💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
Good Morning Everyone!

As a new community, we are still having people buy homes in our addition. We are a community of 45 homes with 3 houses left to sell. We have already had some violators of the CC&R and I believe it has to do with how quickly our 3rd party administrator is getting CC&R's mailed to them.

In my own experience, we did not receive a CC&R until we had been living in our home for a month. When should residents be receiving these? And how do we follow up on violations that have occurred in that small window of time? Side note: I've been stunned to find out that new residents are not being informed that there is an HOA and that there are yearly fees!

Many Thanks for Your Help in Advance!
JohnB26 (South Carolina)
Posts: 1,569
Posted:
the CCRs are public records attached/filed with the deed(s)

they apply IMMEDIATELY at the point of sale/closing

if they were not filed/attached to the deed ... they will NEVER be mandatory

the purchasers may or may not have recourse against the seller (not the HOA's issue)

good luck

CAVEAT EMPTOR
ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
Wow! This is great feedback. We did not have the CC&R attached to our deed, but we did know there was an HOA.

Thank you for the feedback!
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
Chrystal,

They should have gotten a copy at closing.
Unfortunately, as you know, that doesn't always happen.
The delay might also be the time between closing and the management company learning that the sale was finalized.

Tim
ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
I'm assuming this isn't being communicated very well as the builder sold all of our homes to the bank right after finishing the community. Our house sat vacant for 2 years before we bought it. This might be the disconnect. The major problem we are having is that our CC&R states that we must be notified within 30 days that the home will be used as a rental and that we need contact information from the renters. Both of the homes in violation had renters move in immediately following closing.
BruceF1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 2,535
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By ChrystalM on 06/06/2012 8:31 AM
Good Morning Everyone!

As a new community, we are still having people buy homes in our addition. We are a community of 45 homes with 3 houses left to sell. We have already had some violators of the CC&R and I believe it has to do with how quickly our 3rd party administrator is getting CC&R's mailed to them.

In my own experience, we did not receive a CC&R until we had been living in our home for a month. When should residents be receiving these? And how do we follow up on violations that have occurred in that small window of time? Side note: I've been stunned to find out that new residents are not being informed that there is an HOA and that there are yearly fees!

Many Thanks for Your Help in Advance!

Ideally, one should receive a copy of the CCRs upon completing a purchase agreement and putting a deposit on the purchase of a unit. Generally, the purchaser should be given a period of time to review the document and cancel the purchase agreement without penalty. Some states (like Connecticut) require this whereas some do not.
ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
I will have to look into that for the state of Washington AND for our city. Our city tends to do a lot of it's own laws.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
It is another HOA falacy about getting a copy of the CC&R's/Article of Incorporation. Although a few states have a few rules out there about notifying buyers. They are too far and in between. In GENERAL, the CC&R's are looked upon as YOUR responsibility to be informed PRIOR to signing the closing papers. They are PUBLIC documents accessible at your local court house in records department. Thus being considered PUBLIC records the responsibility falls upon the actual individual making the purchase and NOT anyone else. It's a "Courtesy" if others involved like the HOA, Realtor, Previous owner, Lawyer, or mortgage company provide a copy. They are NOT required to do so. Some may not even know they exist as well.

The By-laws on the other hand get a bit "tricky". They are not in most states required to be filed anywhere except with the HOA as they are the HOA's rules/handbook. Hence why you may or may not get a copy of the by-laws at all except through previous owner or HOA itself. They are not attached to your deed like the CC&R's are. The documents are more ammendable and more in control of the owners/members.

Keep in mind this concept...You are NOT a member of the HOA until you sign the closing documents and own the home. The HOA handing over their financial records, rules, or other documentation is NOT required to be given to POTENTIAL buyers as it is confidential information for members only. That is NOT to say they can't give you a run down of the general rules/existance or the dues rates. I used to provide a brochure for interested buyers at our entrance way. It is just that requesting certain types of information and not getting it is NOT a failure on the part of the HOA prior to the actual sale. Your just not entitled to that until your an actual member. A kind of "Catch-22"...

Your lucky and fortunate to work with a HOA that would provide information and does send out rules to new owners. Everyone operates differently and you have to be informed. It NOT THEM informing YOU...

Former HOA President
FredS7 (Arizona)
Posts: 927
Posted:
Arizona is in some ways a backward state...but they DO have the right rules on this.

In Arizona a buyer must sign a document saying that he has received the CC&Rs or that he has waived his right to have them.

Regardless of state law, I can't see any good reason for NOT making these available to a prospective buyer. In advance of purchase.

These days it's only a matter of burning a CD...
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
The reason the documents are NOT made available by the HOA is what I stated earlier. A POTENTIAL buyer is NOT a MEMBER of the HOA UNTIL they have signed on the dotted line. That is why the documents are considered PUBLIC and kept at the courthouse. No one is responsible to provide the documents to limit anyone and everyone's liability for NOT doing so.
I know it sounds like common sense to provide the documents but it truly isn't if you get one digruntle person. The HOA could get sued constantly by complete strangers and members with suits claiming "They were not given documents yada yada"...The Realtor could be sued for NOT doing their job for the information. The mortgage company doesn't have to adhere to the HOA rules and get paid first in any foreclosure actions the HOA may take. We know a lawyer won't do it since they are just there to provide legal paper signage. In the end it YOU the buyer who has to make the efort and not to expect otherwise in most states.

Former HOA President
RogerB (Colorado)
Posts: 5,067
Posted:
The HOA does not provide the governing documents and other documents which are required to be given to a potential buyer. The HOA provides these documents to the owner or the owner's agent who then provides them to the potential buyer or the buyer's agent. Providing these documents is a CCIOA requirement in Colorado. A buyer has the right to cancel a contract to buy if there is anything in these documents which is not acceptable to them.

DARCO recommends that every buyer get and read the CC&Rs prior to signing any agreement to buy.
LarryB13 (Arizona)
Posts: 4,099
Posted:
Ideally, the seller should disclose the existence of the CC&R's to the buyer and furnish a copy. Next best situation would be that the seller, his realtor, the buyer's agent, the escrow agent, or the title company, furnishes a copy to the buyer before closing. Not so ideal but more common in my area is that the CC&R's are furnished at closing. The deed itself should note that the property is subject to recorded covenants.

Perhaps the question might be restated as, "What should a buyer do if the CC&R's are not furnished to him at or before closing?" The deed itself should give the buyer notice that the property is subject to CC&R's. I have never done it myself, but I would see no problem with informing the seller and closing officer that you are not signing off on the deal until you have the CC&R's and an opportunity to read them as they are a material part of the transaction. By signing off on the purcahse without having a copy of the CC&R's a person pretty much waives his right to object later on.

In my county all recorded documents are available on the internet, so if a person knows that there are CC&R's he can obtain unofficial copies himself. Using the county recorder's website and that of the assessor, one can find the name of the subdivision, find out whether there are CC&R's, and download a copy in pdf format. However, when I purchase a home in Phoenix last year I did not bother to do that and was surprised at closing when they handed me a copy of the CC&R's. (The CC&R's were fairly innocuous as they were directed mostly at the original builders in the subdivision and have few restrictions for homeowners and no association.)
ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
It sounds like I need to look over City, County and State laws regarding when this should be handed out. I feel like there might have been a disconnect since this whole community was bank owned. I appreciate everyone's feedback and I look to mention these points at our next HOA meeting.
JohnM48 (Pennsylvania)
Posts: 89
Posted:
PA requires that a prospective buyer be given a copy of the CCRs, ByLaws & any Rules & regulations before settlement. If the buyer has not received the documents in time to review them, they can cancel the purchase without penalty. Once settlement has occurred however, it would be up to the new homeowner to obtain a copy from the association.

Association President
DavidA7 (California)
Posts: 179
Posted:
I'm not 100% sure of all the processes in Califonia but know they are required to be part of Escrow. Not that happens so we have strict instructions to our Management Company that when Escrow is opened on a property that they must send all applicable documents, CC&R's, Rules, Policies and Procedures, and Bylaws to the Escrow company prior to signing of any Escrow documents by purchaser.
GlenL (Ohio)
Posts: 5,491
Posted:
Side note: I've been stunned to find out that new residents are not being informed that there is an HOA and that there are yearly fees!

I don't know about Washington but here when you use the MRL Multiple Real-estate Listings to look at homes it states whether or not there is an HOA and how much the yearly assessments are. Also when I signed the mountain of paperwork to close on my home there was a sheet saying that there was an HOA and by signing I agreed to follow and obey the CC&R's.

Easier to plead ignorance!

Studies show that 5 out of 4 people have problems with fractions
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Doesn't really matter if you look up state laws. Your a member and you owe fees.
JohnC46 (South Carolina)
Posts: 14,265
Posted:
South Carolina can be very weak in many in regulations but it does have something called the SC Horizontal Property which specifically refere to high rise buildings/condos. One section says:

""""""SECTION 27-31-150. Administration of property; bylaws.
The administration of the property constituted into horizontal property, whether incorporated or unincorporated, shall be governed by bylaws which shall be inserted in or appended to and recorded with the master deed or lease.""""""

Now many have rightfully argued that the Horizontal Property Act does not apply to townhouse, standalone home, HOA's. SC did try and come up with Rules and Regulations for HOA's but it died in committee a few years back.

Our HOA CC&R's and Bylaws are recorded with the master deed. There is also a page that says HOA Rules and Regulations exist but they are not attached to the deed.

In our HOA (standalone patio homes, still under declarant control) the procedure is you place a Lot Order that reserves that lot for you for 30 days. In that 30 days all the details will be worked out like style house, options, etc. As part of the Lot Order, you also sign for and receive a copy of CC&R's, Bylaws, and Rule and Regulations. The buyer can cancel the Lot Order for any reason during this 30 days period. During this time, some have many questions about the CC&R's/Bylaws, some have none. Some get their lawyer involved, some do not. There have been several cases where some did back out during the Lot Order phase, but I have been told no one ever said they were backing out due to CC&R's and Bylaws. At the end of the 30 day period you go to a Sales and Purchase Agreement.

I have heard many say well it is the job of the buyer to do this and that. While I agree, but if one has nothing to hide then they should make the process as open and as transparent as possible for all.

JeanneK3 (Maryland)
Posts: 562
Posted:
All:
In Maryland the seller, not the HOA, must provide all documents related to the association either 5 or 7 days before the closing. Any buyer can get out of a contract if these documents were not provided. The buyer must sign a statement saying he/she has received this "resale package."
This seems to me very fair as no one should be hit with a surprise special assessment.
Jeanne
SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
The best way I can put it in perspective for people is this:

Did the town/city give you a book of local laws/regulations and tell you the how much you would have to save each month to pay taxes? No.

Do you have to follow these laws/regulations and pay taxes taxes, of course. Same with an HOA.
FredS7 (Arizona)
Posts: 927
Posted:
>Did the town/city give you a book of local laws/regulations and tell you the how >much you would have to save each month to pay taxes? No.

>Do you have to follow these laws/regulations and pay taxes taxes, of course. Same >with an HOA.

Except everybody knows there is a town government but not necessarily that there are other restrictions (CC&Rs) and other payments (HOA fees).

It's not a matter of legality so much as being above-board and fair. The most appropriate state laws allow a buyer to back out of a purchase, without penalty, if certain information is not provided. Just like a house inspection. (Just as with a house inspection you can also sign a document waiving these rights). There is no benefit and substantial harm when buyers are uninformed.

DavidA7 (California)
Posts: 179
Posted:
Ignorance is bliss: I buy into a property that has a general area everybody walks through, there is a basketball court, a swimming pool, etc... Who the hell do you think owns that or is going to pay for the repairs when necessary, the tooth fairy? These are the same people who bought a house where their payments are 50% or higher of their income and then bled us dry because the were foreclosed on and claimed oh I didn't know I couldn't afford a 400K house on a 40K salary.

Give me a break folks - I don't buy ignorance nor stupidity.
BruceF1 (Connecticut)
Posts: 2,535
Posted:
Quote:
Posted By SteveM9 on 06/07/2012 8:18 AM
Did the town/city give you a book of local laws/regulations and tell you the how much you would have to save each month to pay taxes?

Short answer, yes.

At least for the second part in Connecticut, the municipality sends each homeowner an assessment and a calculation showing what the annual taxes will be. OK, it's not monthly, but that's a math problem.
FredS7 (Arizona)
Posts: 927
Posted:
> I buy into a property that has a general area everybody walks through, there is a basketball court, a swimming pool, etc...

It's not that simple. Some communities have an HOA but no obvious common area at all. Or maybe just a sign with a few flowers planted around it.
DavidA7 (California)
Posts: 179
Posted:
Fred, OK we have a common wall, a walkway through a common corridor, roofing, walls on the outside etc... Wouldn't that give a sane smart person time to stop and say well who is reponsible for this if it needs repair. Look, in my 8 years at our current HOA each time a new owner comes in they know they are in HOA but within at least 2 months each and everyone of them violates some policy or CC&R of the HOA and we have to inform them they are under the laws of our HOA. Each time they express indignity and injustice has been caused against them. We say sorry but you bought into an HOA, you were provided the documents, etc...

I think a big stamp should be stamped on each person who buys into an HOA that says for better or worse you are now married to an HOA and there are repercussion - please proceed with caution. If they don't understand it then I don't know what else will work. LOL

SteveM9 (Massachusetts)
Posts: 3,699
Posted:
Quote:
Except everybody knows there is a town government but not necessarily that there are other restrictions (CC&Rs) and other payments (HOA fees).


Many states dont have these laws.

Also, I've never seen a home in an HOA that didn't mention it on a deed or previous deed. Many home buyers just look at deeds as a bunch of words on a page and dont pay attention to what the deed actually says.

The address is listed on the deed. Now you have the info to look up the tax rate of the town, local laws, zoning, etc.

The property restrictions are mentioned on the deed. Now you know you have to look up info about the HOA. Visit the town hall, look up the development plans, CCR's, maybe bylaws, officers, or knock on a few doors and ask neighbors. In rare cases there is no active HOA, but if there are restrictions, one could be restarted at any time.
ChrystalM (Washington)
Posts: 22
Posted:
I remember seeing the monthly fee for our HOA dues but I just looked over our closing paperwork and there is no CC&R. I continue to believe the disconnect is happening strictly because of the strange situation our community is in. As soon as the builder finished the community, he sold them to a bank. The CC&R was made by the builder prior to completion of the community. I will also follow up on city, county and state laws regarding this matter.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
You have to factor in types of mortgages out there. Each has their own processes. My FHA loan the fees were a factor in getting the loan. The mortgage company told me about the fees and explained I could have bought a house for 20K more without a HOA or the smaller cheaper house in a HOA. I choose the HOA house for it's benefits.

A person paying cash for a home may never get the documents either. The mortgage company does NOT care about the HOA's rules or regulations anyways. They only factor in the "Loan Approval" factor for being able to make the dues and all your bills.

This area is part of the disconnect factor of acknowledging the HOA's existance. They don't know then you may not know. What would trigger them to know? Your HOA or Management company does NOT necessarily know or notify any mortgage companies when a property is sold. Who does that? Too many banks and options. The realtor does not have to notify the HOA/MC they sold a property.

I did go to some closings when I was President. We had to fill out a HUD form with the "health" of the HOA on it. Not every mortgage company used this form but some do use the data from it. FHA used the form but they were government based. Others NOT being backed by government funds do not require this information.

All consideration, notification of a HOA's existance can fall through the cracks just as much as it can rise above. Finding the disconnect is basically caught by the laws that each state has created. Otherwise, your on your own to find the information.

Former HOA President

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here