πŸ’¬ Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account β†’

⚑ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

SherryS (New York)
Posts: 2
Posted:
Pipe saging 45 feet under my townhouse.. Told by HOA that I am responsible for cost of diging up, puting in new piping etc, repairing $13,000. Why am I responsible? Isn't the master policy responsible for pipes under house leading to outside of unit?
BonnieE (Illinois)
Posts: 338
Posted:
Sherry - Could you provide more info? You state that this pipe is located below your townhouse – what kind of pipe is it – water line, sewer line, something else? Does the pipe serve only your unit and none of other town home(s) in your building? How is it known to be sagging? By Master policy are you referring to the insurance purchased by the HOA for the buildings and such? Thanks-Bonnie
SherryS (New York)
Posts: 2
Posted:
Thank you very much for responding.
It is a drain pipe that goes into a sewer line. It appears each unit has there own drain pipe. I know it is sagging because I had a company come in with a camera and they stated "pipe has sage under floor for first 45 feet. Snaked main soil line from 3"pic, toile flnk 88ft past outside. Under video camer under floor to out." $837.00

Master Policy I am referring to is the Homeowners policy of the Home Owners Association. Westchester Property Management Group, Inc. Fortune Building 280 N. Central Avenue, Hartsdale, New York 10530. Maureen O'Hagan Property Manager.
Told me to call in an engineer at my own expense. Isn't something wrong?
Upon contacting them, they said it was my responsibility. However, I was under the impression the policy covers the "unit" as first conveyed. It does not cover additons or alterations which are under my individual Homeowners Policy which is USAA. Isn't the piping part of the "unit as first conveyed?".
Please help me.
PatrickH (California)
Posts: 204
Posted:
Hi Sherry,

If you can locate a section of drain pipe somewhere in your home, under the sinks, behind the cabinets, wherever, check it out. Is it a black plastic pipe?

If so, it may be made of Acrylonitrile Butadine Styrene, ABS for short. There was a lawsuit against the manufacturer of this polymer that was used by various pipe manufacturers to make black plastic ABS drain pipes. Some of the pipe manufacturers were Polaris, Apache, Gable and Phoenix. If you can find some piping, write down whatever words, numbers and letters you see on it.

In the lawsuit, it was shown that the polymer wasn't blended property and at locations where two sections of pipe were glued together, the pipe would crack. That caused leakage of waste water which would undermine the pipe if it was underground or leak into the walls if the pipe was inside the home.

My HOA has the Polaris drain pipes in our homes. Unfortunately, we paid for two repairs ourselves before I learned about the lawsuit by searching the Internet. Since then, we have registered with the company in Portland, Oregon that handles the settlement payments from the lawsuit. It's a lot of forms and paperwork, but well worth it.

Now if we suspect an ABS pipe leak, our plumbing contractor, who also had to register with the people in Oregon, sends a video camera down the drain line to videotape the leak. If it's right where all the other ones were, at a junction of two pipes, the folks in Portland approve and pay for the repair. The bills go directly from the contractor to the settlement people and our HOA and homeowner pay nothing.

You can Google search for information about ABS pipe lawsuit to find out more. It may or may not pertain to your situation, but it's worth checking out before doing all the repairs. Once you do the repairs yourself, they won't reimburse you for the costs.

In regards to who is responsible for your underground drain pipes, you'd need to check your governing documents. In my HOA, which is also townhouses, the owner is responsible for any water lines or drain pipes that are inside the airspace of their unit. The water lines and drain lines that are under the ground or inside common walls are the responsibilty of the HOA.

Good luck.
BonnieE (Illinois)
Posts: 338
Posted:
Hi Sherry - sorry for my delayed response...

PatrickH said: In regards to who is responsible for your underground drain pipes, you'd need to check your governing documents. In my HOA, which is also townhouses, the owner is responsible for any water lines or drain pipes that are inside the airspace of their unit. The water lines and drain lines that are under the ground or inside common walls are the responsibilty of the HOA.

Patrick is correct in that you need to check your governing docs because it varies state to state. In IL and per our governing docs, the water line or drain pipe which is outside of the dwelling unit but which serves that unit exclusively, would be a limited common element and therefore the responsibility would be to the HO.

Our definition of a limited common element includes the statement: β€œany system or component part thereof which serves the Dwelling Unit exclusively to the extent that such system or component part is located outside the boundaries of the Dwelling Unit…”

Our BOD recently passed a policy that almost all limited common elements would be the responsibility of the HO.

Good luck! Bonnie

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • βœ“ Ask follow-up questions
  • βœ“ Share your experience
  • βœ“ Get expert advice
  • βœ“ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account β†’

⚑ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here