💬 Join us to post & get advice from 50,000 HOA & Condo leaders.

Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in

NikkiF (Virginia)
Posts: 4
Posted:
Help! My HOA refuses to enforce our parking restrictions on the streets in order to "reduce speeding by narrowing the street" by use of cars now parked on the street. Our covenants clearly state that:

Section 5.3. Off Street Parking: Each Owner shall provide adequate space for the parking of automobiles on the owners lot rather than on the street or road in front of his/her lot. It is understood that there may be times when additional parking may be necessary, however this should be limited to a 48 hour stay. Please notify the Property Manager if additional time is needed.

A little history: Our streets at the time the CCRs were written were private and then eventually turned over to the county. It is my understanding that they can still enforce the parking restrictions on the home owners through the CCR agreement between the HOA and the homeowner, although my HOA doesn't seem to have a clear understanding of this issue. I cannot find any instances of case law in Virginia that says the HOA can't enforce their that rule. But, I don't think they have done their own reserach and now they want to help curb the speeding issue in our neighborhood by allowing people to park on the streets. I don't see speeding as an issue that the HOA should be solving. This is a county issue and now that the streets or "public" should be left to the cops.
Also, my HOA president told me that recent homes were sold under the pretense that the parking restriction couldn't be enforced, although I think he is wrong, because I think they are ignoring the issue and instead want to let cars park on the street.

Now our streets our cluttered with cars and this causes limited visibility, and has reduced our roads to a one lane pass thru in order to go anywhere. Not to mention that there are several instances where you are forced to meet cars head on because there are cars parked on the street. I don't see how solving a speeding issue by creating this mess makes it any more safe? Plus, I think it detracts from the property values of our homes, as it doesn't make our community very appealing.

Is there anything that can be done?
TimB4 (Tennessee)
Posts: 21,059
Posted:
Nikki,

Since my Association owns the streets, I haven't had the need to spend a lot of time looking into the requirements about enforcement of parking restrictions on public streets.

I was able to find this article written in 2005 by our Associations Law Firm about parking:

http://www.reesbroome.com/associations/files/newsletters/March_2005.pdf

Here is a link to all of their newsletters.

From what I'm reading in that article, a lot of it is going to depend what happened when the streets were deeded back to the County. If restrictions were not recorded and attached to the deed of the roads when they were turned back to the County, then parking restrictions in the covenants would no longer apply to the streets.

You should also be aware that other legal newsletters from other states give a different interpretation on the VA Supreme Court ruling to mean that that Associations in VA may not enforce parking restrictions.

I would suggest that you contact the county recorders office and see if there are any restrictions attached to your (now public) streets.

Everyone else, I am talking about enforcement in VA based on the information contained in the newsletter. I know that other States have different laws (which have been discussed before on this forum) and anyone else not in VA should check their own State statutes.

Tim
JanetB2 (Colorado)
Posts: 4,219
Posted:
Great info Tim!!!

Nicki ... it sounds like the street is extremely narrow. You might check with the County zoning as a concerned citizen with regards to emergency vehicle access. They can review the issue and possibly implement no parking signs on the street, if they find there is a potential hazard or liability issue.
MelissaP1 (Alabama)
Posts: 13,836
Posted:
They can't enforce the road rules anymore once the roads are now considered "Public". What the HOA CAN do is go to the county/city and request an ordanance regarding your HOA conditions. That way they can call the police to enforce the rules. Otherwise, it could fall under "vigilantism" if they try enforce.

We also had narrow streets that didn't allow but 1 car to go through if anyone was parked on the sides of the roads. Many got their mirrors knocked off or scratches down the side. We had an ambulance get stuck responding to an emergency. Fire department could barely make it through to the fire hydrants. Garbage trucks often had to skip pick ups due to cars parked in their way.

Eventually what I did is called the Fire Department and one of our Representatives. We took a tour of the neighborhood and created a plan. We made one side of the road NO-Parking. This way vehicles could make it through and rules enforced. We had to go to the City council meeting to get permission/law to have restrictions on parking. The only snag we hit was with the fact we didn't allow signs in our HOA. The city provided "No parking signs" spaced every few feet. I was able to get with the CODE division of the city and we were able to PAINT the curbs RED instead of signs.

Roads are difficult to control and rules enforced. This is a police matter and they can only do what the law says. They do NOT enforce HOA laws. Know the difference and limitations.

Former HOA President

🎯 You've read this entire discussion

Join the conversation with 50,000 HOA & Condo Leaders:

  • ✓ Ask follow-up questions
  • ✓ Share your experience
  • ✓ Get expert advice
  • ✓ Access 350,000 discussions
Create Free Account →

⚡ Takes 30 seconds

Already a member? Log in here