💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I buried this question in my last post. It is directed toward those who advise to "sell" the HOA home if you do not like it or those who want to sell. There seems to be the issue of "If I find out there is an HOA I would not purchase".

My question to you is then what information are you going to supply to your potential buyer? Some states do require the rules be handed over at closing by the seller. However, most seem to think they should have more than that when deciding to buy. Well, do you want to be required to disclose all those issues that you feel is crooked by your HOA or reveal your HOA status good or bad?

Those who are suing or considering suits against their HOA, do you know that has to be disclosed to financial insitutions? If you get the laws to pass that you are fighting for, then that has to be revealed. Is that something you are comfortable disclosing?

You also have to factor in if you are suing your HOA you can not sell or you will lose your case. If you are no longer a HOA member, then you are no longer sufering damages from something you do not belong to. The court would most likely toss your case out as no longer being valid. However, the lawsuit would still have to be noted on the PUD form until ruled upon. So if you sue, you can not sale anyways if you want to win your case.

I just wanted to point out the otherside besides just saying it is the buyer. The buyer is informed by the information they are given or granted. So you as a seller, can now see how the law works so that it can protect you as well in regardsbof what information is released.

Former HOA President
JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
the PUD form is a banker's requirement

it is NOT a sales requirement

a buyer performing 'due diligence' (caveat emptor) would request (or have his attorney request) the estoppel letter + ?special assessment contemplated?

some states (because of all this toric ka-ka have enacted legislation in an attempt to protect the buyer further)

as Abraham Lincoln said:

'man who represents self has fool for client'
DavidW5 (North Carolina)
Posts: 565
Posted:
The Virginia Property Owners Association Act contains the following disclosure requirements. If a potential buyer reads all of that material and then goes ahead with the purchase, one can assume he is aware of the association and its regulations:

55-509.4. Contract disclosure statement; right of cancellation.

A. Subject to the provisions of subsection A of § 55-509.10, a person selling a lot shall disclose in the contract that (i) the lot is located within a development that is subject to the Virginia Property Owners' Association Act (§ 55-508 et seq.); (ii) the Act requires the seller to obtain from the property owners' association an association disclosure packet and provide it to the purchaser; (iii) the purchaser may cancel the contract within three days after receiving the association disclosure packet or being notified that the association disclosure packet will not be available; (iv) if the purchaser has received the association disclosure packet, the purchaser has a right to request an update of such disclosure packet in accordance with subsection H of § 55-509.6 or subsection C of § 55-509.7, as appropriate; and (v) the right to receive the association disclosure packet and the right to cancel the contract are waived conclusively if not exercised before settlement.

§ 55-509.5. Contents of association disclosure packet; delivery of packet.

A. The association shall deliver, within 14 days after receipt of a written request and instructions by a seller or his authorized agent, an association disclosure packet as directed in the written request. The information contained in the association disclosure packet shall be current as of a date specified on the association disclosure packet. If hand or electronically delivered, the written request is deemed received on the date of delivery. If sent by United States mail, the request is deemed received six days after the postmark date. An association disclosure packet shall contain the following:

1. The name of the association and, if incorporated, the state in which the association is incorporated and the name and address of its registered agent in Virginia;

2. A statement of any expenditure of funds approved by the association or the board of directors that shall require an assessment in addition to the regular assessment during the current year or the immediately succeeding fiscal year;

3. A statement, including the amount of all assessments and any other mandatory fees or charges currently imposed by the association, together with any post-closing fee charged by the common interest community manager, if any, and associated with the purchase, disposition, and maintenance of the lot and to the right of use of common areas, and the status of the account;

4. A statement of whether there is any other entity or facility to which the lot owner may be liable for fees or other charges;

5. The current reserve study report or summary thereof, a statement of the status and amount of any reserve or replacement fund, and any portion of the fund allocated by the board of directors for a specified project;

6. A copy of the association's current budget or a summary thereof prepared by the association, and a copy of its statement of income and expenses or statement of its financial position (balance sheet) for the last fiscal year for which such statement is available, including a statement of the balance due of any outstanding loans of the association;

7. A statement of the nature and status of any pending suit or unpaid judgment to which the association is a party and that either could or would have a material impact on the association or its members or that relates to the lot being purchased;

8. A statement setting forth what insurance coverage is provided for all lot owners by the association, including the fidelity bond maintained by the association, and what additional insurance would normally be secured by each individual lot owner;

9. A statement that any improvement or alteration made to the lot, or uses made of the lot or common area assigned thereto are or are not in violation of the declaration, bylaws, rules and regulations, architectural guidelines and articles of incorporation, if any, of the association;

10. A statement setting forth any restriction, limitation, or prohibition on the right of a lot owner to place a sign on the owner's lot advertising the lot for sale;

11. A statement setting forth any restriction, limitation, or prohibition on the right of a lot owner to display any flag on the owner's lot, including but not limited to reasonable restrictions as to the size, place, and manner of placement or display of such flag and the installation of any flagpole or similar structure necessary to display such flag;

12. A statement setting forth any restriction, limitation, or prohibition on the right of a lot owner to install or use solar energy collection devices on the owner's property;

13. A copy of the current declaration, the association's articles of incorporation and bylaws, and any rules and regulations or architectural guidelines adopted by the association;

14. A copy of any approved minutes of the board of directors and association meetings for the six calendar months preceding the request for the disclosure packet;

15. A copy of the notice given to the lot owner by the association of any current or pending rule or architectural violation;

16. A copy of the fully completed one-page cover sheet developed by the Common Interest Community Board pursuant to § 54.1-2350;

17. Certification that the association has filed with the Common Interest Community Board the annual report required by § 55-516.1, which certification shall indicate the filing number assigned by the Common Interest Community Board, and the expiration date of such filing; and

18. A statement indicating any known project approvals currently in effect issued by secondary mortgage market agencies.
JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
(ii) the Act requires the seller to obtain from the property owners' association an association disclosure packet and provide it to the purchaser


thank you for info re: Virginia

there is NO requirement for the HOA to supply info to the buyer

however, the info must be given to the member/seller

as per the act it is the seller's responsibility to properly inform the buyer

not to play lawyer, but, what is the statute of limitations on 'voiding' the sale for improper/non disclosure ? !
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
John,

I direct you to the posts I made earlier in another recent thread:

Quote:
Posted By TimB4 on 02/13/2014 4:34 PM
Chris,

That may indeed be the way it is in NJ. However, that is simply not true for Associations in other States.

"But where are the owner's rights to know before they buy? (Silence.) "

In VA, it's located in the law, specifically VA § 55-509.5 and the buyers responsibility to stay focused and ask for information prior to entering into agreements.

Just because your State doesn't have a law similar to NJ, it doesn't prevent a potential buyer from asking for additional information. Perhaps you can lobby your State representative for adopting a similar set of laws that VA (or any other State) has.

Quote:
Posted By TimB4 on 02/13/2014 7:43 PM
Posted By ChrisA13 on 02/13/2014 7:10 PM

A. The association shall deliver, within 14 days after receipt of a written request and instructions by a seller or his authorized agent, an association disclosure packet as directed in the written request.

It seems to give the SELLER the right to request the information. Not the buyer. Am I reading the wrong thing here?


Nope, you are correct. This is because only the seller, who is a member of the Association, has the right to request the information. However, if you read other portions of the VA Property Owners' Association Act, you will see that the Association must comply with any request for a disclosure package within 14 days. Additionally, per this same act, the seller can void the purchase contract with no penalty within 3 days after receiving the packet from the seller.

Quote:
Posted By ChrisA13 on 02/13/2014 7:10 PM

Also, "asking" for information is great. What is the seller says they don't have any? I know for certain my COA would never release any information to anyone, especially not a non-owner.


It is standard practice in housing transactions in VA for this information to be released. The sellers realtor will often be the one who initiates the request on behalf of the member because they know it's part of VA Real Estate laws to provide a disclosure package to potential buyers. Additionally, if the buyer is using an agent, that agent will also make sure that a package is received.

As I posted earlier, the seller (or the sellers agent) is the one that requests the package because only the member of the Association has a right to obtain that information.

Quote:
Posted By ChrisA13 on 02/13/2014 7:10 PM

s per lobbying, that's a great idea. Of course, I think I've made it quite clear that NJ doesn't want to give owners power.


All you have to do is find one member of the State legislature who is sympathetic to the issue. Perhaps you should start with the drafters of the NJ Common Interest Real Property Act. It was introduced in 1996, so it's possible that some of those sponsors of the act are still serving. Check with the NJ legislature site to identify who the sponsors were.


CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
Despite the beliefs of some posters that many states don't have requirements that the seller provide the buyer with certain documents, I see that VA does have such legislation. So does CA and the list is similar to the one David supplied us--only longer (no surprise!), e.g., disclosure about any restriction on rentals.

The HOA must provide the documents to the seller and the HOA can charge the seller for copies. But many of the docs can be sent to the seller electrically. The seller must provide these to the prospective buyer 10 days prior to the close of escrow (done by title or escrow officers in CA, not attorneys).

I do not know what other states have these requirements. Say, Melissa, you were prez of one HOA and now, I think, reside in another HOA. What are the laws, if any, in Alabama? Please cite the statute title & numbers if there are any.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I don't post laws or references to them. I do NOT represent myself as a lawyer nor do I play lawyer. The reason being is that I do NOT practice law and am NOT qualified to interpt the law properly. That is up to a paid legal practitioner of the law. I can't verify that any laws/links are accuracy of them. They of a google search or other source that I would not trust. It's best for the professionals to handle.

I can tell you what I know from experience and my education. Which I did go to college and took some law classes. Another reason why I know better than to post law references. I am okay with other doing it. However, my personal preference is to never do this. It's my opinion and advice... Take it or leave it. A law reference isn't going to change your opinion of that.

Former HOA President
JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
the HOA is NOT the seller and has no obligation to provide documents

the HOA supplies the docs to the seller/member ....period
CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
You're correct, JohnB26. In CA the HOA only is required to provide the materials to the seller. It's the seller who's required to provide them to the prospective buyers.

I can understand your preference, Melissa, to never cite the laws. But, I'd advise others who read these posts to count on much more than simple personal opinions and personal experience to help them understand the issues.

I just finished a month of jury service for a fascinating civil trial. If jurors had relied solely on their personal experience and personal opinions, the verdict would have been a disaster. Why? Because the topic was one none of us knew anything about except gossip and rumor. And both sides proved the latter was wrong. There needs to be some sound foundation for forming opinions beyond just personal experiences and feelings..

JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
I do not know what SC says about which documents have to be turned over but I can assure you of one thing.

Were I selling my home (in an HOA) I would scan in our Covenants, Bylaws, Rules and Regulations, Annual Budget report. I would scan them to a disc and any interested buyer is welcome to a disk containing such.

Bottom line is I would want the deal as clean and honest as I could make it. I walk away with a clear mind and a clear heart.

Doing anything less, even if a state law says you can, could be opening the door for problems down the line. Problems that could be nipped in the bud for very short money.

In my HOA all our docs (Covenants, Bylaws, and Rules and Regulations) are filed with the deed.

In my HOA but when you want to buy a home from the developer (6 left out of 113) you place a unconditional, $500 (refundable) lot order which gives you a 30 day reserve on your chosen lot. When you sign this, you are given a package that contains the Covenants, Bylaws, Rules & Regulations, and a copy of the annual budget with a breakdown of where dues go. You sign a letter stating you have received copies of such. In the next 30 days you agree on what type house, options, final cost, etc. You can walk at anytime for any reason and your $500 is refunded. That is how to run a "clean deal".

BanksS
Posts: 403
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By JohnC46 on 02/17/2014 5:50 AM

Bottom line is I would want the deal as clean and honest as I could make it. I walk away with a clear mind and a clear heart.


You are obviously a man with integrity. I really admire that.
JoK2 (California)
Posts: 198
Posted:
JohnC has it right, if I am the seller I would do what I could to help the sale along and that would be to have said documents out on the counter for potential buyers to see. It's similar to the whole Fiduciary deal. Doesn't everyone in the sales process have a certain responsibility to making the sale happen? Doesn't every single aspect of our daily lives depend on everyone involved to take some responsiblity to make something happen?

These day's everyone wants to blame someone else, and in this case there is one more person to blame. In an instance in our neighborhood, the seller blamed the PM on the loss of the sale because the buyer never got the paperwork, we will never know the whole story, but if a seller knew that was requested, it would only make sense that they should take some responsibility to make sure it's being done.
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
Actually, we have gotten more visitors to our Associations web site from potential buyers than from members and have received positive feedback from the Realtor community for having our documents available.
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By TimB4 on 02/17/2014 6:29 AM
Actually, we have gotten more visitors to our Associations web site from potential buyers than from members and have received positive feedback from the Realtor community for having our documents available.

I agree with this approach.

When we owners take over from the developer (details being worked out now), one of our discussions has been to scan our docs and post them on our web site. Only question so far was if they were not up to date, could we be held accountable? Initial reply from our lawyer was not if you specifically note the date of the documents and add some disclaimer.

BanksS
Posts: 403
Posted:
I applaud those of you who take efforts to inform the buyer.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here