laugh.
PitA1
Posts: 222
Posted:
the 'old folk' have strokes and heart attacks when seen parked in driveways

not to mention 'knip fits'

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here