GT1 (California)
Posts: 10
Posts: 10
Posted:
I am new to this forum and please forgive my verbosity in advance. My newly wed wife and I recently bought a bank owned condo in a 30+ unit complex in Los Angeles, CA. When we purchased the HOA dues were $275, when we moved in, we found out it was $325. Just yesterday, it was raised again to $350/mo.
This is a lower income part of LA in San Fernando Valley where average HOA's in the same neighborhood for similar complex range in the $100's. HOA dues pay for water and trash and basic maintenance, there is no pool or other extravagant amenities. Increases have been occurring over the past year and in addition, two to three "special assessments" of $500 have already been charged in the last year, with a new $2000 assessment on the horizon.
The HOA claims this is due to budget/reserves shortfall due to deliquencies and foreclosure related charges. I don't buy it because I calculate the HOA management fees to account for over 43% of the $325/mo dues, accounting for over $100,000k in management fees annually. Compared with other property management companies, this is way above and beyond market rates. I've challenged the HOA to look at quotes from other management companies and they play it off and say something to the effect of "you can't compare apples to oranges".
The homeowners that have dissented have been forced out/foreclosed upon/gave up. Police were called once due to arguing. The supervisor from the Santa Monica based HOA property management company is a haughty condescending b**ch that blows smoke and spins deceptive lies. When I asked for the accounting statements, the HOA company is very evasive and cryptic. I and other owners have a laundry list of complaints which I will spare the details here.
HOA meetings are controlled by the property management company acting as "proxy" for the homeowners that were either too lazy or stupid to decline representation. The board of directors are run by a small secretive group of homeowners with multiple units who have for some reason "voted" to side with the property management company. Thus, they always seem to have a slight plurality of votes and win any decisions.
They also made it very difficult for new homeowners to be voted onto the board because the old board members are automatically on the ballot, while new owners have to be "write on" candidates. Write-ons hardly ever win. I suspect that there are improprieties/under the table stuff going on between the board members and the HOA but cannot prove it.
Bottom line: homeowners are forced to pay these outrageous HOA dues/special assessments or face foreclosure while this HOA company is lining there pockets and laughing all the way to the bank. Condos in our complex are foreclosed left and right depressing home values leading to a death spiral. Meanwhile, hard working honest homeowners are trying to feed families and keep a roofs over our heads.
I called the state Fair Housing Commission and LA Dept Real Estate, and they just send me in circles.
Help. PLEASE. Any legitimate suggestions truly appreciated.
This is a lower income part of LA in San Fernando Valley where average HOA's in the same neighborhood for similar complex range in the $100's. HOA dues pay for water and trash and basic maintenance, there is no pool or other extravagant amenities. Increases have been occurring over the past year and in addition, two to three "special assessments" of $500 have already been charged in the last year, with a new $2000 assessment on the horizon.
The HOA claims this is due to budget/reserves shortfall due to deliquencies and foreclosure related charges. I don't buy it because I calculate the HOA management fees to account for over 43% of the $325/mo dues, accounting for over $100,000k in management fees annually. Compared with other property management companies, this is way above and beyond market rates. I've challenged the HOA to look at quotes from other management companies and they play it off and say something to the effect of "you can't compare apples to oranges".
The homeowners that have dissented have been forced out/foreclosed upon/gave up. Police were called once due to arguing. The supervisor from the Santa Monica based HOA property management company is a haughty condescending b**ch that blows smoke and spins deceptive lies. When I asked for the accounting statements, the HOA company is very evasive and cryptic. I and other owners have a laundry list of complaints which I will spare the details here.
HOA meetings are controlled by the property management company acting as "proxy" for the homeowners that were either too lazy or stupid to decline representation. The board of directors are run by a small secretive group of homeowners with multiple units who have for some reason "voted" to side with the property management company. Thus, they always seem to have a slight plurality of votes and win any decisions.
They also made it very difficult for new homeowners to be voted onto the board because the old board members are automatically on the ballot, while new owners have to be "write on" candidates. Write-ons hardly ever win. I suspect that there are improprieties/under the table stuff going on between the board members and the HOA but cannot prove it.
Bottom line: homeowners are forced to pay these outrageous HOA dues/special assessments or face foreclosure while this HOA company is lining there pockets and laughing all the way to the bank. Condos in our complex are foreclosed left and right depressing home values leading to a death spiral. Meanwhile, hard working honest homeowners are trying to feed families and keep a roofs over our heads.
I called the state Fair Housing Commission and LA Dept Real Estate, and they just send me in circles.
Help. PLEASE. Any legitimate suggestions truly appreciated.