💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

AlexM1 (Oklahoma)
Posts: 287
Posted:
One person here(an owner) at a condo complex (comprised of condo units in buildings with one unit downstairS and another
upstairs, etc. One tenant works at an Electrical Repair and brings his van home and parks it in one of the open parking
areas. This one owner isobjecting to the van being parked there in that this is an upscale complex and having a
van of that type parked there only brings down the value of the property and demands that the van(with its markings on the side)
be move. Does that owner have a right to demand such a things?
CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
Do your governing documents prohibit vehicles of that type from parking in those spots?
MatthewW4 (Arizona)
Posts: 500
Posted:
As a retired person who collects Social Security benefits, I have no objections to someone parking his work van where he lives. That work van tells me the guy has a job and is most likely putting money into the same pot I take money out of. I will do nothing to discourage workers from contributing to my benefits. Those who someday wish to enjoy their own benefits would be wise to follow a similar course.

On a related note, I was recently saw a Chevy Astro van with Ohio plates in my neighborhood. This was clearly a passenger vehicle with three rows of seats and windows all around. The Ohio license plates said it was a commercial truck. In Arizona, it would be licenses as a passenger car. Go figure.

AlexM1 (Oklahoma)
Posts: 287
Posted:
No... our documents do not so stipulate or distinquish
BrianB (California)
Posts: 2,820
Posted:
a) the board should ask the owner to provide clear, documented proof, at least 5 independent sources, that said actions with said vehicles indeed lower property values.

b) the board should look at their CC&R's, and see if said vehicles are specifically listed as being illegal to park.

from the sounds of your previous response, answer to B) is "there's no such rule", and thus, they should tell the owner "thank you for your input, the board will not be considering the claim."

MatthewW4 (Arizona)
Posts: 500
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AlexM1 on 05/02/2013 3:26 PM
One person here (an owner) at a condo complex. . . . One tenant works at an Electrical Repair and brings his van home and parks it in one of the open parking areas. This one owner is objecting to the van being parked there in that this is an upscale complex and having a van of that type parked there only brings down the value of the property and demands that the van (with its markings on the side) be moved. Does that owner have a right to demand such a things?

Alex,

I have been trying to hold back the laughs but my moral fiber is only so strong. I am forced to give in to temptation. Just exactly what makes a condo complex "upscale?" Those are two terms that do not normally belong in the same sentence.

As one who lives in and owns a single-family detached home in a neighborhood full of such homes, my property values would take a dive if there was a condo complex nearby.

AlexM1 (Oklahoma)
Posts: 287
Posted:
Matthew:

I also had to hold back laughter but this person(owner) is .... well, I will say no more.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Let's not laugh boys... There are some really nice condo's out there that are nicer than stand alone homes. I know many along lakes or rivers. We have many here even in a high rise hotel in an upscale outdoor shopping mall/community.

I think people confuse property value with being "ATTRACTIVE" to potential buyers. Many here will argue those terms granted. However, home values are based on real numbers and realities. Home values are based on what other homes in the area have sold/appraised for. It's NOT the amount they have the sale amount for. A foreclosure/short sale has more effect on home values than having ugly plants in the yard. Home values are based on square footage and the number of bedroom/baths available amongst similar homes. Typically 3bd/2ba houses are tied in with similar 3bd/2ba houses. A 5bd/2.5ba house is not going to have the same value as a 3bd/2ba house. Although a family of 5 may find it of more value. That is part of the "Attractive" factor.

Location plays the other major role in home values. Homes close to rivers/lakes/downtown will have more value than homes in the country/suburbs. It is Location, location, location when you deal with real estate. That is why you hear that in terms of real estate sales and values. It also play a big portion into the attractive value as well.

Overall, a HOA does not maintain or increase home VALUES. What it does do, is maintain a certain ATTRACTIVENESS to potential buyers. A buyer is more likely to buy into a HOA for it's amenities and looks versus a stand alone home with none. I bought mine because it provided lawncare. That was of value to me but not to my bank who approved the loan. Hence why I define HOA's based on their ability to attract owner versus being involved in home values. A bank loans for numbers not if you have access to a pool or tennis courts.

So tell your CCO that it is NOT a home values issue. It is just a less attractive thing for the neighborhood. If they want, they can submit their idea to modify your rules to put in vehicle restrictions. That then in turn takes a vote of the board to put that up to the general membership to amend the CC&R's. A HOA is managed by it's people for it's people. So it can make the rules up as they feel as long as it doesn't violate local, state, or federal laws.

Former HOA President
CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
Say, Matthew, Melissa knows upscale condos in Alabama. Our urban high-rise twin tower condos with loads of amenities & fabulous views of a bay & the ocean are upscale. There also are many other similar properties in our neighborhood. I would think there are upscale condos in Phoenix and Tucson, no? Or on golf courses in AZ?
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Upscale condos in Alabama does NOT mean a trailer put up on blocks with gold underpinning... ;-)

Former HOA President
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By AlexM1 on 05/02/2013 3:26 PM
One person here(an owner) at a condo complex (comprised of condo units in buildings with one unit downstairS and another
upstairs, etc. One tenant works at an Electrical Repair and brings his van home and parks it in one of the open parking
areas. This one owner isobjecting to the van being parked there in that this is an upscale complex and having a
van of that type parked there only brings down the value of the property and demands that the van(with its markings on the side)
be move. Does that owner have a right to demand such a things?

Some associations do have restrictions on type vehicles that can be parked. Some do not even allow motor cycles.

We have had many discussions on here about what constitutes a commercial vehicle. Few can define it clearly and state laws will vary widely. Some say an SUV with a business name on the back window (quite common) constitutes a commercial vehicle. Some say if there are two identical vans but one has a business sign makes it a commercial vehicle. In one HOA that had very tough vehicle rules (includning no motorcycles, we had told an owwner that their mini-van with an Airport Shuttle on it was commercial and as such they had to park it in their. They filed a complaint about a Highway Patrol cruiser being parked in the open as it had "signs" on it. We ruled it a safety vehicle thus an exception to our commercial vehicle ban. Now that might have meant one could park a fire truck in their driveway........LOL

If you have no restrictions, I think it would be tough to implement any and I can guarantee you they will be near impossible to define.

Are all the vehicle complaints you mention coming from the same person?

JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
EDIT

We did not allow commercial vehicles to park overnight in a driveway (we had no street parking) but you could park your commercial vehicle in your garage. All homes had double wide, deep driveways, and two car garages.

Our issues came when the garage was full of stuff and people wanted to park their commercial vehicle overnight in their driveway.

MatthewW4 (Arizona)
Posts: 500
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By CarolR11 on 05/04/2013 10:38 AM
Say, Matthew, Melissa knows upscale condos in Alabama. Our urban high-rise twin tower condos with loads of amenities & fabulous views of a bay & the ocean are upscale. There also are many other similar properties in our neighborhood. I would think there are upscale condos in Phoenix and Tucson, no? Or on golf courses in AZ?

Carol,

I am sure that your condo towers are a cut above the rest but I doubt that their presence has increased the property values around them. No matter how upscale you think your property is, I doubt that your neighbors would be happy to see another tower or two going up around them.

It's kind of like a real estate quiz I saw once with questions like, "Do you want to live near shopping, schools, and church?" Then it asked, "Would you want to buy a home next to a shopping center, a school, or a church?"
CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
All of the residential properties within 8 or so blocks of us are condo buildings, Matthew. I'd say that ours is a cut above some and a cut below others. The ones a cut (or more) above have concierge service, valet parking, sauna rooms, and more conference rooms and lounges than we have, for example. Among all the condos near us, some have great water views and/or wonderful amenities, and others have fewer amenities and/or no water views. All except one were built in 2000 or more recently.

About a mile from us is a very nice neighborhood that has a mix of detached homes, small apartment bldgs., & low-rise condo buildings. Because the location is so desirable, the condos & apts., all of which are well-maintained, do not harm the value of the detached homes.

Pretty funny, Melissa! I think we saw some nice condo buildings in Mobile near the water while on a car trip though the deep south two years ago.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I've stayed in some nice ones in North Carolina in ski country. We have condo's in a Westin hotel that go for 400K to 1.9 million. The houses outside of that go only for 150K - 200K. Within a 3 mile radius of my house we have apartments that rent for 600 to 1K for a 1 bedroom apartment. We have an HOA small homes some attached who's home prices are 80 - 100K. The next street over the homes are 400-700K. My own neighborhood is older homes that go for 100K up depending on size/remodel materials. I always joke that I could not afford to move into my own neighborhood!!!

My area is very unique and very well mixed. The condos a few miles down the road don't even have an effect on our home values. That's because condo's are "comped" with condos and NOT the houses. The rent of the apartments are based on other factors. However, the rent does reflect the age of the apartments.

So I don't connect the effect on condo's/apartments on my home value. My home is not compared to any of those. It's just the speed of which they sell that makes a difference here. In my HOA I've seen homes sell within 6 hours of a sign being put up. Other neighborhoods signs have stayed up for months. To me the overall factor is the economy and not if you live next door to condos.

Former HOA President
MatthewW4 (Arizona)
Posts: 500
Posted:
Carol,

I think you could count all the high-rise condos in Phoenix on one hand. Four of the five that I can think of were already built when I moved here in 1968 and the newest was built some time in the 1980's.

Sometime before I moved here, the city council had decreed that high-rises (residential or commercial) could be built only within a zone five miles long and one mile wide. The four older high-rise condos were all located in that zone and the newest is just outside the original boundaries. While it did create a high-rise corridor it also led to rampant speculation with investors buying up all the property within the zone in the hopes that they would cash in.

Fast-forward 50 years and hardly any new high-rises have been added in the high-rise corridor since the 1960's. The properties that the speculators bought up are all overgrown with weeds and are eyesores. Some properties have reverted to their original residential use with new homes built as in-fill projects, but much of it lies dormant. The city eventually abandoned the high-rise corridor concept and commercial high-rises can be found in other areas.

I learned years ago that building upward is more expensive than building outward. Therefore, it makes sense to build high-rises only when the land becomes so expensive that outward expansion is no longer feasible. Phoenix is surrounded by hundreds of square miles of fairly flat desert so the land costs remain fairly low. There is far more supply than demand.

Aside from the high-rises, there are few "upscale" condos of any type. That's because if you have the money to be upscale you live in Phoenix only during the winter months.

CarolR11 (Colorado)
Posts: 2,563
Posted:
This reminds all of us that what's typical of one area of one state can't be generalized to other areas of other states! I, for example, do not know Phoenix at all, but assumed it had nice high rises like so many CA cities. Boy was I wrong!
KevinK7 (Florida)
Posts: 1,343
Posted:
Here in florida there are numerous condos. Especially during the housing boom many apartment complexes converted to condo units and now some newer developments have been timeshare/hotel/condo/apartment combos. Before the housing boom a huge development was taking place near my home that was going to build condo towers. I was excited because someting like that could have helped the area and improved my valueas.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here