💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

BradP (Kansas)
Posts: 2,640
Posted:
Here is our situation...we are in the process of trying to clean up the mess of people that have dues that are way past due. We have sent out letters to those who are over a year past giving them 30 days to act before we file a lien.

I have also been keeping track of homes for sale in the neighborhood and one popped up last week that when I checked on their status they were nine months behind. They are also getting a 30 day notice letter. Here is my questions, some of our board members think we should also CC their realtor on it so they are aware that they owe this money and that a lien could be filed soon. I am not so sure that isn't violating confidential information, once a lien is filed then it is publice but until then I am not sure.

Any thoughts on whether this is an accepted practice?
RonaldW (South Carolina)
Posts: 901
Posted:
Posted By BradP on 03/02/2007 6:04 AM

Here is our situation...we are in the process of trying to clean up the mess of people that have dues that are way past due. We have sent out letters to those who are over a year past giving them 30 days to act before we file a lien.

I have also been keeping track of homes for sale in the neighborhood and one popped up last week that when I checked on their status they were nine months behind. They are also getting a 30 day notice letter. Here is my questions, some of our board members think we should also CC their realtor on it so they are aware that they owe this money and that a lien could be filed soon. I am not so sure that isn't violating confidential information, once a lien is filed then it is publice but until then I am not sure.

Any thoughts on whether this is an accepted practice?


I don't know about contacting the sellers agent, but we have been contacted by the buyer's agent or settlement attorney for a confirmation that assessments are current.

I suspect it would be wrong to contact the seller's agent just as it would be wrong to tell his/her neighbors or publish the information in a newsletter or website.


Ron
SC
JoeW1 (New York)
Posts: 728
Posted:
BradP - if anything your HOA would notify the listing agent's broker. does your state practice the provision of a statement from the seller as to the condition of the property, awareness of any late fees, dues, special assessments on the common property, etc.? some states do this. you really should consult your attorney on disclosing the info to the listing agent's broker because your hoa may be accused of blowing the real estate deal.
BradP (Kansas)
Posts: 2,640
Posted:
Joe:

I believe our state has a disclosure statement, whether the owner is honest is another thing. We have had several title companies contact prior to closing asking how much an owner owes. But..sometimes that doesn't happen. We just had one sale last fall that slipped through the cracks, luckily the owner was up to speed on dues but we charge a $100 initiation fee and we are having to go back to collect that now from the new owner who didn't know anything about it.

My worry is that this seller is not going to disclose what they owe and try to skip out on it, I am trying to save a lot of headache and time by freezing him before he sells. But, his letter is in the mail, it gives 30 days and as of right now the house is not sold, so unless they sell quickly and close sooner than 30 days we are in good shape.
DJ1 (Ontario)
Posts: 798
Posted:
Be careful, if you interfere in a home sale and it falls thru the HOA might be sued. Check with a lawyer. A lien may be public record but until it reaches that point it is still private.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
Go ahead and place the lien. Do you really need to give such a 30 day notice? In my state, we only have to give a 10 day notice for a renter to move out. Giving 30 days for a lien notice is too lengthy IMO. I would send them a notice that one was placed if they are already trying to sell. That may be a reason they are selling.
A lien prevents a person from selling their property until the money is paid up. If your HOA fails to place the lien, then that person could sell the home "free and clear". It's only when the title company looks up and sees the lien placed, can any action be taken. You can NOT pursue the new owner to pay the backdues or if there is a renter.
Any realtor can sell the home. The name on the sign is just the listing agent. Whoever buys the house can have their own realtor handle the deal. So your not guaranteed to be notifying the right realtor. Plus realtor's aren't in the business of caring if the person owes money to the HOA or not. They just care if the sell will go through to get their profit. A realtor isnt' responsible for even giving the rules of the HOA to anyone. They just have to inform a potential buyer that there is a HOA and the dues amount.
You had better act quickly. If the bank decides to lien a home before an HOA does, then your out that money. If the owner owes money to the bank and the HOA, and the HOA files FIRST, the bank still gets it's cut of the money owed. If that owner' owed more money to the bank, then the HOA gets nothing and did the "dirty work". So be careful and do your own research. Lien notices are published in the "Legals" section of the newspaper in the classified sections. It may not be everyday posting. (They post only 2 days a week here.) Lien/foreclosure notices will be posted there. That way you will know if the bank has a lien/foreclosure going on a property in the HOA. The bank isn't going to tell the HOA they are! (This saved our HOA a few times!).

Former HOA President
JM2 (Oregon)
Posts: 439
Posted:
Hi Brad:

A few cautions: 1) Be sure that you follow the legal requirements of your state and/or county in filing the lien, including any notice sent prior and the time period allowed. If there's a questions, check with the Association's lawyer. 2) In many states (including mine, Oregon) the Bank's mortgage takes first place among all liens on a property; if sold in foreclosure, the HOA only gets money if the sale exceeds what is owed to the Bank; and the bank just wants their money, so they may sell only for what is owed them. 3) In some states the assessment itself is a lien on the property for legal purposes, even if a formal lien isn't filed. 4) It's probably wise to inform the listing agent (who represents the owner in the sale of the property) of the amounts owed; they don't want to get into an ethics issue with their state real estate licensing bureau, so it's likely (if they are ethical) that they will make sure that the debt on the property is properly listed on the disclosure; but check with your association's lawyer before taking this step. It may be worthwhile to have the lawyer send the letter...

A side question that's probably relevant: how does your association collect assessments? Do you use a coupon book, or send assessment notices monthly? While I understand the concept behind coupon books, sending out statements of what's owed with a section to cut off and send in with payment does keep the owenr on notice of what is owed - so they don't get behind without realizing it. Many associations that are self-managed use a bookkeeping service or billing service or accountant to send out bills, or set up a contract with a management company to only handle finances; then, those services keep up on the accounts and send past-due notices, etc....if your board passes a "collection resolution" then the process is all set up so that people receive notice after being delinquent a certain amount of either time or money and then either set up a payment plan or get a lien filed.

J. Patrick Moore, CMCA
BradP (Kansas)
Posts: 2,640
Posted:
Melissa:

The purpose behind the 30 day notice is to try and save some good will with neighbors and to be consistent. Even though they owe the money I don't think just slapping a lien is an appropriate step, especially when maybe a strongly worded letter might work. Secondly, the house is listed, not sold yet. The listing realtor is the realtor that was hired by the homeowner, so any sale has to go through them, I don't follow your statement on any realtor can sell, typically a contract is entered into with a certain person and they are rep for the seller. I am going to keep an eye on it, including the possibility of calling in a week or so to inquire if it is still on the market.

JM2:

We bill quarterly via an invoice, we have our own in house treasurer that does this. We also put reminders in our quarterly newsletter. This is a new step for us, liens have been threatened in the past, but never followed through on. Things are different this time and I have a feeling it will take a couple for the word to spread and things to get better. You are right on a collection resolution, we just did that, which says that anyone over 6 months past due will be given a 30 day last chance letter and then be filed on. Just sent out several of those a couple of days ago, will see what happens.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
I've missed out on plenty of oportunities to lien on members that didn't pay up. Filing liens isn't that easy. It costs atleast $300 to place a lien here in my state. Each state varies. That money comes directly out of the HOA's budget. So if your going to threaten lien, the HOA had better be prepared to be out that money.
You will have to possibly treat each non-paying owner the same dispite the personal circumstances at first. Once a member calls, I'd recommend going on a case to case basis. I found offering the member the ability to "double" their dues payment each month helpful in preventing a lien. It allows them to "catch up without adding late fees and the HOA gets it's money without spending any. An excellent solution for most.
Remember, the HOA is NOT guaranteed to get the money owed until the house is sold. The owner can use the property as rental if they choose. It may take a LOOONG time to collect. In the meantime the HOA is out the lien filing costs. Most likely dues will continue NOT to come in. If that continues for another 6 months, then send out notices of foreclosure next.
Make sure the lien covers: Current/continous Dues, added up late fees, an interest rate either dictated by your documents/state law AND the cost of filing the lien. (may include attorney fees). The lien can't be placed just for late fees alone. It must be dues. The letter you send out should include all the costs the member will ensue if they keep on the course they are on. The word "lien" may have no meaning unless they truly know the meaning of what it truly costs.

Former HOA President
KevinC2 (Michigan)
Posts: 15
Posted:
Brad,

My association has many situations like the one you described. The board's common practice is to notify the property owner that a lien will be placed on their property if dues are not paid in full by a specific date (we usually give them a week). We will then go ahead and place a lien, which in Michigan does not cost a lot of money. With regards to collecting the past due amounts when the owner is selling, the backed association dues usually are revealed in the documents that are sent by the mortgage company on the buyer's behalf. The documents ask if there are any backed dues or liens. The best bet to collecting your money is to place a lien so title to the property cannot be transferred without the backed dues being paid. For my association, our bylaws state that backed dues cannot be transferred to a new owner and that all special assessments must be paid by the owner of the unit at the time the special assessment was passed (i.e. not transferrable to new owner). Best of luck with your situation!

Kevin
Board President
The Courtyards Association

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here