💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

AvanD1
Posts: 22
Posted:
For a small condo building in California, the HOA Board wants to replace the community garage overhead gate with a sliding gate.

Installing the sliding gate door would require that it slides along a wall next to a unit owner's parking space. Installation of the garage motor may inhibit opening/closing of the unit owner's vehicle doors.

How should the HOA Board proceed?
📎 Attachments (1):

⏸ Downloads temporarily unavailable

📄127401093271.pdf(123 KB)
AvanD1
Posts: 22
Posted:
Edit: "Installing the sliding gate door would" should be "Installing the sliding gate would"
KevinK7 (Florida)
Posts: 1,326
Posted:
I would say the HOA needs to find another solution. Are the spots guaranteed to every homeowner? Could they relocate the parking spot?
AvanD1
Posts: 22
Posted:
No, there are no other spots.

I also wonder if there is a code issue -- perhaps there needs to be a certain amount of clearance space between the gate and the parking space.
LarryB13
Posts: 4,089
Posted:
Avan,

What is the issue with the current set-up, other than some really strange looking hardware in the area of the lift motor?
TimB4 (Virginia)
Posts: 20,986
Posted:
The Association should look at reassigning spots and/or remarking current parking spaces to accommodate the required hardware.
GlenL
Posts: 5,429
Posted:
Looking at the picture I find it unusual that your HOA allows parking in front of the stairwell door, I would think that that was a code violation. Why does the Board want to change gate types? I'm assuming that the sliding type is more secure.
JohnB26
Posts: 1,542
Posted:
sliding gates are cheaper than overhead gates

the existing was designed by architects and engineers

the original developer installed the overhead type for very good reasons

? why must we all think that we know about things including engineering, construction, architectural design, building code, etc. better than the original builder(s) ?

remember: you can pay me now, or pay me a lot more later

AvanD1
Posts: 22
Posted:
The Board says that sliding gates will require less maintenance in the future.

Each unit has it own stairwell, which leads to a private patio. The patio leads to the unit.
Each unit has two parking spots next to its own stairwell.

There really isn't any room to redraw/reconfigure the parking spots.
There are no guest parking spots.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,734
Posted:
I would check out other gate options besides the sliding one. Has there been other gate types discussed? Or did they buy into the sales pitch of one contractor?
What is the opinion of the person's who's space will be invaded? They seem to have the most say in how the HOA is to proceed. Are they talking suing or any action against or for it? That's the most important aspect is having them involved in the process.

Why can't the gate slide outward/inward? Can a gate be put up exteriorly farther up? There's so much more that needs to be discussed before jumping into this decision.

Former HOA President
LarryB13
Posts: 4,089
Posted:
Based on past experience with sliding gates, the person who owns the space pictured will lose one to two feet of width from their space. While the gate itself may be only 2 inches thick, they typically require some sort of roller guides along the top and the structure for those will intrude into the space. The motor for the gate is also going to intrude into the parking space.

A sliding gate ought to have some sort of safety screen to prevent injury to the persons in the parking space next to where the gate would retract. Again, a little more intrusion.

Since the motor will likely sit on the floor next to the gate, what happens if there is a need for emergency service, there is a car parked next to the gate, and the owner is not present to move the car? From experience, gates have a habit of breaking down unpredictably and the service personnel need a bit of room to access the mechanisms.

It looks like the installation of a sliding gate as proposed would result in the loss of one parking space.
JohnB26
Posts: 1,542
Posted:
DOH

AvanD1
Posts: 22
Posted:
Thank you all for the valuable input.

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here